When to Stop Using Hex Crawls in 5e
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
You should consider stopping a hex crawl in your 5e game when it no longer serves the narrative, becomes repetitive and unenjoyable for the players, or when the story necessitates a more focused and directed approach. This might happen when the party reaches a significant plot point, discovers a key location, or when player engagement wanes due to the inherent openness and potential for aimlessness of hex crawling.
Why Hex Crawls are Great (and Why They’re Not)
Hex crawls are a fantastic tool for sandbox campaigns, offering players unparalleled freedom to explore and discover the world at their own pace. They encourage player agency, reward curiosity, and allow for emergent storytelling as the party stumbles upon hidden locations, encounters unique monsters, and shapes the world through their actions. The feeling of charting unknown territory and uncovering secrets is a powerful draw for many players.
However, hex crawls aren’t a one-size-fits-all solution. Their strength – open-ended exploration – can also be their weakness. If not carefully managed, hex crawls can lead to:
- Lack of Direction: Players can feel lost and unsure of what to do next, leading to decision paralysis and frustration.
- Repetitive Encounters: Rolling for random encounters every day can become tedious, especially if the encounters are uninspired or don’t contribute to the overall narrative.
- Slow Pace: Traveling across vast stretches of wilderness can take up significant game time, potentially bogging down the story’s momentum.
- Disconnection from the Main Plot: The freedom of a hex crawl can sometimes distract players from the central storyline, making it difficult to maintain a sense of urgency or purpose.
Signs It’s Time to Move On
Recognizing when a hex crawl has run its course is crucial for maintaining player engagement and ensuring the campaign continues to progress in a satisfying way. Here are some key indicators:
- Decreased Player Enthusiasm: Are players becoming less excited about exploring new hexes? Are they starting to express a desire for more directed storytelling? This is a strong signal that the hex crawl may be losing its appeal.
- Lack of Meaningful Discoveries: If the party has spent a considerable amount of time exploring and consistently finding only mundane encounters or irrelevant locations, the sense of discovery that makes hex crawls enjoyable is likely diminished.
- Plot Convergence: Has the party discovered a key location related to the main plot? Are they about to confront a major villain? These moments often signal a shift in focus away from open exploration and towards more plot-driven events.
- Reaching a Defined Goal: Perhaps the party set out on the hex crawl to map a specific region or find a lost artifact. Once they achieve their objective, continuing the hex crawl may feel pointless.
- The Story Demands it: Sometimes, the narrative itself requires a more focused approach. A looming threat, a ticking clock, or a sudden crisis might necessitate abandoning the leisurely pace of a hex crawl in favor of a more urgent and directed course of action.
Transitioning Out of a Hex Crawl
Moving away from a hex crawl doesn’t have to be abrupt or jarring. Here are a few strategies for transitioning smoothly:
- Introduce a Time-Sensitive Quest: Present the players with a mission that requires them to reach a specific location within a limited time frame. This provides a clear objective and a sense of urgency, guiding them away from aimless exploration.
- Focus on a Particular Location: Direct the party’s attention to a specific town, dungeon, or landmark. Provide compelling reasons for them to investigate this location, shifting the focus from the overall map to a more localized area.
- Introduce a New Faction or Threat: A powerful new faction emerging in the region or a sudden, widespread threat can disrupt the established order and force the party to take a more proactive role in addressing the problem.
- Use a Plot Hook: Introduce a compelling plot hook that leads the players down a specific path. This could be a mysterious message, a cryptic prophecy, or the discovery of a hidden artifact.
- Consider a Time Skip: If the hex crawl has become truly stagnant, consider using a time skip to advance the story and introduce new challenges or opportunities.
What to do After the Hex Crawl
The transition from a hex crawl opens up new possibilities for the campaign. Here are some potential directions to take the story:
- Political Intrigue: The party might become embroiled in the complex political machinations of a city or kingdom.
- Dungeon Delving: The party might embark on a series of expeditions to explore dangerous and rewarding dungeons.
