Which Fish Best to Sell in Animal Crossing: New Horizons? Maximizing Your Bell Earnings
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of which fish are the most profitable to sell in Animal Crossing: New Horizons is a common one for players looking to amass wealth quickly. While the allure of rare catches might be strong, the true secret lies in understanding market dynamics and maximizing your opportunities. The short answer? Selling your fish to CJ, the otter, is the most lucrative approach. CJ buys fish at 150% of their normal selling price, making him the go-to choice whenever he visits your island. However, even with CJ on your side, some fish are inherently better earners than others. Let’s dive deeper into which finned friends can line your pockets.
Understanding the Fish Market
Before we delve into specific species, it’s essential to grasp how fish values work in New Horizons. Each fish has a base selling price at Nook’s Cranny. This is the price you’d receive from Timmy and Tommy. However, when CJ arrives (randomly), he offers 1.5x (or 150%) of that base price. This is a substantial increase and should always be your preferred selling method whenever possible.
The Importance of CJ
C.J. is the single most important factor when determining the best fish to sell. Even relatively common fish become far more profitable when sold to him. It’s therefore wise to stash fish away in your home storage or a designated holding area when you aren’t sure if CJ is arriving that day. This way, when he does visit, you’re prepared for a bell bonanza.
Top Fish for Profitability
While CJ’s markup makes most fish worth selling, some stand out for their high base prices. Here are some of the top fish to focus on, especially when CJ is around:
- Sharks: Any shark with its distinctive fin is a strong bet. The Great White Shark is particularly valuable and recognizable.
- Oarfish: This enormous fish commands a high price and is easily recognized by its massive shadow.
- Coelacanth: This prehistoric fish is both rare and valuable. Though difficult to catch, it’s worth the effort.
- Mahi-Mahi: Another high-value fish, often found near the pier.
- Tuna: Pier-specific and seasonal, but worth the effort when available.
- Blue Marlin: Another pier-exclusive that fetches a good price.
Beyond the Rare
While rare fish are great for big payouts, don’t overlook the common ones! With CJ’s 1.5x multiplier, even a Red Snapper (base 3,000 bells) becomes a decent 4,500 bell earner. Focus on collecting multiple specimens of all fish when CJ is around and you’ll maximize your profits.
Fishing Strategies for Max Profit
To effectively fill your pockets, you need a solid strategy. Here are a few tips:
- Fish Bait: Crafting and using fish bait is key. This allows you to spawn fish near you, drastically increasing your catch rate and chances of getting valuable ones. The pier is a prime spot to use bait since many rare fish like tuna and marlin spawn there.
- Time of Day: Be aware that fish spawns change by time of day and seasons. Some fish are only available at night, some only during the day, and others only during specific months. Check your Critterpedia to plan your fishing trips.
- Fin Watch: Keep an eye out for fish with fins, these are almost always sharks, which are highly profitable. They can be spotted before you cast your line.
Important Considerations
While selling is important for financial growth, remember:
- Museum Donations: Always donate the first of each new fish you catch to the museum. It’s essential for completing your collection.
- Storage Space: Make sure you have adequate storage to stash fish while waiting for CJ. An extra storage shed is a huge benefit.
The Best Approach
The best approach is a combination of focused fishing for high-value fish and diligently selling to CJ when he’s present on your island. Never sell to Timmy and Tommy if you can help it when CJ is on island. By following these tips and carefully choosing when and how to sell, you will steadily increase your Bell earnings in Animal Crossing: New Horizons.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Does CJ buy sea creatures?
No, CJ will not buy sea creatures that you caught by diving. He only buys fish caught with a fishing rod.
2. What is the most expensive fish to sell in Animal Crossing: New Horizons?
The Oarfish is one of the most expensive fish, selling for 9,000 bells at Nook’s Cranny (13,500 bells with CJ). However, sharks like the Great White are also very valuable.
3. Are there times when CJ won’t buy my fish?
Yes, CJ will first ask you to complete a Seasports Challenge before he buys fish from you.
4. How do I know when CJ is visiting my island?
CJ will appear randomly on your island, just like other visitors. Check the island in the morning, or look at any signs the Nooklings may post. You’ll also see him wandering around.
5. Is it better to sell fish to CJ or Timmy & Tommy?
Absolutely CJ. He buys fish for 1.5 times the original price, making him far more profitable than Nook’s Cranny.
6. Should I always donate the first fish I catch?
Yes, if you’re aiming to complete your museum, always donate the first fish of every type.
7. What are the most profitable places to fish?
The sea generally yields the most expensive larger fish, especially along the coast and the pier area.
8. How often does CJ visit my island?
CJ visits randomly, so there’s no set schedule. Be patient and always check if he is on your island.
9. Can I sell fish to CJ if I traveled to another island?
Yes, you can sell fish caught on any island as long as CJ is visiting your island.
10. Is cooking profitable in Animal Crossing?
Cooking can be profitable when you sell the cooked food to Nook’s Cranny, but fish are generally more profitable on their own (especially with CJ).
11. What are the rarest fish in Animal Crossing?
Some of the rarest fish include the Coelacanth, Great White Shark, and Golden Trout. Rarity can also depend on the season.
12. What is the best way to find sharks?
Look for large shadows with fins in the ocean. Also, using fish bait can help spawn them faster.
13. What are some high-value, but less rare, fish?
The Red Snapper, Koi, and Ocean Sunfish are decent earners.
14. Are there specific times of day to catch certain fish?
Yes, many fish only appear at certain times. Check your Critterpedia for detailed information on each species.
15. Does selling furniture and materials make more money than fish?
While furniture and materials can be profitable, fish, especially when sold to CJ, are often the quickest and most reliable way to make bells. It’s about optimizing your time and focus.