Which Plastics Should You Avoid Reusing?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The world is awash in plastic, a material lauded for its convenience and versatility, but increasingly recognized for its environmental and health impacts. While recycling efforts are crucial, an equally important aspect of responsible plastic use is understanding which types are safe for reuse and which should be avoided. This article delves into the world of plastics, specifically focusing on those that pose potential health risks when reused. In short, plastic #1 (PET or PETE) is the primary culprit that should not be reused.
The Problematic Plastics: A Closer Look
Plastic #1: Polyethylene Terephthalate (PET or PETE)
You’ll find plastic #1, or PET, everywhere – in disposable water, soda, and juice bottles. While this plastic is considered safe for single-use applications, the same cannot be said for reuse. Here’s why:
- Potential for Leaching: Repeated use can cause PET to degrade, increasing the risk of chemicals leaching into your beverage or food. While the term “leaching” may sound harmless, it means the transfer of substances, including potential toxins, from the plastic into whatever is in contact with it. Although PET is considered inert, repeated use can weaken its structure.
- Bacterial Growth: Plastic #1 bottles are notoriously difficult to clean thoroughly. The porous nature of the plastic can harbor bacteria and fungi in microscopic cracks and crevices, even after washing. This risk of bacterial contamination multiplies with every reuse.
- Not Designed for Multiple Uses: Single-use plastic bottles are designed for one-time use and not to withstand the wear and tear of washing and refilling. This makes them vulnerable to physical degradation and more likely to leach chemicals.
Other Problematic Plastics: A Note on #6 and #7
While #1 is the primary concern for reuse, it’s also wise to be cautious about plastics #6 (polystyrene) and #7 (other).
- Plastic #6 (Polystyrene or PS): Commonly known as Styrofoam, this plastic is used in foam containers, disposable cups, and packing materials. It is generally not considered food safe for reuse due to its tendency to break down and leach chemicals. Furthermore, #6 plastic is extremely difficult to recycle, adding to the environmental burden.
- Plastic #7 (Other): This is a catch-all category that includes a mix of plastics that aren’t #1 through #6. A notable member of this category is polycarbonate (PC), which contains bisphenol-A (BPA), a known endocrine disruptor. Avoid reusing any #7 plastic especially for food and beverages, as it is hard to ascertain which plastics fall into this category, and if they’re safe. Specifically, avoid polycarbonate for drink containers, choosing glass or unlined stainless steel instead.
The Safest Plastics to Reuse
Not all plastics are created equal. Some, like #2 (HDPE), #4 (LDPE), and #5 (PP) are generally considered safe for reuse under normal conditions, provided they are not showing any signs of wear.
Plastic #2: High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE)
Plastic #2, or HDPE, is robust and has a high strength-to-density ratio, resulting in excellent wear resistance. It is commonly used for milk jugs, detergent bottles, and some food storage containers. HDPE is considered safe for reuse and can withstand both heating and freezing.
Plastic #4: Low-Density Polyethylene (LDPE)
Plastic #4, or LDPE, is found in grocery bags, bread bags, and squeezable bottles. Like HDPE, LDPE is considered safe for food contact and reuse.
Plastic #5: Polypropylene (PP)
Plastic #5, or PP, is known for its heat resistance and is frequently used in food storage containers, yogurt tubs, and medicine bottles. It is generally considered the safest plastic for reuse, even when exposed to warm or hot water.
Understanding Recycling Labels: Beyond the Numbers
The numbers inside the recycling symbol don’t guarantee that a plastic item is recyclable in your area. These numbers are resin codes that help factories sort plastics for recycling, but local recycling programs will have their own specific rules on what is accepted. Many plastics, even with numbers, end up in landfills.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are 15 common questions about plastic reuse and recycling, offering further insight into best practices.
1. Why is reusing plastic #1 (PET) so widely discouraged?
Reusable plastic bottles that are #1 have not been manufactured to withstand long term reuse. They’re not designed to be cleaned easily, which allows bacteria to thrive in microscopic crevices and cracks, even after washing, and their chemical stability decreases with repeated use and potential exposure to heat.