- Faction Warfare: The party might choose to align themselves with a particular faction and participate in a larger conflict.
- Personal Quests: The players might focus on pursuing their individual character goals and backstories.
- Large-Scale Campaigns: The party might take on a grand quest to save the world from a powerful evil.
The key is to maintain the sense of player agency and choice that made the hex crawl enjoyable, while also providing a clear direction and compelling narrative.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is a hex crawl, exactly?
A hex crawl is a style of tabletop role-playing game campaign where the game world is represented as a map divided into hexagonal areas, or hexes. Players explore the world hex by hex, typically using a map to track their progress and encountering random or pre-determined events within each hex. It emphasizes exploration and discovery.
2. Is a hex crawl suitable for all player groups?
Not necessarily. Hex crawls are best suited for players who enjoy open-ended exploration, player agency, and emergent storytelling. Players who prefer a more structured and linear narrative might find hex crawls frustrating.
3. How long should a hex crawl typically last?
There’s no set duration. A hex crawl can last for a few sessions or for an entire campaign, depending on the scope of the campaign and the players’ interests. The important thing is to ensure it remains engaging and serves the overall narrative.
4. What if players want to continue exploring even after it seems like the hex crawl should end?
Listen to your players. If they’re still enjoying the exploration, consider introducing new mysteries, locations, or challenges to keep them engaged. Adapt the hex crawl to their interests and continue as long as it remains fun for everyone.
5. How do I prepare a good hex crawl?
Focus on creating a detailed and interesting world. Populate each hex with unique locations, encounters, and secrets. Consider the history, ecology, and factions of the region. Prepare random encounter tables and be ready to improvise.
6. What are some good resources for creating hex crawl maps and content?
There are many online tools and resources available, including map generators, random encounter tables, and pre-written hex crawl modules. Websites like Donjon and Watabou’s Procgen are helpful. Consider using tools like World Anvil or Obsidian to organize your notes.
7. How do I handle player travel time and resource management in a hex crawl?
Implement rules for travel speed, encumbrance, and resource consumption (food, water, etc.). Consider using a system for tracking days spent traveling and the supplies used each day. Random encounters can also deplete resources.
8. What if players get lost or disoriented during the hex crawl?
Provide opportunities for them to find landmarks, consult maps, or seek guidance from local NPCs. Consider using survival skills checks to help them navigate and avoid getting lost. A skilled cartographer in the party is invaluable!
9. Can I combine a hex crawl with a more traditional adventure path?
Yes! You can seamlessly integrate a hex crawl into a larger campaign by using it as a way to explore the region surrounding the main adventure site or to introduce side quests and optional challenges.
10. How do I handle player choices that significantly alter the hex crawl environment?
Embrace the consequences of player actions. If they destroy a village, that hex should reflect that change. If they make allies with a powerful faction, that faction’s influence should be felt throughout the region.
11. What are some common pitfalls to avoid when running a hex crawl?
Avoid repetitive encounters, aimless exploration, and a lack of clear goals. Ensure that the hex crawl contributes to the overall narrative and provides meaningful rewards for exploration.
12. How can I make random encounters more interesting?
Don’t just rely on combat encounters. Include encounters with friendly NPCs, strange phenomena, environmental hazards, or opportunities for role-playing and problem-solving. Consider the context of the hex when designing encounters.
13. Is it possible to run a hex crawl online?
Yes! Use online tools for mapping, dice rolling, and communication. Virtual tabletop platforms like Roll20 and Fantasy Grounds support hex maps and allow for easy tracking of player movement.
14. How do I encourage players to explore different areas of the hex map?
Tease interesting locations and rumors. Provide clues to hidden treasures or lost secrets in different regions. Offer rewards for exploring remote or dangerous areas.
15. What if my players completely ignore the hex crawl and want to do something else entirely?
Be flexible and adaptable. Listen to your players’ interests and adjust the campaign accordingly. If they’re not enjoying the hex crawl, consider shifting the focus to something else entirely. It is their game, after all.