Thorn vs. Lumina: A Guardian’s Guide to Choosing the Right Hand Cannon
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The age-old question for any seasoned Guardian facing the abyss: Thorn or Lumina? The answer, as with most things in Destiny 2, isn’t a simple one. It boils down to playstyle, team composition, and the activity you’re facing. Lumina is generally the better choice for team support and survivability, offering potent healing and a damage buff to allies. Thorn, on the other hand, excels in situations where sustained damage and self-reliance are paramount. While both share a dark past – Lumina being the cleansed form of the original Thorn – their current roles couldn’t be more different. Deciding which to wield depends entirely on understanding their unique strengths and weaknesses.
Understanding the Darkness and the Light: A Deep Dive into Thorn and Lumina
To truly grasp the differences, let’s dissect each hand cannon’s intrinsic perks and overall utility.
Thorn: The Poisonous Embrace
Thorn is the epitome of a selfish, yet highly effective, weapon. Its core identity revolves around applying Mark of the Devourer, a damage-over-time effect that lingers on targets.
- Mark of the Devourer: This is Thorn’s bread and butter. Rounds fired from Thorn pierce targets, inflicting a persistent poison damage effect. This not only deals damage but also hinders enemy healing and shields.
- Remnants: Kills with Thorn leave behind remnants that, when collected, strengthen Mark of the Devourer and partially refill the magazine. This creates a powerful feedback loop, encouraging aggressive gameplay and rewarding skilled aim.
- Crucible Dominance: In the Crucible, Mark of the Devourer can be devastating. It can weaken opponents, allowing for easier cleanups by teammates or a swift two-tap kill if the poison stacks high enough. This makes Thorn a popular choice for aggressive players who enjoy controlling engagements.
Thorn thrives in situations where you can consistently land shots and maintain a high uptime on Mark of the Devourer. It’s excellent for clearing waves of weaker enemies and applying pressure to tougher foes.
Lumina: The Guiding Light
Lumina is the antithesis of Thorn, a symbol of Light and support. Its primary function is to heal and empower allies, making it an invaluable asset to any fireteam.
- Noble Rounds: Kills with Lumina leave behind remnants. Absorbing these remnants transforms your next hip-fired shot into a Noble Round, which seeks out and heals allies.
- Blessing of the Sky: When a Noble Round hits an ally, it not only heals them but also grants both the shooter and the healed ally a damage buff. This creates a powerful synergy, increasing the overall damage output of the team.
- Team Synergy: Lumina is designed for coordinated gameplay. Its effectiveness relies on communication and teamwork. A skilled Lumina user can keep their team alive and significantly boost their damage, making it perfect for raids, dungeons, and Nightfalls.
Lumina excels in challenging activities where survivability and coordinated damage are key. It’s a must-have for support players who prioritize the well-being of their team. Games Learning Society highlights the importance of teamwork and strategy in achieving success, a principle perfectly embodied by Lumina’s design. You can find more about their insights at GamesLearningSociety.org.
Thorn vs. Lumina: A Head-to-Head Comparison
Now, let’s break down the key differences between Thorn and Lumina across various aspects of gameplay.
- Damage: Thorn deals consistent, lingering damage through Mark of the Devourer. Lumina’s damage buff, Blessing of the Sky, amplifies the damage of both the shooter and the healed ally. While Thorn provides consistent self-sufficiency damage, Lumina offers potential for much higher overall damage through team coordination.
- Healing: Thorn provides no direct healing. Lumina is a dedicated healing weapon, providing significant health regeneration to allies with each Noble Round. This makes Lumina far superior in terms of survivability for the team.
- Ease of Use: Thorn is relatively straightforward to use. Its effectiveness depends on accurate aim and consistent application of Mark of the Devourer. Lumina requires more coordination and awareness, as you need to prioritize healing allies and positioning yourself to collect remnants.
- Situational Awareness: Thorn benefits from an aggressive playstyle, focusing on individual engagements. Lumina demands a broader awareness of the battlefield, keeping track of ally health and positioning to maximize healing and damage output.
