The Ultimate PES Showdown: Which Pro Evolution Soccer Reigns Supreme?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question that has plagued digital football fans for decades: Which Pro Evolution Soccer (PES) game is truly the best? The answer, like a perfectly weighted through ball, is complex and depends entirely on what you value most in your virtual football experience. However, taking into account gameplay, realism, innovation, and enduring legacy, PES 2013 and PES 2017 stand out as top contenders, with PES 2018 close behind. While opinions vary wildly across the fanbase, these titles consistently receive high praise for capturing the beautiful game’s essence in their respective eras.
Defining the “Best” PES
Before diving into specific titles, it’s essential to define what makes a PES game “good.” For some, it’s all about gameplay fluidity and the feeling of control over every pass, tackle, and shot. Others prioritize realism, seeking accurate player representations, authentic stadiums, and AI that mimics real-world football tactics. Then there’s the Master League, the beloved career mode that allows you to build a team from the ground up and lead them to glory. Finally, the online experience also has a place in determining the best edition. A great PES must strike a balance between these elements, catering to a wide range of players.
The Contenders: A Look at Key PES Titles
Here’s a rundown of some of the most talked-about PES games, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses:
-
PES 2013: Often cited as a fan favorite, PES 2013 delivered a fast-paced, attacking brand of football. Its responsiveness and arcade-like feel resonated with many players. While it might not be the most realistic, the sheer joy of scoring spectacular goals kept people coming back for more. PES 2013 offered freedom and enjoyment for its players and maintained a popular following for years.
-
PES 2017: Widely regarded as the last truly great PES, PES 2017 refined the gameplay of its predecessors, offering a more tactical and strategic experience. The AI was improved, player animations were smoother, and the overall presentation felt polished. Many felt that PES 2017 found a perfect balance between realism and fun, making it a benchmark for the series.
-
PES 2018: While somewhat divisive, PES 2018 is admired by many for its refined gameplay, impressive graphics, and legendary nemeses system. The offline gameplay was a high point, and for many, it was the most enjoyable experience to be had in a football game at the time. However, some felt it lacked the soul of earlier titles.
-
PES 2019: While falling short of the heights of 2017 and 2018, PES 2019 had a positive reception, in particular for having responsive AI and control. It’s considered to be the last “modern” version of the game that was still playable for many fans.
-
PES 2020 & 2021 (Season Update): These titles marked a turning point for the series. While they weren’t universally disliked, many felt that they strayed too far from the series’ core strengths, with some even labeling PES 2021 as the worst ever PES in history.
-
eFootball 2022 & 2023: The transition to eFootball, a free-to-play model, was met with a lot of challenges. Initial impressions of eFootball 2022 were overwhelmingly negative, with many criticizing the game’s graphics, gameplay, and overall presentation. eFootball 2023 saw improvements, but the game still struggled to win back the hearts of long-time PES fans.
The Verdict
Ultimately, the “best” PES game is subjective. But the combination of nostalgia, gameplay fluidity, and tactical depth positions PES 2013 and PES 2017 as the frontrunners. PES 2018 is a strong contender, and even titles like PES 6 and Winning Eleven are considered popular by the fan base. If you value fast-paced action and arcade-like fun, PES 2013 might be your pick. If you prefer a more strategic and realistic experience, PES 2017 is a great option. Experiment with different titles and see which one resonates with you. Organizations like the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org explore how games impact learning and culture, and understanding the evolution and preferences surrounding games like PES can offer insights into player engagement and game design principles.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Why is PES 2013 considered so good by many fans?
PES 2013’s popularity stems from its fluid gameplay, responsive controls, and arcade-like feel. It’s a game where spectacular goals are common, and the overall experience is simply fun and engaging.
2. What makes PES 2017 stand out from other titles?
PES 2017 is praised for its balance between realism and fun. The gameplay is tactical and strategic, the AI is improved, and the overall presentation feels polished.
3. Is PES 2019 better than PES 2020?
Many players feel that PES 2019 is superior to PES 2020 in terms of gameplay fluidity and AI behavior. It’s considered to be the last “modern” PES game that still captured the spirit of the series.
4. Why was the transition from PES to eFootball so controversial?
The transition to eFootball, a free-to-play model, was met with criticism due to the game’s initial poor graphics, gameplay issues, and lack of content.
5. What are the main differences between PES and FIFA?
PES is often praised for its gameplay realism, while FIFA excels in presentation, licensing, and game modes like Ultimate Team and Volta Football.
6. Does eFootball have a career mode similar to PES’s Master League?
While eFootball has introduced elements that resemble a career mode, it is not yet as deep or as beloved as PES’s Master League.
7. Which PES game has the best Master League mode?
Many fans consider classic PES titles like PES 5 and PES 6 to have the best Master League modes, due to their depth, customization options, and sense of progression.
8. Is eFootball 2023 an improvement over eFootball 2022?
Yes, eFootball 2023 is considered to be an improvement over eFootball 2022, with better gameplay and graphics. However, it still faces challenges in winning back long-time PES fans.
9. What are the key factors that make PES gameplay so unique?
PES gameplay is known for its emphasis on player positioning, momentum, and tactical decision-making. The game rewards players who understand football and can anticipate their opponents’ moves.
10. Why did Konami decide to rebrand PES as eFootball?
Konami rebranded PES as eFootball in part due to losing key licenses and wanting to move towards a free-to-play model.
11. Is PES 2018 worth playing in 2024?
If you appreciate refined gameplay, offline modes, and aren’t too concerned about having the latest licenses, PES 2018 is still worth playing in 2024.
12. Does PES have better graphics than FIFA?
The perception of graphics quality can be subjective. While FIFA has exclusive access to the Frostbite engine, which enhances in-play graphics, PES is praised for its realistic gameplay and fluid player animations.
13. What can be done to improve eFootball and make it a worthy successor to PES?
To improve eFootball, Konami needs to address the gameplay issues, improve the graphics, add more content, and communicate effectively with the community. Bringing back classic modes like Master League would also be a great step.
14. Has eFootball fully replaced PES?
Yes, eFootball has fully replaced PES as Konami’s flagship football game franchise. However, the legacy of PES continues to influence the development of eFootball.
15. Where can I find more information about the history and evolution of PES?
You can find more information about the history and evolution of PES on gaming websites, forums, and video game history archives.