Table of Contents

Which Johto Starter Reigns Supreme? A Deep Dive

Quick answer

This page answers Which Johto starter is better? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

Choosing a starter Pokémon is a monumental decision. It shapes your entire journey, coloring your victories and influencing your strategic approach. In the Johto region, trainers are faced with the classic Fire, Water, and Grass dilemma, embodied by Cyndaquil, Totodile, and Chikorita. So, which Johto starter is actually the best?

While personal preference certainly plays a role, a cold, hard look at their strengths, weaknesses, and overall utility within the Gold, Silver, and Crystal games (and their remakes, HeartGold and SoulSilver) reveals a clear winner:

Cyndaquil emerges as the superior choice for most players.

Let’s break down why:

Early Game Dominance: Cyndaquil provides a significant advantage early on. The first gym leader, Falkner, is a Flying-type specialist. While Rock Throw can be taught to Totodile and Chikorita learns Razor Leaf at level 6, dealing with Bugsy, the Bug-type gym leader, can be tricky for Totodile or Chikorita. Cyndaquil, however, can handle Bugsy with ease.
Limited Fire-Types in Johto: The Johto region suffers from a severe lack of viable Fire-type Pokémon. Choosing Cyndaquil immediately fills this niche, preventing you from relying on less optimal options later in the game.
Favorable Matchups: Cyndaquil, upon evolving into Typhlosion, boasts a high Special Attack stat and access to powerful Fire-type moves like Flamethrower and Fire Blast. It is super effective against Bug, Steel, Grass, and Ice and can deal substantial damage to most trainers and their Pokemon. It’s worth noting, Typhlosion can also learn Thunder Punch for increased type coverage!
Viable Movepool: Cyndaquil’s movepool is generally adequate for an in-game playthrough, though not as diverse as Totodile’s. With access to Fire-type moves, coverage moves like Thunder Punch, and even moves like Swift, Typhlosion can handle many challenges in the Johto region.

While Totodile (evolving into Feraligatr) is a solid contender with good Attack, a diverse movepool, and the ability to learn Ice-type moves for tackling Dragon-types, it falls slightly short due to its reliance on physical attacks and coverage moves like Earthquake may be unavailable until later in the game. Chikorita (evolving into Meganium), unfortunately, struggles immensely throughout the Johto journey. Its Grass-typing leaves it vulnerable to many common threats, and its stats and movepool are underwhelming.

Therefore, the decision ultimately comes down to Cyndaquil vs. Totodile. While both are viable, Cyndaquil’s early-game advantage, scarcity of Fire-types, and strong Special Attack give it the edge.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Johto Starters

H3 1. Is Chikorita really that bad?

Unfortunately, yes. Chikorita faces a significant uphill battle in Johto. Its weaknesses to Flying, Poison, Bug, Fire, and Ice are prevalent in the early game and its movepool lacks significant offensive power. It struggles against the first three gym leaders and many other important battles throughout the region. It is not recommended for new or inexperienced players.

H3 2. Does choosing Totodile make the game harder?

Not necessarily “harder,” but potentially more challenging in the early game. The Bug-type gym is a hassle and requires a rock-type Pokemon, whereas Cyndaquil would simply make that gym much easier. Totodile’s strength lies in its versatility later in the game, when its access to strong water-type moves can take over.

H3 3. Which starter is better for a Nuzlocke challenge?

For a Nuzlocke challenge, Totodile is generally considered the safer option. Its greater bulk and access to diverse coverage moves allow it to handle a wider range of threats. However, a skilled player can make any starter work in a Nuzlocke.

H3 4. Which starter is best for competitive battling?

In competitive battling, the viability of each starter varies depending on the generation and specific metagame. However, Typhlosion and Feraligatr have seen some usage over the years, with Typhlosion often used as a special attacker and Feraligatr as a physical sweeper with the Sheer Force ability.

H3 5. Does the difficulty of the game change depending on my starter?

Yes, significantly. As mentioned previously, Chikorita creates the most challenging experience, while Cyndaquil generally offers the smoothest playthrough. Totodile provides a middle ground, requiring more strategic team building early on but becoming a powerhouse later.

H3 6. What are the final evolutions of each starter?

Cyndaquil evolves into Quilava at level 14, and then into Typhlosion at level 36.
Totodile evolves into Croconaw at level 18, and then into Feraligatr at level 30.
Chikorita evolves into Bayleef at level 16, and then into Meganium at level 32.

H3 7. What are the best moves for Typhlosion in Gen 2 (Gold, Silver, Crystal)?

The best moveset for Typhlosion in Gen 2 often includes:

Flamethrower: A powerful and reliable Fire-type STAB move.
Thunder Punch: For coverage against Water and Flying-types.
Earthquake: For coverage against Rock, Steel, and other Ground types.
Fire Blast: Risky, but a powerful choice if you are confident in your moves.

H3 8. What are the best moves for Feraligatr in Gen 2 (Gold, Silver, Crystal)?

A strong Feraligatr moveset in Gen 2 includes:

Surf: A strong Water-type STAB move.
Ice Beam: Coverage against Grass, Flying, and Dragon-types.
Earthquake: Coverage against Electric, Rock, and Steel types.
Slash/Return: A powerful Normal-type move for general damage.

H3 9. Is the Johto region a good one for beginners?

The Johto region is generally considered a good region for beginners. Although more complex than Kanto, Johto is still not overly complicated and the storylines/mechanics introduced in Gen 2 are easier to grasp.

H3 10. Which starter has the coolest design?

This is purely subjective! Some trainers prefer the fiery intensity of Typhlosion, while others admire the aggressive power of Feraligatr or the gentle elegance of Meganium.

H3 11. Are the remakes (HeartGold and SoulSilver) any different in terms of starter viability?

The remakes slightly improve the viability of all starters, but the general power dynamic remains similar. Cyndaquil still excels early, Totodile becomes a strong mid-to-late game choice, and Chikorita still struggles. The availability of more moves and abilities slightly buffs all three.

H3 12. Does starter choice impact the Elite Four battles?

Yes, significantly. A Fire-type like Typhlosion can be invaluable against Will (Psychic) and Karen (Dark). Feraligatr is strong against Lance (Dragon), particularly with Ice Beam. Chikorita struggles against several Elite Four members.

H3 13. Which starter is faster, Typhlosion or Feraligatr?

Typhlosion is significantly faster than Feraligatr. Typhlosion’s high Special Attack is further enabled by its high speed.

H3 14. What is the best ability for these starters?

Typhlosion’s Blaze: Boosts Fire-type moves when HP is low. Situational, but can be useful.
Feraligatr’s Torrent: Boosts Water-type moves when HP is low. Similar to Blaze.
Meganium’s Overgrow: Boosts Grass-type moves when HP is low. Least useful of the three.

H3 15. What can I do to make Chikorita viable?

To make Chikorita viable, you’ll need to carefully plan your team composition. Focus on covering its weaknesses with strong teammates and teach it supportive moves like Reflect, Light Screen, or Aromatherapy to enhance its utility. This game requires more attention to detail regarding strategies.

In conclusion, while personal preference is paramount, the numbers and the Johto landscape favor Cyndaquil as the most strategically sound starter choice. However, with thoughtful planning and team building, any of these beloved Pokémon can lead you to victory. The study of games and how they impact learning, cognitive function, and societal behavior is more important than ever, be sure to visit the Games Learning Society website for more information! You can visit it here: https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.