Which of the 3 Captives Should I Kill in Skyrim?
To answer the question directly, it doesn’t matter which captive you choose to kill in Skyrim, as the outcome will be the same, and you won’t encounter them again unless you return to the shack. The decision of killing Vasha, Alea, or Ralof is up to personal preference, but Astrid seems to prefer it if you kill Vasha, the Khajit, as she remarks that he was the obvious choice.
Understanding the Context
The Dark Brotherhood questline in Skyrim is complex and filled with moral dilemmas, one of which is deciding which captive to kill. This decision, although seeming pivotal, does not significantly impact the overall storyline but reflects on the character’s morality and Astrid’s perception of the player.
Implications of the Decision
Regardless of the choice, Astrid will give the player the password to the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary’s “The Black Door” if one or more captives are killed. This leads to an invitation to join the secret society of assassins and the provision of the key to the shack.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What Happens if I Kill All Three Captives in Skyrim?
Killing all three captives will result in Astrid extending an invitation to join the Dark Brotherhood and providing the key to the shack, urging the player to enter the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary near Falkreath.
2. Which of the Three Should I Kill in Skyrim?
For most players, either Vasha or Alea are considered the correct victims, but Astrid won’t confirm if the assessment was right, making the choice somewhat subjective.
3. Who is the Right Captive to Kill in Skyrim?
Astrid prefers the player to kill Vasha, the Khajit, as he describes himself as a murderer, a rapist, and a thief, making him the obvious choice in her eyes.
4. Who Are You Supposed to Kill in With Friends Like These?
The quest allows for the killing of any of the hostages, and the result will be the same: Astrid giving the location of the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary.
5. Is it Better to Join the Dark Brotherhood or Destroy It?
Joining the Dark Brotherhood is beneficial for achieving completions and acquiring unique items, but destroying it aligns with a more moral playstyle.
6. Is it Better to Kill Astrid or Not?
Killing Astrid initiates the quest “Destroy the Dark Brotherhood!” and makes all members killable, while not killing her makes them un-killable.
7. Who Are the Best People to Sacrifice in Skyrim?
Ralis Sedarys is considered one of the most justifiable choices due to his actions and character in the game.
8. What Followers Cannot Be Killed in Skyrim?
Essential followers, including Aela the Huntress, Barbas, and Cicero, cannot be killed, making them valuable companions.
9. What Happens if I Kill Lydia?
If Lydia dies, there are no spells to bring her back permanently, and using Raise Zombie will only temporarily revive her.
10. Which Side is Good in Skyrim?
The choice between the Imperials and the Stormcloaks depends on the player’s character direction and preferences.
11. Can You Kill Both Sides in Skyrim?
While it’s possible to kill characters from both factions, it won’t significantly affect the storyline, and essential characters are protected unless killed as part of a specific quest.
12. What is the Most Evil Thing You Can Do in Skyrim?
Empowering The Ebony Blade by killing characters who trust the Dovahkiin is considered one of the evilest choices, as it involves betrayal and murder of innocent characters.
13. Can You Permanently Kill Lydia?
Yes, Lydia can be permanently killed, but it requires specific circumstances, such as the player directly killing her or her being hit by an unintended attack or spell.
14. What Happens if You Become a Cannibal in Skyrim?
There are no significant downsides to being a cannibal in Skyrim, aside from moral implications and potential guard trouble.
15. Who is the Most Badass Follower in Skyrim?
Serana is considered the best follower due to her necromancy abilities and combat prowess, making her a powerful ally in battles.