Who gives Arthur TB?

▶

Arthur Morgan contracts tuberculosis (TB) from Thomas Downes, a character in the game who coughs blood on Arthur, transmitting the disease to him. This event is a pivotal moment in the story of Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2), as it sets in motion the eventual decline and death of Arthur Morgan due to TB, a disease that was prevalent in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

Understanding TB in RDR2

The Impact of TB on Arthur Morgan

In RDR2, Arthur Morgan’s contraction of TB is a significant plot point that affects the story and its characters. To understand this better, let’s explore some frequently asked questions related to TB in RDR2.

FAQs

1. Can you prevent Arthur Morgan from getting tuberculosis? No, it is not possible to prevent Arthur from getting TB in RDR2, as it is part of the storyline. However, there is a loophole where if you don’t progress in the game, Arthur won’t succumb to TB.

2. Can you avoid getting TB in RDR2? Getting TB is integrated into the story, and even if you try to skip the mission where Arthur gets sick, he will still develop symptoms of TB.

3. Does Arthur know Thomas gave him TB? Yes, Arthur remembers exactly who gave it to him, as Thomas Downes coughs blood on him, which is a clear indication of how Arthur contracted TB.

4. Why did no one get TB from Arthur? For the sake of the story, the game developers chose not to have other characters contract TB from Arthur, despite the closeness and lack of precautions, which could be seen as a stretch of the imagination.

5. Does Micah get tuberculosis? No, Micah does not get TB, even after being exposed to infected blood, which is inconsistent with how Arthur contracted TB from Thomas Downes.

6. Did Dutch know Arthur was sick? Dutch seems to notice that Arthur is sick but does not make any serious inquiries about his condition, which is odd given their relationship.

7. Will there be a RDR3? While there has been no official announcement from Rockstar Games, hints and teases suggest that there might be a Red Dead Redemption 3 in the future, possibly set in a different time period.

8. Would Arthur have died from tuberculosis? Yes, regardless of how RDR2 is played, Arthur Morgan always contracts TB and passes away by the end of the game.

9. Did Arthur infect anyone with TB? No, despite not taking precautions, no one in the Van der Linde gang becomes sick with TB over the course of the game.

10. Can you shoot Thomas Downes in RDR2? Yes, you can encounter Thomas Downes again in the game and choose to shoot him if you wish, near the stable in Valentine.

11. Why did Dutch betray Arthur? Dutch’s betrayal of Arthur stems from his misunderstanding of Arthur’s intentions and his own paranoia, fueled by Micah Bell’s manipulations.

12. Was Arthur mentioned in RDR1? Arthur is not mentioned in the first Red Dead Redemption game, possibly because it’s too painful for the characters to recall memories of him.

13. Can you play as Arthur after he dies? No, once Arthur dies, you can only continue playing as John Marston, and there are no cheats to allow play as Arthur after his death.

14. Could Arthur have killed Micah without TB? Possibly, if Arthur had not contracted TB, he might have been stronger and able to kill Micah Bell at the end of RDR2.

15. Why did Dutch shoot Micah? Dutch shoots Micah as a form of redemption for Arthur’s death and the downfall of the gang, acknowledging Micah’s betrayal and its consequences.

Conclusion

The story of Red Dead Redemption 2 is deeply intertwined with the historical context of tuberculosis (TB), a disease that was rampant during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Understanding who gives Arthur TB and how it affects the story provides insight into the game’s narrative and characters. Through the FAQs, we’ve explored various aspects of TB in RDR2, from its transmission to its impact on the characters and the story’s progression. Rockstar Games has woven a complex and engaging tale that not only entertains but also educates players about a significant period in history.