Skyrim’s Shifting Seats of Power: A Comprehensive Guide to Jarl Replacements
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
In the ever-dynamic world of Skyrim, political power is as fluid as the raging rivers that carve through its landscapes. The Civil War between the Stormcloaks and the Imperial Legion serves as a major catalyst for change, resulting in numerous Jarls being ousted and replaced. A victory for either side dramatically reshapes the political map of Skyrim, impacting the lives of its citizens and the very structure of its holds. Let’s delve into the intricacies of which Jarls are replaced depending on your chosen allegiance.
The Bottom Line: Depending on whether you side with the Imperial Legion or the Stormcloaks, a multitude of Jarls can be replaced in their holds. Imperial victories see Stormcloak-aligned Jarls removed, while Stormcloak triumphs result in the removal of Imperial-supporting Jarls. These changes can significantly impact gameplay, influencing quest availability, character interactions, and the overall atmosphere of the game.
Jarl Replacements: A Hold-by-Hold Breakdown
The Civil War questline in Skyrim is a pivotal point that can drastically alter the ruling figures in each hold. The outcome of the war, determined by the player’s choices, directly affects the position of the Jarls, leading to a reshuffling of power across the province. Here’s a detailed look at which Jarls get replaced depending on the victor:
Imperial Victory
If the Imperial Legion emerges victorious from the Civil War, the following Jarls will be replaced:
- Eastmarch (Windhelm): Ulfric Stormcloak is removed and replaced by Brunwulf Free-Winter.
- The Pale (Dawnstar): Skald the Elder is replaced by Brina Merilis.
- Winterhold: Korir is replaced by Kraldar.
- The Rift (Riften): Laila Law-Giver is replaced by Maven Black-Briar.
- Falkreath Hold (Falkreath): Siddgeir is replaced by Dengeir of Stuhn.
- The Reach (Markarth): Igmund is replaced by Thongvor Silver-Blood.
- Hjaalmarch (Morthal): Idgrod Ravencrone is replaced by Sorli the Builder.
- Whiterun Hold (Whiterun): Balgruuf the Greater remains Jarl.
Stormcloak Victory
Conversely, a Stormcloak victory results in the removal of the following Jarls:
- Haafingar (Solitude): Elisif the Fair is “coerced” into supporting the Stormcloaks.
- The Pale (Dawnstar): Brina Merilis is replaced by Skald the Elder.
- Winterhold: Kraldar is replaced by Korir.
- The Rift (Riften): Maven Black-Briar is replaced by Laila Law-Giver.
- Falkreath Hold (Falkreath): Dengeir of Stuhn is replaced by Siddgeir.
- The Reach (Markarth): Thongvor Silver-Blood is replaced by Igmund.
- Hjaalmarch (Morthal): Sorli the Builder is replaced by Idgrod Ravencrone.
- Whiterun Hold (Whiterun): Balgruuf the Greater is replaced by Vignar Gray-Mane.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What happens to the ousted Jarls after the Civil War?
At the end of the Civil War questline, all the Jarls who supported the losing faction are stripped of their power and relocated to the Palace of the Kings in Windhelm. This serves as a temporary holding place while their futures remain uncertain.
2. Does Elisif the Fair actually die if the Stormcloaks win?
No, Elisif the Fair does not die if the Stormcloaks win the war. Instead, she is captured by Ulfric Stormcloak and forced to renounce her support for the Imperial Legion in favor of the Stormcloaks.
3. Can I marry a Jarl in Skyrim?
Unfortunately, no. You cannot marry any of the Jarls in Skyrim through standard gameplay. There are mods available that attempt to enable this, but they are often buggy and may not function as intended.
4. What happens to Balgruuf if I side with the Imperials?
If you side with the Imperial Legion, Balgruuf the Greater remains the Jarl of Whiterun. His steadfast loyalty to the Empire ensures his continued rule over the hold.
5. Is it possible to become a Jarl in Skyrim without mods?
No, you cannot become a Jarl in Skyrim through the vanilla game. There are no quests or storylines that allow the player to assume the mantle of Jarl in any of the holds. This requires the use of mods.
6. Who is considered the “best” Jarl in Skyrim?
Many players consider Balgruuf the Greater to be the best Jarl in Skyrim. His honorable nature, effective leadership, and genuine concern for his citizens make him a well-respected and admired ruler.
7. Does siding with the Stormcloaks change my relationship with Lydia?
If you become Thane of Whiterun before the Civil War and side with the Stormcloaks, Lydia will still be your Housecarl. After the Battle for Whiterun, she returns to Breezehome.
8. Who replaces Igmund in Markarth if the Stormcloaks win?
If the Stormcloaks are victorious, Igmund is replaced as Jarl of Markarth by Thongvor Silver-Blood.
9. Do the Thalmor leave Skyrim if the Stormcloaks win?
No, the Thalmor do not leave Skyrim if the Stormcloaks win the Civil War. While their presence may shift, they remain a force in the province, pursuing their own agendas. You may find fewer Thalmor patrols, but the ones you encounter will now be hostile. This is a nod to the complex political landscape. The Games Learning Society studies how games represent such complex narratives.
10. What happens to Vignar Gray-Mane after the Civil War if the Imperials win?
If the Imperial Legion wins the war, Vignar Gray-Mane loses his position as Jarl of Whiterun and returns to his previous life. He can be found back in Whiterun after the events.
11. Who becomes Jarl of Riften if the Stormcloaks win?
If the Stormcloaks are victorious, Laila Law-Giver returns to her position as Jarl of Riften, replacing Maven Black-Briar.
12. Can I switch sides during the Civil War?
Yes, you can betray the Stormcloaks during the quest “The Jagged Crown” by giving the crown to General Tullius instead of Ulfric. However, you must choose a side eventually.
13. What impact does the choice of side have on the overall storyline of Skyrim?
The choice between the Imperial Legion and the Stormcloaks primarily affects the Civil War questline and the political landscape of Skyrim. It doesn’t significantly alter the main questline involving dragons and Alduin, but it does shape the atmosphere and your interactions with various factions and characters.
14. Is it better to side with the Stormcloaks or the Imperials?
The “better” side is entirely subjective and depends on your character’s values and motivations. The Imperial Legion represents order, tradition, and the rule of law, while the Stormcloaks champion freedom, independence, and the Nord way of life. Your choice should align with the character you wish to role-play.
15. Who is the Jarl of Winterhold before the Civil War begins?
Before the Civil War escalates and depending on the side you choose, Korir is the Jarl of Winterhold. However, his rule is often viewed as ineffective, particularly in the wake of the Great Collapse that devastated the city.
Conclusion: A Province Transformed
The shifting allegiances and subsequent Jarl replacements in Skyrim highlight the dynamic political landscape of the game. Whether you choose to side with the Imperial Legion or the Stormcloaks, your decision will have lasting consequences on the rulers of each hold and the overall balance of power in the province. These replacements add depth and replayability to the game, encouraging players to explore different perspectives and experience the Civil War from various angles. Understanding these political nuances enhances your engagement with the world of Skyrim, enriching your overall gaming experience and providing insight into decision-making within game environments. You can learn more about the impact of video games on society through research conducted by organizations like the GamesLearningSociety.org.