2. Can I sterilize plastic to make it safe for reuse?
While sanitizing with bleach solutions or alcohol can kill bacteria, it won’t reverse the structural changes caused by wear and tear or repeated washing. The plastic will still be more prone to leaching chemicals. Additionally, not all plastics are created to withstand high temperatures. Using boiling water to sanitize may alter the shape of the plastic or cause chemicals to leach out quicker.
3. Is it safe to put boiling water in plastic #5 containers?
Generally yes, Plastic #5 (PP) is considered to be the most heat resistant of all plastics, making it unlikely to leach when exposed to warm or hot water. That being said, it is advised not to use boiling water as a rule as there is still a slight chance of chemicals leaching.
4. What about plastic ice cream containers? Can I reuse them?
Yes, most ice cream containers are made from food-grade plastic and are safe to reuse. They are generally made from plastic #5, which is safe for food storage.
5. Are Gatorade bottles safe to reuse?
While Gatorade bottles are made from recyclable plastic (usually #1), they are considered disposable and not designed for reuse due to cleaning difficulties and potential distortion when exposed to high heat. They should also be avoided because they are often made of PET #1.
6. Why are some plastics not recyclable?
Each type of resin melts at a different temperature. Manufacturing facilities are set up to take only specific resin types. Even different resins with the same number may not be compatible for recycling. For example, #6 polystyrene (Styrofoam) is notoriously difficult to recycle because of its bulkiness and high air content.
7. What are some safe alternatives to plastic for food and beverages?
Glass and unlined stainless steel are the best alternatives to plastic for drink containers. For food storage, consider glass containers, beeswax wraps, and stainless steel containers.
8. Is there such a thing as “biodegradable” plastic?
Some plastics are labeled as “biodegradable,” but this doesn’t mean they break down easily in a landfill or composting environment. Many require specific industrial composting conditions. It’s better to focus on using less plastic and choosing durable, reusable alternatives.
9. Why is #6 plastic so problematic?
#6 plastic (Polystyrene), which is commonly known as Styrofoam, is not widely recyclable and is difficult to reprocess. It also breaks down easily and can leach chemicals. Foam polystyrene is mostly air making it inefficient to recycle.
10. What are the environmental impacts of plastic reuse and recycling?
While recycling reduces the need for new plastic production, it’s not a perfect system. The overall energy consumption and emissions required to transport, sort, and reprocess plastics also have an environmental footprint. Reusing durable plastics like #2, #4, and #5 is better in theory, but not always in practice, due to potential contamination issues.
11. Is it true that most plastic cannot be recycled?
Yes, it is. The majority of plastic is not actually recycled. Due to the limited infrastructures and financial reasons, a great deal of plastic is sent to landfills. Many plastic products, such as flexible plastic, soft plastics and film plastics, are not accepted in recycling programs.
12. Why do plastics have numbers inside the triangle symbol?
These numbers are resin codes, not recycling symbols. They identify the type of plastic resin used, helping recycling plants sort the plastics. This number doesn’t guarantee that the plastic is recyclable in your area.
13. Why is plastic cutlery so problematic for the environment?
Plastic cutlery is a major threat to sea turtles, birds and other marine animals. They are often found in waterways and can cause serious internal injuries and poisoning.
14. How can I reduce my plastic consumption overall?
Start by avoiding single-use plastics such as straws, plastic bags, and disposable coffee cups. Opt for reusable alternatives, buy in bulk to reduce packaging, and be mindful of your choices.
15. What is the “great plastic lie”?
The “great plastic lie” refers to the misleading marketing campaigns by big plastic producers that promoted recycling as a solution to plastic waste. These campaigns shifted responsibility to the consumer, while the industry was aware that recycling would never be sufficient.
Conclusion
Understanding which plastics to avoid reusing is an important step in protecting your health and the environment. By being informed about the risks associated with plastic #1 and being aware of the benefits of safely reusing #2, #4 and #5, we can all become more responsible consumers. Remember, when in doubt, opt for durable, reusable materials like glass and stainless steel.