Dark Souls Showdown: Which Game Takes Longer, 1 or 2?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The age-old question, debated in the fiery pits of Lordran and the sun-drenched shores of Drangleic: Which Dark Souls game, the original or its sequel, demands more of your time? The answer, definitively, is Dark Souls 2 (including Scholar of the First Sin) is significantly longer than Dark Souls 1. While individual playthroughs can vary wildly based on player skill, playstyle, and completionist tendencies, the raw data and anecdotal evidence consistently point to a greater time commitment for the second installment. Let’s delve deeper into why this is the case and what factors contribute to this difference in playtime.
Why Dark Souls 2 Requires More Time
Several core design elements contribute to Dark Souls 2’s longer average completion time:
- Larger World and More Content: Dark Souls 2 features a more expansive map than its predecessor. While Dark Souls 1 boasts a beautifully interconnected world, Dark Souls 2 offers a greater number of distinct areas, many of which are quite large and intricate. This translates directly to more exploration, more enemy encounters, and more secrets to uncover.
- Enemy Placement and Ganks: Dark Souls 2 is notorious for its enemy placement, often throwing waves of enemies at the player in what many consider “gank squads.” While this design choice is controversial, it undeniably adds to the game’s length, forcing players to proceed with caution and potentially replay areas multiple times to overcome these challenging encounters.
- Adaptability and Agility: The introduction of the Adaptability stat, which influences Agility and thus affects i-frames during rolls, plays a crucial role. New players often find themselves struggling with the initial lack of i-frames, leading to more deaths and increased playtime while they figure out how to level this stat appropriately.
- Boss Runs and Difficulty Spikes: While the difficulty of Dark Souls is subjective, many find Dark Souls 2’s boss encounters, especially those in the DLC, to be particularly challenging. Coupled with longer runs to reach some bosses, this can significantly inflate playtime.
- Item Acquisition and Upgrade Paths: The process of obtaining and upgrading equipment in Dark Souls 2 can be more time-consuming than in Dark Souls 1. This is partly due to the scarcity of certain upgrade materials and the increased need to farm for them, especially when experimenting with different builds.
Analyzing Completion Time Estimates
Various sources offer estimates for completion times, and while these can fluctuate, they consistently show Dark Souls 2 requiring more hours:
- Main Story Completion: On average, a focused playthrough of Dark Souls 1, concentrating only on the main story, might take around 35-45 hours. Dark Souls 2, in contrast, generally requires 40-50 hours for a similar playthrough.
- Completionist Runs: For players aiming to achieve 100% completion, including all achievements, secret areas, and optional bosses, Dark Souls 1 can stretch to 60-80 hours. Dark Souls 2, however, can easily surpass 100 hours, potentially reaching 120 hours or more.
- Speedruns: Even speedruns, which optimize routes and gameplay, tend to be longer for Dark Souls 2 than for Dark Souls 1, further illustrating the game’s inherent length.
First-Timer Experience vs. Veteran Players
The difference in playtime between Dark Souls 1 and 2 is most pronounced for first-time players. The unfamiliarity with the game’s mechanics, enemy attack patterns, and world layout results in a steeper learning curve in Dark Souls 2. Veterans of the series, familiar with the Souls-like formula, might find the gap in playtime somewhat smaller, but Dark Souls 2’s increased scope and density still make it a longer experience overall.
Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin Considerations
It’s essential to consider the Scholar of the First Sin (SotFS) version of Dark Souls 2. SotFS features significant changes to enemy placement, item locations, and overall game balance. While SotFS is generally considered more challenging than the original Dark Souls 2, it doesn’t drastically alter the overall playtime. The increased difficulty might lead to more deaths and retries, but the core content and world size remain the same, meaning it is still longer than Dark Souls 1.
The Subjectivity of “Length”
It’s crucial to acknowledge the subjective nature of “length” in video games. A player who meticulously explores every nook and cranny of Lordran in Dark Souls 1 might spend more time in that game than someone who rushes through Drangleic in Dark Souls 2. However, when considering average completion times and the sheer volume of content, Dark Souls 2 consistently emerges as the longer experience. Ultimately, which one is more enjoyable or replayable is going to be up to the player.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Which Dark Souls game is considered the hardest?
The difficulty of Dark Souls is subjective and often debated, but generally, Dark Souls 2 is considered the most mechanically punishing, while Dark Souls 1 has some of the most iconic and challenging boss fights. Each game offers unique challenges that cater to different playstyles.
2. Is Dark Souls 2 harder than Elden Ring?
While Elden Ring offers numerous tools to overcome challenges, including Spirit Ashes, its late-game bosses are notoriously difficult. On average, Elden Ring is considered more difficult.
3. Can I play Dark Souls 2 without playing Dark Souls 1?
Yes, you can play Dark Souls 2 without having played Dark Souls 1. The stories are largely independent, although Dark Souls 2 builds on the lore and themes established in the first game.
4. Which Dark Souls game has the best story?
Bloodborne is considered by many to have the best story, due to its extensive and detailed lore.
5. Are Dark Souls 1 and Dark Souls 2 connected?
Yes, the story of DS2 is definitely built on the foundation of DS1. In DS2, Nashandra, Elana, Nadalia and Alsanna are fragments of Manus’ soul, so its main story is basically a continuation of the first DLC.
6. Is Dark Souls 1, 2, or 3 easier?
Dark Souls 3 is often considered more aggressive, making it harder for new players. Dark Souls 2 introduces unique mechanics that can be challenging. Therefore the general consensus is: 3 > 1 > 2.
7. How long is Dark Souls 1?
A standard playthrough of Dark Souls 1 takes around 42 hours.
8. How many hours is Dark Souls 2?
For focused playthroughs, Dark Souls 2 averages about 43.5 hours, while a completionist run can take around 118 hours.
9. Is Dark Souls 2 slower than Dark Souls 1?
While weapon recovery times are faster in DS1, it is generally agreed that neither game is significantly slower than the other.
10. Is Dark Souls 2 harder than Dark Souls 1?
Yes, combat is generally harder on a moment-to-moment basis in Dark Souls 2.
11. Which Dark Souls is the longest?
Dark Souls 2 (including Scholar of the First Sin) is significantly longer than Dark Souls 1.
12. Is Dark Souls really the hardest game?
While the difficulty of Dark Souls series is known for difficulty, Bloodborne is generally seen as more challenging thanks to its fast-paced combat.
13. Is Dark Souls 3 after Dark Souls 1?
Yes, DS3 obviously takes place after DS1. Andre is still alive, so it can’t be that long.
14. Which is better, Dark Souls 2 or 3?
Better AI design for both mobs and bosses and more responsive controls lead dark souls 3’s combat to be significantly better than DS2’s as a whole.
15. What is the strongest class in Dark Souls 2?
Deprived is considered the best class in Dark Souls 2.
Conclusion
While both Dark Souls 1 and Dark Souls 2 offer rewarding, challenging, and time-consuming experiences, the sequel boasts a larger world, denser enemy encounters, and mechanics that contribute to a longer average playtime. Whether you prefer the interconnected world and tight design of Dark Souls 1 or the sprawling scope and intricate challenges of Dark Souls 2, be prepared to invest a significant chunk of your time in either adventure. And, as you navigate the treacherous landscapes of these games, consider the educational potential within game design and problem-solving, as explored by the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org. It is also important to remember that the question of which game is better is largely a subjective one and that both provide great gaming experiences.