Assassin’s Creed Valhalla: Decoding the Broder Dilemma – Who Gets the Viking Booty?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
So, you’ve found yourself in East Anglia, the mead is flowing, and suddenly you’re presented with the opportunity to… shall we say, fraternize with one of Oswald’s brothers, Broder or Brothir. The burning question, the one that keeps Vikings up at night (aside from raiding, of course): which brother do you sleep with in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla?
The somewhat anticlimactic, yet liberating answer is: It doesn’t matter! The game treats the outcome of this encounter as a lighthearted dalliance. There are no story repercussions, no relationship meters impacted, and no bad endings triggered. The developers essentially give you a free pass to indulge in a bit of Viking revelry with whichever brother tickles your fancy. The choice is purely based on your personal preference and which character you find more appealing, or perhaps which dialogue options are the most amusing. Assassin’s Creed Valhalla presents this scenario as a minor, inconsequential diversion. Enjoy it, or don’t, the fate of England remains unaffected.
The Beauty of Consequence-Free Viking Fun
Why does this choice not matter? Ubisoft seems to have designed certain romance options in Valhalla as low-stakes experiences. This allows players to explore the romantic inclinations of Eivor without fear of jeopardizing the main narrative or other, more significant relationships. Think of it as a Viking vacation fling – fun while it lasts, but ultimately transient. It also adds a touch of historical realism. Viking society, while having its own moral codes, often saw such encounters as less significant than long-term partnerships or political alliances.
Broder vs. Brothir: The Definitive (But Ultimately Meaningless) Showdown
So, if the choice doesn’t matter, how do you even choose? Let’s break down what little we know about each brother:
-
Broder: He’s often portrayed as the more overtly flirtatious and outgoing of the two. If you’re looking for a straightforward, no-nonsense encounter, Broder might be your guy (or gal, depending on your Eivor).
-
Brothir: He’s generally depicted as slightly more reserved. If you prefer a touch of mystery or a more subtle approach, Brothir might be the more appealing option.
Ultimately, the differences are minimal. Pick the one whose dialogue amuses you more, whose beard you prefer, or simply flip a coin!
The Broder Encounter in Context
This encounter happens within the context of the East Anglia storyline. The game is emphasizing the celebrations and feasting around the establishing of a new leader, and it fits the theme of Vikings being sexually liberated and progressive. It’s an example of how games can explore societal norms and values. To find out more about the educational impact of games, visit the Games Learning Society website: GamesLearningSociety.org.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Assassin’s Creed Valhalla Romances
1. Does sleeping with Broder/Brothir affect my relationship with Randvi?
No. As previously mentioned, this encounter has no impact on other, more significant relationships in the game, including Randvi. Your romance with Randvi is determined by separate choices and dialogue options during the main storyline.
2. Can I romance both Broder and Brothir?
Unfortunately, no. You are presented with a single opportunity to engage in a romantic encounter during the East Anglia questline, and the game only allows you to choose one of the brothers.
3. What are the long-term romance options in Valhalla?
The long-term romance options include:
- Randvi: Sigurd’s wife, but available later in the game if you navigate the relationship carefully.
- Petra: A hunter in your settlement.
- Potentially others, depending on how you define “long-term.”
4. Does choosing the “wrong” dialogue option ruin my chances with a character?
Sometimes. For major romance interests like Randvi, certain dialogue choices can negatively impact your chances. However, for minor flings like the Broder/Brothir encounter, dialogue options are primarily for flavor.
5. Can Eivor get married in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla?
No, there is no formal marriage mechanic in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla. Relationships are depicted through dialogue, cutscenes, and shared activities, but there is no actual marriage ceremony or legal commitment.
6. Can I cheat on my chosen romantic partner?
The game handles this in a somewhat ambiguous way. Sleeping with other characters outside of a committed relationship with someone like Randvi appears to have no negative consequences.
7. Is there same-sex romance in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla?
Yes! Eivor’s gender is fluid (you can switch between male and female Eivor at any time), and all romance options are available regardless of Eivor’s current gender.
8. How do I initiate a romance with Petra?
To romance Petra, you must first build the Hunter’s Shack in your settlement. Completing her quests and choosing the appropriate dialogue options will eventually lead to a romantic relationship.
9. What is the best romance option in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla?
This is subjective, but many players consider Petra to be the best option due to the lack of negative consequences and the natural progression of their relationship.
10. Can I romance Randvi without getting a bad ending?
Yes, it’s possible, but tricky! The safest approach is to initially choose the “I care for you as a friend” option when she first confesses her feelings. You can then pursue a romance with her after she and Sigurd separate.
11. Does Eivor ever lose an eye like Odin?
This is a complex question. Eivor does lose an eye twice in the game (during flashbacks as Havi and in Valhalla). However, they do not permanently lose an eye during the main storyline, despite being connected to Odin who is known for only having one eye.
12. What are Sigurd’s “strikes” that affect the ending?
Sigurd’s strikes are a series of choices you make throughout the game that influence the ending you receive. These include:
- Taking or leaving the treasure.
- Romancing Randvi before Sigurd and Randvi separate.
- Making certain decisions during the Fulke mission.
- Fighting with Dag.
- Siding with or against Sigurd during an argument in the longhouse.
13. Can I romance Soma?
Unfortunately, Soma is not a romance option in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla.
14. How old is Eivor during the main storyline?
Eivor is approximately 25 years old at the start of the main storyline in 872 CE.
15. Does it matter if I pick the wrong name when sleeping with Broder?
The scenario you describe, mixing up the names, does not happen in the game. The developers seem to have tried to keep the scenario straightforward. The Broder vs Brothir encounter is about experiencing the lighthearted side of Viking culture.
Final Thoughts
The choice of whether to sleep with Broder or Brothir in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla is a testament to the game’s ability to offer low-stakes choices that add flavor to the narrative without significantly impacting the overall story. So, embrace the Viking spirit, choose the brother who catches your eye, and enjoy the ride! There’s a whole world of stories to explore.