Which Dark Souls Game Takes the Longest to Beat? The Definitive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
If you’re plunging into the unforgiving world of the Dark Souls series, you’re likely bracing yourself for a challenge. But alongside the difficulty, another metric often pondered is the sheer time investment required. So, which Dark Souls game demands the most hours of your life? The answer, based on average completion times focusing on the main story, points towards Dark Souls II or Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin. While initial estimates and personal experiences may vary wildly, Dark Souls II tends to clock in longer due to its larger world, sprawling level design, and generally slower pace than other entries.
However, “longest” can be interpreted in several ways. Are we talking about the time to simply finish the main story? Or are we considering the time needed for 100% completion, including all optional areas, bosses, and achievements? The answer shifts depending on the metric. For pure main story completion, Dark Souls II and its updated version still often claim the top spot. But when factoring in everything, the differences become more nuanced.
This is where the discussion gets interesting. Let’s delve into the factors that contribute to play time in each game and address some common questions.
Diving Deeper: Factors Affecting Playtime
Several factors influence how long it takes to beat a Dark Souls game:
-
Player Skill: This is the most obvious factor. Experienced players familiar with the series mechanics will naturally progress much faster than newcomers. Knowing enemy attack patterns, optimal builds, and shortcuts drastically reduces playtime.
-
Playstyle: A cautious, methodical player who explores every nook and cranny will take considerably longer than someone who rushes through the main path.
-
Build Choice: Some builds are more efficient at dealing damage and surviving encounters, allowing for faster progression. A well-optimized build can significantly cut down on playtime.
-
Co-op: Playing with friends can speed up the process, especially in challenging areas or boss fights. However, it can also lead to distractions and increased playtime.
-
Game Design: The game’s level design, enemy placement, and overall difficulty heavily influence how long it takes to progress. Dark Souls II, in particular, is often cited for its intricate and sometimes frustrating level layouts, which can contribute to longer playtime.
-
Completionism: As previously mentioned, aiming for 100% completion drastically increases playtime. Collecting all items, defeating all bosses, and unlocking all achievements can easily double or even triple the time required to beat the main story.
Examining the Dark Souls Games Individually
Here’s a brief overview of each Dark Souls game and its approximate playtime:
-
Dark Souls: Prepared to Die Edition/Remastered: Generally considered to be shorter than Dark Souls II, with a main story completion time ranging from 26-105 hours, but more likely settling around 40-50 hours for a first-time player. The interconnected world and memorable boss fights contribute to its enduring appeal.
-
Dark Souls II/Scholar of the First Sin: This is the contender for the longest playtime. The base game and its updated version, Scholar of the First Sin, feature a sprawling world, numerous areas, and a slower combat pace. Completion times can range from 36-119 hours, with many players spending upwards of 50+ hours on a single playthrough.
-
Dark Souls III/The Fire Fades Edition: Arguably the shortest Dark Souls game in terms of main story completion. Its faster combat, more linear level design, and fewer optional areas contribute to a shorter overall playtime. Expect to spend 32-93 hours on a playthrough.
It’s important to reiterate that these are just estimations. Your personal experience may vary significantly depending on the factors mentioned above.
FAQs: Delving Deeper into Dark Souls Playtime
Q1: Is Elden Ring Longer than the Dark Souls Games?
While not a Dark Souls game, Elden Ring shares many similarities and is developed by FromSoftware. Elden Ring is a very large game that dwarfs the individual Dark Souls games.
Q2: Which Dark Souls Game is the Hardest? Does Difficulty Affect Playtime?
Difficulty is subjective, but Dark Souls II is often cited as the most challenging due to its unique mechanics, enemy placement, and sometimes unforgiving level design. This increased difficulty can certainly lead to longer playtime, as players may need to spend more time learning enemy patterns, finding optimal strategies, and overcoming obstacles.
Q3: Is Dark Souls II Longer Because It’s Harder?
