Mending vs. Unbreaking: The Ultimate Minecraft Durability Showdown
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Which is better: Mending or Unbreaking? The definitive answer, for most situations in Minecraft, is Mending. While Unbreaking extends the lifespan of your items, Mending offers near-infinite durability by repairing items with experience points (XP). However, the choice isn’t always so straightforward. The “best” enchantment truly depends on the item, your playstyle, and your access to resources. Let’s delve into the nuances of each enchantment to help you make the right choice.
Understanding Mending
Mending is a treasure enchantment, meaning it can’t be directly applied via an enchanting table. Instead, you’ll need to acquire a Mending book through fishing, trading with villagers, or finding it as loot in dungeons, mineshafts, or strongholds.
When applied to an item, Mending utilizes XP orbs collected by the player to repair the item’s durability. The repair rate is two durability points restored per one XP point. Any excess XP beyond what’s needed to fully repair the item goes towards the player’s experience bar.
Benefits of Mending
- Near-Infinite Durability: With a reliable source of XP (mob farms, mining, etc.), your Mending-enchanted items will effectively last forever.
- Convenience: No need to manually repair items on an anvil, saving you resources and time.
- Versatility: Mending can be applied to a wide range of items, including tools, weapons, armor, and even Elytra.
Drawbacks of Mending
- Availability: Obtaining Mending books can be challenging, requiring patience and luck.
- Experience Dependency: Mending is useless without a consistent source of XP. If you’re exploring in areas where XP is scarce, your item’s durability can still deplete.
- Incompatibility with Infinity: Mending is mutually exclusive with the Infinity enchantment on bows. This is a crucial factor to consider for ranged combat enthusiasts.
Understanding Unbreaking
Unbreaking is a standard enchantment that can be applied to items through an enchanting table. Its effect is simple: it increases the item’s durability by giving it a chance to not lose durability when used.
The Unbreaking enchantment comes in three levels, with each level increasing the chance of avoiding durability loss. The average lifespan of an item with Unbreaking is increased by a factor of (level+1). So, Unbreaking I doubles the durability, Unbreaking II triples it, and Unbreaking III quadruples it.
Benefits of Unbreaking
- Increased Durability: Extends the lifespan of your items, reducing the frequency of repairs.
- Easy to Obtain: Unbreaking can be easily obtained through enchanting tables.
- Cost-Effective Early Game: Before you have reliable access to XP farms, Unbreaking can be a great way to make your early-game tools last longer.
- Compatibility: Unbreaking works well with many other enchantments and doesn’t have the compatibility issues that Mending does.
Drawbacks of Unbreaking
- Limited Lifespan: Even with Unbreaking III, your items will eventually break, requiring repair or replacement.
- Repair Costs: Repairing Unbreaking-enchanted items on an anvil can become expensive, especially with multiple enchantments.
- Less Efficient in the Late Game: Once you have established XP farms, the benefits of Unbreaking are significantly diminished compared to Mending.
Mending vs. Unbreaking: A Detailed Comparison
Here’s a breakdown of when Mending is superior and when Unbreaking might be a better choice:
When Mending is the Best Choice
- High-Value Items: Netherite tools, armor, and Elytra are ideal candidates for Mending. Their high resource cost makes preserving them a priority.
- Late-Game Scenarios: When you have consistent access to XP through mob farms or other means, Mending provides practically limitless durability.
- Items with High Repair Costs: Mending eliminates the need to constantly repair expensive items on an anvil.
When Unbreaking is a Good Option
- Early-Game Tools: Before establishing XP farms, Unbreaking can significantly extend the lifespan of your initial tools.
- Resource-Constrained Environments: If XP is scarce, Unbreaking can help your tools last longer between repairs.
- Specific Item Builds: Unbreaking is a great option when a high level bow is not required, but something is still needed for short term survivability and/or when there are no villager trades available to get a Mending book.