- PVE: In PVE content, Lumina will take the win over thorn. Thorn is good for killing lower level enemies with its mark of the devourer but falls off at higher tier enemies due to a longer time to kill and need for constant reloads. Lumina excels due to the healing it can provide and with coordinated groups, the increase in damage output due to blessing of the sky.
- PVP: The win goes to Thorn in this scenario. With thorn you are able to kill enemies then pickup the remnant to reload the weapon for a follow up attack. This allows you to play very aggressively, but with the help of the poison, you are able to two tap enemies with high damage over time.
Choosing the Right Tool for the Job
Ultimately, the choice between Thorn and Lumina depends on your personal preference and the specific circumstances of the encounter.
- Choose Thorn if: You prefer a self-sufficient, aggressive playstyle; you excel at landing shots and maintaining consistent damage; you need to clear waves of weaker enemies quickly; you want to apply pressure to tougher foes in PvP.
- Choose Lumina if: You enjoy playing a support role; you prioritize the survivability and damage output of your team; you are facing challenging content that requires coordinated teamwork; you want to contribute to the overall success of the fireteam.
Conclusion: Embracing the Light and the Darkness
Both Thorn and Lumina are powerful hand cannons with unique strengths and weaknesses. There is no objectively “better” weapon. The key is to understand their individual capabilities and choose the one that best suits your playstyle and the needs of your team. Whether you embrace the poisonous embrace of Thorn or the guiding light of Lumina, both weapons can be formidable tools in the hands of a skilled Guardian.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is the best overall exotic hand cannon in Destiny 2?
This is subjective and depends on the player’s playstyle and the current meta. However, popular choices include Ace of Spades for its versatility, Eriana’s Vow for its anti-barrier capabilities, and The Last Word for its close-quarters dominance.
2. Is Ace of Spades better than Thorn?
Generally, Ace of Spades is considered a more versatile and well-rounded hand cannon than Thorn. Its Memento Mori perk provides a significant damage boost without requiring remnants, and its radar remains active while aiming down sights. However, Thorn’s Mark of the Devourer can be devastating in the right hands.
3. Can Lumina heal yourself?
No, Noble Rounds from Lumina can only heal allies. You cannot target yourself with the healing projectiles.
4. Is Thorn good for Crucible?
Yes, Thorn can be very effective in the Crucible. Its Mark of the Devourer can weaken opponents and allow for easy cleanups, and collecting remnants provides a damage boost. However, it requires accurate aim and an aggressive playstyle to truly shine.
5. What does Thorn do in Destiny 2?
Thorn applies Mark of the Devourer, a damage-over-time effect, to targets. Kills with Thorn leave behind remnants that strengthen Mark of the Devourer and partially refill the magazine.
6. Did Thorn become Lumina?
Yes, Lumina was originally the Thorn used by Dredgen Yor. The weapon was cleansed and transformed into a symbol of Light.
7. Are Thorn and Lumina the same gun?
Yes, Lumina was once the original Thorn. However, the Thorns that other Guardians wield are mere replicas.
8. Is Sunshot still good in 2024?
Sunshot can still be fun to use. The hand cannon has its explosions and provides fun gameplay. However, in today’s meta, there are better guns to use.
9. What is Shaxx’s hand cannon?
Shaxx’s hand cannon is Imago Loop.
10. Does Thorn have a catalyst?
Yes, Thorn now has a catalyst in Destiny 2. The catalyst improves the weapon’s Range and Stability.
11. Is Igneous Hammer still obtainable in 2024?
Yes, Igneous Hammer is still obtainable in 2024 through Trials of Osiris.
12. Which exotic hand cannon is the easiest to get?
Exotic hand cannons have different methods to get them. Some are simple missions while others are from luck.
13. What is higher than Ace of Spades?
In most standard card games, nothing is inherently higher than an Ace. However, in certain games with Jokers, a Joker card might outrank the Ace.
14. What’s the difference between Thorn and Rose?
Rose is the base weapon from which both Thorn and Lumina were created. Thorn represents the corrupted form of Rose, while Lumina is the cleansed version.
15. What Hand Cannon is better for solo play, Thorn or Lumina?
Thorn is generally better for solo play. While Lumina can be useful for survivability in niche situations by healing allies, Thorn allows you to kill enemies at a faster rate and collect remnants to keep the weapon running.