Yes, to some extent. The increased difficulty in Dark Souls II can definitely contribute to longer playtime. However, it’s not just the difficulty; the game’s level design, enemy density, and slower combat pace all play a role in extending the overall playtime.
Q4: Is Dark Souls 1 Longer than Dark Souls 3?
Generally, Dark Souls 1 is slightly longer than Dark Souls 3. While Dark Souls 3 has a faster pace and more streamlined level design, Dark Souls 1 features a more interconnected world and a greater emphasis on exploration, which can add to the overall playtime.
Q5: Is Dark Souls 3 the Easiest Dark Souls Game?
Many players find Dark Souls 3 to be more accessible than its predecessors due to its faster combat, more linear level design, and generally more forgiving mechanics. However, it still presents a significant challenge, especially for newcomers to the series.
Q6: Does Playing Co-op Make the Game Shorter?
Yes, playing co-op can significantly reduce playtime, especially for challenging areas or boss fights. Having a teammate to share the burden and provide support can make the game much easier and faster to complete.
Q7: Is Dark Souls 2 Worth Playing if It’s the Longest?
Absolutely! Despite its length and sometimes controversial design choices, Dark Souls II offers a unique and rewarding experience. It features a vast world, numerous areas to explore, and a distinct atmosphere that sets it apart from other Dark Souls games.
Q8: How Many Hours Does It Take to 100% Dark Souls?
The time required to 100% a Dark Souls game varies greatly depending on the game and the player’s skill. On average, expect to spend anywhere from 80 to 150+ hours to achieve 100% completion in any of the Dark Souls games. For Dark Souls II, this number could be even higher.
Q9: Is Dark Souls 3 Better for Beginners?
Dark Souls 3 is often recommended for beginners due to its faster combat, more linear level design, and generally more forgiving mechanics. It provides a more accessible entry point to the series while still retaining the challenging gameplay that defines Dark Souls.
Q10: Why is Dark Souls 2 so Different?
Dark Souls 2 was directed by different people, the reasons for the changes can be found at GamesLearningSociety.org.
Q11: Is Dark Souls 2 Harder Than Dark Souls 1?
Many players find Dark Souls 2 to be harder than Dark Souls 1 due to its unique mechanics, enemy placement, and sometimes unforgiving level design. However, difficulty is subjective, and some players may find Dark Souls 1 to be more challenging.
Q12: Is Sekiro Harder Than Dark Souls?
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice, while also developed by FromSoftware, is a different beast entirely. Its combat is heavily focused on parrying and deflecting, which requires precise timing and quick reflexes. Many players find Sekiro to be more challenging than the Dark Souls games due to its demanding combat system.
Q13: Which Dark Souls Game Has the Best Level Design?
This is a matter of personal preference. Some players prefer the interconnected world of Dark Souls 1, while others appreciate the intricate and sprawling level design of Dark Souls II. Dark Souls 3 offers a more linear and streamlined experience, while Bloodborne features a Gothic-inspired world with a unique sense of atmosphere.
Q14: Is Dark Souls 3 a Good Ending to the Series?
Many fans consider Dark Souls 3 to be a fitting conclusion to the trilogy, as it brings closure to many of the series’ overarching themes and storylines. Its epic boss battles, stunning visuals, and satisfying gameplay make it a memorable and rewarding experience.
Q15: Does Build Variety Affect Playtime?
Yes, a well-optimized build can significantly cut down on playtime. Some builds are simply more efficient at dealing damage and surviving encounters than others. Experimenting with different builds and finding one that suits your playstyle can make the game much easier and faster to complete.
Final Thoughts
While the exact playtime for each Dark Souls game varies depending on individual factors, Dark Souls II generally takes the longest to beat, especially when aiming for 100% completion. However, each game offers a unique and rewarding experience, and the choice of which one to play depends on your personal preferences and playstyle. Regardless of which Dark Souls game you choose, be prepared for a challenging and unforgettable journey. Remember to embrace the difficulty, learn from your mistakes, and never give up.