Who Is Bad in Skyrim? Unpacking the Morality of Tamriel

▶

Defining “bad” in Skyrim is like trying to nail jelly to a wall. There’s no simple answer. Morality in Tamriel, the world of The Elder Scrolls, is complex and nuanced. While characters like Alduin, the World Eater, and Mehrunes Dagon, a Daedric Prince of Destruction, are unequivocally villainous, the morality of others is far more subjective. Ultimately, who you consider “bad” depends entirely on your perspective, your character’s choices, and your personal values. Skyrim offers a vast array of individuals and factions whose “evil” is rooted in their actions, beliefs, and impacts on the world.

Understanding Skyrim’s Moral Landscape

Skyrim isn’t a black and white world. Even those who appear virtuous might harbor questionable motivations. Here’s a breakdown of different types of “bad” you’ll encounter:

• The Unrepentant Villains: These are the characters who are unambiguously evil. They revel in destruction, enslavement, and suffering. Alduin and Mehrunes Dagon fall squarely into this category. Their goals are inherently destructive to the mortal realm.

• The Morally Grey: This is where things get interesting. Characters like Ulfric Stormcloak and Maven Black-Briar occupy this space. Their actions are driven by complex motivations, and their impact is both positive and negative depending on who you ask. Are the Stormcloaks racist and oppressive? Or are they freedom fighters defending their homeland? Are the Imperials tyrannical or providing much-needed order? Is Maven Black-Briar a successful businesswoman, or a ruthless exploiter? It’s all up to you.

• The Misunderstood: Sometimes, characters are labeled “bad” due to circumstance or perception. The Thieves Guild and Dark Brotherhood, for example, are criminal organizations, but many players find their stories and characters compelling. Some quests even force you to consider the ethical implications of your choices within these factions.

• The Monsters: Beyond humanoids, Skyrim is filled with terrifying creatures. While not inherently “evil” in the sentient sense, entities like Chaurus and Draugr Death Overlords pose significant threats to the innocent. They actively seek to cause harm and thus fall under the definition of “bad” within the confines of the game world.

Key Figures and Factions: A Deeper Dive

To truly understand the moral ambiguity of Skyrim, let’s examine some key figures and factions:

• Alduin: As the World Eater, Alduin’s goal is the complete destruction of the current world to make way for a new one. This makes him undeniably evil in his goal.

• Mehrunes Dagon: This Daedric Prince enjoys the destruction of entire cities and empires. His quest is nothing but destruction.

• Ulfric Stormcloak: Ulfric’s motivations are debated. Is he fighting for Skyrim’s freedom, or is he a power-hungry demagogue? His actions definitely caused a lot of unnecessary bloodshed.

• Maven Black-Briar: Manipulative and ruthless, Maven’s pursuit of wealth and power comes at the expense of others. She is hated among fans for her manipulative behavior.

• The Thalmor: This group of High Elves believe themselves superior to humans and seek to impose their will on Tamriel. They are responsible for the ban on Talos worship, and their actions are highly controversial.

• The Forsworn: While often seen as savage raiders, the Forsworn are fighting to reclaim their ancestral lands. Their methods are brutal, but their cause is rooted in injustice.

• Bandits and Necromancers: While generic, these enemies are evil to all people. They steal, murder, and generally commit evil acts in the world.

Making Your Own Judgment

Ultimately, determining who is “bad” in Skyrim is a deeply personal process. The game encourages players to make their own judgments based on their own moral compass. Consider the motivations behind characters’ actions, the consequences of their choices, and how their behavior impacts the world around them.

Skyrim’s brilliance lies in its ability to make you question your own sense of right and wrong. Are you willing to compromise your values for power? Are you willing to fight for what you believe in, even if it means resorting to violence? These are the questions that Skyrim forces you to confront.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Skyrim’s Villains

Here are some frequently asked questions to help you navigate the morally complex world of Skyrim:

1. Is Alduin truly defeated at the end of the game?

   While Alduin is defeated at the Throat of the World, some lore suggests he may return in the future. His nature as a fundamental force of destruction implies he’s not entirely gone for good.

2. Are the Stormcloaks inherently racist?

   The Stormcloaks’ stance on non-Nords is a point of contention. While the game doesn’t explicitly state that they are racist, there are instances of prejudice and discrimination within their ranks. However, some Nords are accepting of the non-Nords while others are not.

3. Is the Empire corrupt?

   The Empire is portrayed as weakened and heavily influenced by the Thalmor. While not inherently corrupt, their alliance with the Thalmor and their restrictions on religious freedom raise questions about their moral integrity.

4. What makes Mehrunes Dagon so evil?

   Mehrunes Dagon embodies pure destruction and chaos. His goal is to tear down existing structures and plunge the world into turmoil, making him a quintessential villain.

5. Is there a definitively “good” side in the Civil War?

   No. Both the Stormcloaks and the Empire have compelling arguments and flaws. The choice of which side to support depends on your own values and priorities.

6. Can you be a truly evil character in Skyrim?

   Yes. While the game doesn’t have a formal “evil” alignment system, you can make choices that align your character with morally reprehensible actions. Examples are destroying the Dark Brotherhood.

7. Are the Thalmor the ultimate bad guys in Skyrim?

   The Thalmor are certainly presented as antagonists, but their motivations are complex. They believe they are acting in the best interests of their people, even if their methods are questionable.

8. What are some of the darkest quests in Skyrim?

   Quests like “Boethiah’s Calling” and certain Dark Brotherhood contracts involve morally questionable choices and actions. They force you to confront the darker aspects of the game world.

9. Is Maven Black-Briar just a successful businesswoman?

   Maven is a successful businesswoman, but her methods are often ruthless and exploitative. She uses her influence to manipulate others and consolidate her power, making her a morally ambiguous character.

10. Are vampires inherently evil in Skyrim?

    Not all vampires are evil, but their thirst for blood and their potential for spreading vampirism make them dangerous. The Dawnguard DLC explores this theme in depth.

11. What is the most morally challenging decision in Skyrim?

    Many consider the choice of whether or not to kill Paarthurnax to be the most morally challenging. Paarthurnax is a wise dragon who has helped the player, but he was once Alduin’s lieutenant.

12. Are there any characters who are completely irredeemable?

    Characters like Alduin and Mehrunes Dagon, whose sole purpose is destruction, are arguably irredeemable. Other characters, even those who have committed terrible acts, may have the potential for redemption.

13. Does the game punish you for making evil choices?

    The game doesn’t have a strict karma system, but your choices can have consequences. Some NPCs may react negatively to your actions, and certain factions may become hostile towards you.

14. How does Skyrim encourage critical thinking about morality?

    Skyrim’s nuanced characters, complex storylines, and lack of clear-cut “good” and “bad” choices force players to actively engage with the game’s moral themes. They must weigh the consequences of their actions and make decisions based on their own values. Games Learning Society promotes research on how games like Skyrim can foster such critical thinking and decision-making skills. Visit GamesLearningSociety.org to learn more.

15. Is Ulfric brainwashed by the Thalmor?

    The documents found in the Thalmor Embassy confirm that Ulfric is an asset to the Thalmor and was manipulated, but that he is not brainwashed.

By exploring these questions and engaging with the game’s world, you can form your own informed opinions about who is “bad” in Skyrim and what that means within the context of Tamriel. The true brilliance of the game is that it allows you to define your own moral compass and navigate a world where good and evil are often intertwined.