Delving into the Ancient Tomes: What Sets Are Legal in Old School MTG?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The siren song of Old School Magic: The Gathering beckons players back to a simpler, rawer time. Before planeswalkers dominated the meta and complexity reigned supreme, there was a glorious era of big mana, powerful artifacts, and unforgiving strategies. But what exactly is legal in this nostalgic format? The answer, while seemingly simple, comes with nuances depending on the specific Old School ruleset you’re playing.
Generally speaking, the core of Old School Magic centers around the sets released between 1993 and 1994. This means the following sets are the foundation of nearly every Old School format:
- Alpha (Limited Print Run)
- Beta (Unlimited Print Run)
- Unlimited Edition
- Revised Edition
- Arabian Nights
- Antiquities
- Legends
- The Dark
- Fallen Empires
However, remember that some Old School groups will alter the legality of sets. For example, some groups exclude Fallen Empires due to its perceived power level or design aesthetic that differs from the early sets. Always check with your local playgroup or tournament organizer to confirm the specific rules they are using. Now, let’s dive into the frequently asked questions to clarify more.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the most common Old School MTG format?
The most popular version is often referred to as “93/94“. This format strictly limits the legal sets to those printed in 1993 and 1994, as outlined above. There are also Swedish and Eternal Central variations.
Are there any banned or restricted cards in Old School?
Absolutely! Most Old School rulesets include a list of banned and/or restricted cards. A restricted card can only be included as a single copy in your deck. Common examples of restricted cards include:
- Ancestral Recall
- Black Lotus
- Time Walk
- Timetwister
- Mox Emerald, Jet, Pearl, Ruby, Sapphire
- Sol Ring
Banned cards are completely illegal for use. Specific banned lists vary, but cards like Chaos Orb (due to dexterity issues) and cards that never had a paper printing like the arena promos are often on the banned list.
Why are some cards restricted instead of banned?
The goal of restriction is to temper the power level of certain cards without completely eliminating them from the format. This allows for more diverse deckbuilding options and keeps the spirit of Old School alive while preventing a single card from dominating the metagame.
What is the “Mana Burn” rule in Old School?
The Mana Burn rule, a relic of the early days of Magic, states that any unspent mana at the end of a phase deals damage to the player who controlled that mana. While no longer part of modern Magic, it is a staple of nearly all Old School formats, adding another layer of strategy and risk to mana management.
Are reprint sets like Chronicles legal in Old School?
No, sets like Chronicles, which reprinted cards from earlier expansions, are generally not legal in Old School. The focus is on the original printings from the designated sets (Alpha through Fallen Empires in the most common format).
Can I use foreign language versions of cards in Old School?
This typically depends on the tournament organizer or your playgroup’s preferences. Some groups are strict about using English-language cards only, while others allow foreign language versions as long as the card’s identity is clearly identifiable. It’s always best to check beforehand.
What about cards like Arena and Sewers of Estark?
Arena and Sewers of Estark are promos from 1994 Book. As such, they aren’t usually legal in Old School MTG.
What are some popular Old School deck archetypes?
Old School boasts a variety of exciting and powerful archetypes. Some of the most popular include:
- The Deck: A control strategy using cards like Disenchant, Swords to Plowshares, and Wrath of God
- Mono-Black Control: Employing cards like Demonic Tutor, Mind Twist, and The Abyss to disrupt opponents and gain control.
- Atog Aggro: Leveraging the power of Atog and cheap artifacts to quickly deal damage.
- Naya Zoo: An aggressive deck featuring efficient creatures from Red, White and Green.
- 4C Control: A rainbow control deck that uses a combination of removal and counterspells alongside powerful threats.
Where can I find Old School tournaments and playgroups?
Online communities and local game stores are excellent resources for finding Old School playgroups. Search for “Old School MTG” on social media platforms and online forums. Many cities have established Old School communities that host regular events.
Are proxies allowed in Old School?
The allowance of proxies varies widely depending on the playgroup or tournament organizer. Some groups embrace proxies to make the format more accessible, while others strictly prohibit them. Always confirm the proxy policy before participating in any Old School event.
What is the Swedish Old School ruleset?
The Swedish ruleset is similar to the standard 93/94 format, but with its own specific banned and restricted list. It often features a slightly different metagame due to these variations. It also only allows white-bordered cards, so only the Unlimited and Revised editions are allowed.
What is the Eternal Central Old School ruleset?
The Eternal Central ruleset is another popular variation. It features a unique banned and restricted list, designed to foster a diverse and balanced metagame. It has several differences to the Swedish and 93/94 lists.
Is Power 9 really as powerful as everyone says?
Yes, absolutely! The “Power Nine” (Black Lotus, Ancestral Recall, Time Walk, Timetwister, Mox Emerald, Mox Jet, Mox Pearl, Mox Ruby, Mox Sapphire) are incredibly powerful cards that provide significant advantages in terms of mana acceleration, card draw, and tempo. Their cost reflects their rarity and desirability.
What is the appeal of playing Old School Magic?
Old School Magic offers a unique and nostalgic experience. It’s a chance to revisit the roots of the game, experience the raw power of early card design, and engage in a slower, more strategic style of play. The smaller card pool fosters greater deckbuilding creativity and rewards players who understand the format’s intricacies.
Where can I learn more about the history of Magic: The Gathering?
Organizations like the Games Learning Society provide valuable resources and research related to the history and cultural impact of games, including Magic: The Gathering. You can visit their website at GamesLearningSociety.org for more information.