Which XCOM is the Hardest? A Deep Dive into Tactical Terror
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of which XCOM game reigns supreme in terms of difficulty is a common debate among fans of the franchise. The answer, however, isn’t as straightforward as picking a single title. It largely depends on which specific aspects of the game you’re focusing on, which difficulty setting you are playing, and even your personal playstyle. Overall, XCOM 2, particularly with the War of the Chosen expansion (WotC), is generally considered the most challenging, primarily due to its relentless difficulty scaling and the introduction of powerful new enemies and mechanics. However, it’s not a cut-and-dry case. Let’s break it down.
XCOM: Enemy Unknown/Enemy Within – A Tough Start
The original reboot, XCOM: Enemy Unknown, and its expansion, Enemy Within, set a high bar for difficulty. Many players found the early game to be particularly brutal. Resource management was tight, rookies were fragile, and a single mistake could easily snowball into a squad wipe. In Enemy Unknown, there were no time constraints on many missions, allowing for patient and methodical play. Enemy Within added new elements like MELD and gene mods, which increased complexity but also provided tools to overcome challenges. The difficulty in these games is somewhat player-controlled; a slower pace focusing on research and soldier progression can make the game more manageable, while rushing key missions can lead to overwhelm. However, both games lack the relentless scaling that characterises XCOM 2’s difficulty curve.
XCOM 2 – A Relentless Challenge
XCOM 2 shifts the narrative, placing the player as a guerrilla force fighting against alien occupation. The difficulty escalates progressively with each mission, regardless of your progress. This relentless pressure makes XCOM 2 feel much more challenging than its predecessors for many players. Time constraints are introduced, forcing more aggressive tactics and less cautious overwatch strategies. XCOM 2 also features more varied enemies and unpredictable map layouts.
XCOM 2: War of the Chosen – The Pinnacle of Difficulty
War of the Chosen (WotC) takes XCOM 2’s difficulty and cranks it up even further. The introduction of the Chosen – powerful, unique, and persistent adversaries – adds a new layer of stress. These enemies actively hunt the player, appearing at inopportune moments and forcing you to alter your tactics. Additionally, WotC introduces new factions, resistance orders, and fatigue mechanics, leading to resource management and strategic decisions being even more critical. While these new systems can make the game more engaging, they also add a considerable amount of complexity, making WotC significantly harder than vanilla XCOM 2 for new and even experienced players.
Difficulty Settings Compared
The perception of difficulty also changes when comparing the specific difficulty levels. For instance, XCOM 2 is considered easier than previous games on Veteran and Commander difficulty, offering a more forgiving experience. However, XCOM 2’s Legendary difficulty is significantly harder than the Impossible difficulty of XCOM: Enemy Unknown/Within. This is due to the aforementioned scaling of difficulty, tighter mission timers, and the aggressiveness of the AI.
So, Which is the Hardest?
In summary, while the earlier games, XCOM: Enemy Unknown/Within, can be brutally hard at the start, particularly on higher difficulties, they lack the consistently increasing difficulty of XCOM 2. XCOM 2, especially with the War of the Chosen expansion, is generally considered the hardest XCOM game, due to its unforgiving nature, the aggressive AI, the Chosen, and the relentless scaling of mission difficulty.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is XCOM 1 harder than XCOM 2?
While XCOM 1 (Enemy Unknown/Within) has a steep learning curve and can be brutally punishing initially, XCOM 2 features a more consistent difficulty curve and is generally considered harder overall, especially on higher difficulties. The absence of a strategic layer in XCOM: Enemy Unknown means you are not constrained to the same extent as in XCOM 2.
2. Is XCOM or XCOM 2 easier?
XCOM 2 can be easier on lower difficulties (Veteran and Commander) compared to XCOM 1, but on Legendary difficulty, XCOM 2 is significantly harder.
3. Is XCOM 1 or XCOM 2 better?
Both games are excellent, but XCOM 2 is considered the better game overall, offering more variety in enemies, playstyles, and mechanics. The expansion, War of the Chosen, takes this further with vast enhancements.
4. Is XCOM War of the Chosen harder?
Yes, War of the Chosen is considerably harder than vanilla XCOM 2, even on normal difficulty. The Chosen, new factions, and increased complexity make it much more challenging.
5. Should I select XCOM 2 or War of the Chosen?
It’s generally recommended to start with vanilla XCOM 2 first to get a grasp of the base mechanics. However, if you have WotC, you might as well jump straight into it, as it significantly enriches the game.
6. Is XCOM 2 War of the Chosen easier?
The early game in WotC is generally harder due to encounters with the Chosen. However, with squad size upgrades, the addition of the hero classes, and a functioning Resistance Ring, the mid- and late-game can feel somewhat easier.
7. Should I beat XCOM 1 before 2?
It’s beneficial to play the first game to understand the series’ continuity and experience the different mechanics. XCOM 2 is more polished, so playing the first game can make you appreciate the improvements in the sequel.
8. Which XCOM should I buy?
Start with either:
* Vanilla XCOM 2 (without Alien Hunters DLC)
* XCOM 2 War of the Chosen (WotC)
* XCOM: Enemy Unknown with Enemy Within DLC.
9. Is XCOM worth playing after XCOM 2?
Yes, XCOM: Enemy Within offers unique gameplay that is not just a straight downgrade. It introduces elements like MELD and gene mods that differ from XCOM 2.
10. How many years between XCOM 1 and 2?
XCOM 2 takes place 20 years after the events of XCOM: Enemy Unknown.
11. Who is the strongest character in XCOM 2?
The Reaper class is often considered the strongest class in XCOM 2, followed by Grenadiers.
12. Can you make XCOM 2 easier?
Yes, XCOM 2 offers options like ‘Lengthy Scheme’ (doubles the Avatar Project timer) and ‘Time Turner’ (doubles mission timers) that can significantly ease the difficulty.
13. Is XCOM 2 never-ending?
XCOM 2, similar to the original, has a final mission that ends the game, but you can continue playing side missions indefinitely before deciding to do it.
14. How hard is XCOM 2 for beginners?
XCOM 2 can be very challenging for beginners, especially with all the options and mechanics introduced early on. It is important to understand the concepts of cover and flanking, and to build a balanced team.
15. What is the most powerful weapon in XCOM 2?
The Plasma Bolt Caster is one of the most powerful standard weapons in XCOM 2, but it needs to be reloaded after every shot.