Who Has Killed a Primarch? An In-Depth Analysis
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The grim darkness of the far future is rife with conflict and loss, and even the mighty Primarchs, superhuman sons of the Emperor of Mankind, are not immune to death. However, the list of those who have permanently extinguished a Primarch’s life is surprisingly short. Officially, the known killers of Primarchs are: Fulgrim (who slew Ferrus Manus), Horus (who slew Sanguinius), The Emperor (who slew Horus), Rogal Dorn (who presumably slew Alpharius), and M’Shen (the Callidus Assassin who slew Konrad Curze). Guilliman did defeat Magnus, but did not kill Magnus. Now, let’s delve deeper into the circumstances surrounding each of these momentous events.
The Primarch Killers: A Detailed Examination
Fulgrim: The Fall of the Phoenician and the Death of Iron
The infamous Drop Site Massacre on Istvaan V marks one of the darkest days in the Horus Heresy. It was here that Fulgrim, once a noble and close brother to Ferrus Manus, fully embraced the corruption of Chaos. Driven by his desire for perfection and influenced by a daemon blade, Fulgrim turned on his loyalist brothers. In a brutal duel, Fulgrim struck down Ferrus Manus, beheading him in a single, decisive blow. This act served as a chilling testament to the power of Chaos and the devastating consequences of betrayal. Fulgrim’s act of patricide etched his name into the annals of treachery.
Horus: The Arch-Traitor and the Angel’s Demise
The Battle of Terra, the climactic siege of the Imperial Palace, witnessed the ultimate confrontation between Horus, now fully consumed by Chaos, and his father, the Emperor of Mankind. During the desperate struggle, the noble Sanguinius, the Great Angel of the Blood Angels, confronted Horus in a valiant attempt to protect his father. Sanguinius fought with unmatched courage and skill, but Horus, empowered by the Chaos Gods, proved too strong. Horus ultimately slew Sanguinius, a sacrifice that bought the Emperor the precious time needed to strike back.
The Emperor: The Redemption of Mankind at a Terrible Cost
Following the death of Sanguinius, the Emperor himself engaged Horus in a final, cataclysmic duel aboard the Vengeful Spirit. The battle raged across the warship, tearing through bulkheads and warping reality itself. In the end, the Emperor, witnessing the ruin that Horus had wrought and the threat he posed to humanity’s future, was forced to unleash his full power. With a devastating psychic blow, the Emperor obliterated Horus’s soul, ending the Warmaster’s rebellion but sustaining wounds that would confine him to the Golden Throne for millennia. While the Emperor triumphed, it was a pyrrhic victory, forever altering the fate of the Imperium.
Rogal Dorn: The Fortifier and the Ambiguity of Death on Pluto
The death of Alpharius (or someone claiming to be him) is shrouded in mystery and intrigue, befitting the Primarch of the Alpha Legion. During the campaign following the Horus Heresy, Rogal Dorn, Primarch of the Imperial Fists, confronted Alpharius on the world of Pluto. In a fierce duel, Dorn prevailed, allegedly slaying Alpharius. However, given the Alpha Legion’s penchant for deception and infiltration, it remains uncertain whether Dorn actually killed Alpharius or merely one of his many doubles or champions. The uncertainty surrounding Alpharius’s death continues to fuel speculation and debate among Warhammer 40,000 fans.
M’Shen: The Assassin’s Blade and the Night Haunter’s End
Konrad Curze, also known as Night Haunter, the Primarch of the Night Lords, was a tortured and tormented soul. Plagued by visions of a dark future, he embraced brutality and terror as his weapons. Eventually, Curze allowed himself to be captured by the Imperium and orchestrated his own assassination. He prophesized the arrival of an assassin, and when M’Shen, a Callidus Assassin of the Officio Assassinorum, arrived, Curze offered no resistance. He was killed by M’Shen; making her the only known mortal who succeeded to kill a Primarch. His death served as a final, twisted act of defiance and a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Has Guilliman Killed a Primarch?
No, Roboute Guilliman has never killed another Primarch. He wounded Magnus, however, Magnus retreated instead of being killed by Guilliman.
2. Which Primarchs are Confirmed Dead?
The most definitively confirmed dead Primarchs are: Horus, Sanguinius, Ferrus Manus, and Konrad Curze.
3. Is Rogal Dorn Truly Dead?
While officially listed as deceased, the fate of Rogal Dorn is more ambiguous. He disappeared on board the Chaos warship Sword of Sacrilege, and only his hand was ever recovered. Some believe he still lives, fighting somewhere in the galaxy.
4. Who is the Weakest Primarch?
In terms of combat prowess, Lorgar is often considered the “weakest” Primarch. He was more focused on philosophy and religion than martial skill.
5. Who is the Strongest Living Primarch?
Currently, the “strongest” living Primarch is a matter of debate. While Vulkan is renowned for his physical resilience and strength, Lion El’Jonson and Roboute Guilliman also possess formidable abilities and strategic minds. Also the Chaos Primarchs might have been boosted by the powers of Chaos.
6. Can a Space Marine Beat a Primarch?
No. A standard Space Marine cannot defeat a Primarch in a straight fight. The Primarchs were designed to be far superior warriors.
7. Could a Custodes Beat a Primarch?
A single Custodes would likely be defeated by a Primarch. However, a squad of Custodes might be able to overwhelm a Primarch through sheer numbers and coordinated tactics, but they would suffer heavy losses.
8. Is Magnus the Red Dead?
No, Magnus the Red is not dead. He is a Daemon Primarch, bound to the service of Tzeentch.
9. Can a Primarch Defeat a Chaos God?
Absolutely not. A Daemon Primarch’s power comes from their patron Chaos God. They are vastly outmatched by the Gods themselves.
10. Was Malcador Stronger than a Primarch?
Malcador the Sigillite was a powerful psyker, but he was not stronger than the Primarchs in terms of combat ability.
11. How Long Does a Primarch Live?
Primarchs are functionally immortal. They do not die of old age.
12. Will Sanguinius Ever Return?
The consensus is that Sanguinius will not return. His death is a pivotal moment in the lore.
13. Is Guilliman the Only Loyal Primarch Left?
No. Both Lion El’Jonson and Guilliman are active in the Imperium. Corvus Corax is still alive, but his current form is corrupted and barely resembling his old self.
14. Who Was the Biggest Primarch?
Vulkan is the largest Primarch, standing over 10 feet tall.
15. What is the Games Learning Society?
The Games Learning Society is an organization dedicated to exploring the educational and transformative potential of games. You can learn more at GamesLearningSociety.org.
In conclusion, the act of slaying a Primarch is a momentous and rare occurrence in the Warhammer 40,000 universe. These acts of destruction have shaped the narrative and continue to fuel the grim darkness of the far future.