The Bow Dilemma: Mending vs. Infinity
The bow presents a unique situation due to the incompatibility between Mending and Infinity. Infinity allows you to fire an unlimited number of arrows as long as you have at least one arrow in your inventory. For many players, this is incredibly convenient.
If you choose Infinity, you’ll want to pair it with Unbreaking to extend the bow’s lifespan. If you opt for Mending, you’ll need to manage your arrow supply carefully but benefit from near-infinite durability.
The “better” choice for a bow depends on your playstyle. If you prefer the convenience of unlimited arrows, go with Infinity and Unbreaking. If you’re comfortable managing arrows and have a good XP source, Mending is the superior option. Some advanced players utilize skeleton farms, as mentioned on GamesLearningSociety.org, for both arrows and experience, making Mending a very viable option.
The Power of Combining Mending and Unbreaking
For many items, the ideal solution is to combine both Mending and Unbreaking III. This provides the best of both worlds: increased durability from Unbreaking and near-infinite lifespan from Mending. However, this is not always the most cost-effective solution depending on your enchanting setup.
Conclusion
While Mending is generally the superior enchantment for most items in Minecraft, Unbreaking still has its place, especially in the early game or when dealing with specific items like bows (when paired with Infinity). By understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each enchantment, you can make informed decisions to optimize the durability and longevity of your precious tools and armor. Always consider your current resources, playstyle, and the specific item you’re enchanting to make the best choice for your Minecraft adventure. Remember to check out Games Learning Society for more insights on Minecraft and game-based learning!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Can you have both Mending and Unbreaking on the same item?
Yes, Mending and Unbreaking can be applied to the same item, except for bows, where Mending conflicts with Infinity. Combining these enchantments provides the ultimate durability for your tools and armor.
2. Is Mending better than Unbreaking on a bow?
Generally, no. On a bow, Infinity and Unbreaking are typically preferred over Mending because Mending and Infinity are mutually exclusive. However, If you don’t mind managing arrows or have a good source of arrows via farms or trading, then Mending can be viable.
3. Does Unbreaking III make an item last forever?
No, Unbreaking III does not make an item last forever. It only increases the item’s durability by a factor of four on average. The item will still eventually break.
4. How do I get Mending?
Mending can be obtained through fishing, trading with librarian villagers, or finding it as loot in chests in dungeons, mineshafts, and strongholds.
5. What items should I put Mending on?
Mending is best applied to high-value items such as Netherite tools, armor, and Elytra. These items are expensive to craft and benefit greatly from the near-infinite durability provided by Mending.
6. Why isn’t my Mending pickaxe working?
Make sure you hold the Mending-enchanted item in your hand or have it equipped in your armor slots. Mending only repairs the item when you collect XP while it’s actively equipped or held.
7. What’s the best way to get XP for Mending?
Mob farms are an excellent source of XP for repairing Mending-enchanted items. Other good sources include mining, smelting, and trading with villagers.
8. Is it worth putting Unbreaking on a Gold pickaxe with Mending?
No, it is generally not worth putting Unbreaking on a Gold pickaxe, even with Mending. Gold tools have very low durability compared to other materials, making them inefficient for most tasks.
9. How much does Mending repair?
Mending repairs two durability points per one XP point collected.
10. Can Mending repair cursed items?
Yes, Mending can repair items with curses, such as Curse of Binding or Curse of Vanishing.
11. Does Mending work in the off-hand?
Yes, Mending works when the item is held in the off-hand.
12. What enchantments cannot go with Mending?
The only enchantment that cannot be combined with Mending is Infinity on a bow.
13. Is there a Mending II enchantment?
No, there is no Mending II enchantment in the base game.
14. Does Unbreaking add durability?
Unbreaking gives tools and armor a chance to not lose any durability in a situation where it normally would.
15. Is Mending worth it for armor?
Yes, Mending is definitely worth it for armor. Armor takes a lot of damage during combat, and Mending ensures that your valuable armor set stays in good condition indefinitely.