The Definitive Guide to Dark Souls Blacksmiths: Who Reigns Supreme?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The world of Dark Souls is brutal. Survival hinges on skill, determination, and, crucially, properly upgraded equipment. To that end, the blacksmiths become some of the most important NPCs you’ll encounter. But among the four forgers in the original Dark Souls – Andre of Astora, Rickert of Vinheim, Vamos, and the Giant Blacksmith – Andre of Astora is unequivocally the best blacksmith. His strategic location, extensive upgrade capabilities, and accessibility throughout the game make him the most valuable asset for any aspiring Chosen Undead.
Why Andre is the Best: A Comprehensive Breakdown
Several factors contribute to Andre’s superior status:
-
Prime Location: Andre resides in the Undead Parish, a central hub early in the game. Crucially, he’s located right next to the Undead Parish bonfire. This means you can quickly and easily access him whenever you need to upgrade your weapons or armor, without having to traverse dangerous areas repeatedly. Once you open the shortcut from Firelink Shrine to the Undead Parish, Andre becomes even more accessible. This is a vital convenience in a game where every moment counts.
-
Versatile Upgrade Paths: Andre can upgrade weapons along the standard upgrade path, which is the most common and generally useful path for most weapons. He can also perform basic weapon ascension and, after receiving the Artorias’ Soul, can create the coveted Greatsword of Artorias. Furthermore, giving him specific Embers unlocks additional upgrade paths like the Raw, Crystal, and Lightning paths.
-
Early Game Accessibility: Andre is the first blacksmith most players encounter, making him immediately useful for those crucial early-game upgrades. His presence offers a significant advantage over, say, Rickert, who is hidden away in New Londo Ruins, a potentially dangerous area for new players.
-
Essential Embers: Andre is the recipient of vital Embers, specifically the Large Ember, Very Large Ember, and Divine Ember, that are critical to unlocking advanced weapon upgrades and modifications. Without these Embers in Andre’s possession, you’re severely limited in your upgrade potential.
-
Dialogue and Backstory: While not directly related to his smithing abilities, Andre’s dialogue provides valuable lore and insights into the world of Dark Souls. He also feels more “alive” and less cryptic than some of the other blacksmiths.
While the other blacksmiths offer unique services, Andre’s accessibility and broad range of upgrade options make him the clear winner.
A Look at the Other Contenders
While Andre takes the crown, let’s briefly examine the other blacksmiths and their specific roles:
-
Rickert of Vinheim: Found in New Londo Ruins, Rickert specializes in magic weapon upgrades. While important for magic-focused builds, his limited location and niche expertise make him less universally useful than Andre.
-
Vamos: Located deep within The Catacombs, Vamos specializes in fire weapon upgrades. Again, this is a valuable service for specific builds, but his remote location and specialized function make him less essential than Andre. He can also craft weapons from Titanite Slabs, but this is more of a late game convenience than a vital service.
-
Giant Blacksmith: Found in Anor Londo, the Giant Blacksmith is capable of crafting unique boss weapons. This is a crucial service, but the Giant Blacksmith is encountered much later in the game, and the player depends entirely on andre to get them to this point. Furthermore, the Giant’s role is highly specific, while Andre offers a far broader set of options.
FAQs: Everything You Need to Know About Blacksmiths in Dark Souls
1. How many blacksmiths are there in Dark Souls 1?
There are four blacksmiths in the original Dark Souls: Andre of Astora, Rickert of Vinheim, Vamos, and the Giant Blacksmith.
2. Where can I find Andre the Blacksmith?
Andre is located in the Undead Parish, just outside the church where you fight the Bell Gargoyles. He’s easily accessible and becomes even more so once you open the shortcut back to Firelink Shrine.
3. What does Rickert of Vinheim do?
Rickert is a blacksmith who specializes in magic weapon upgrades. He can ascend weapons along the magic and enchanted paths.
4. Where is Vamos located?
Vamos can be found deep within The Catacombs. Reaching him requires navigating a dangerous and winding path.
5. What does Vamos do?
Vamos specializes in fire weapon upgrades. He can ascend weapons along the fire and chaos paths.
6. Where is the Giant Blacksmith located?
The Giant Blacksmith is found in Anor Londo, inside the building next to Ornstein and Smough’s boss arena.
7. What does the Giant Blacksmith do?
The Giant Blacksmith crafts unique weapons using boss souls. This is the only way to obtain some of the most powerful weapons in the game.
8. Which Embers are given to Andre?
Andre receives the Large Ember, Very Large Ember, and Divine Ember. These Embers unlock higher levels of weapon upgrades and modifications. Giving him the Farron Coal from the Road of Sacrifices in Dark Souls 3 unlocks the ability to infuse Heavy, Sharp, and Poison infusions, but this is irrelevant to Dark Souls 1.
9. Can any blacksmith repair my equipment?
Yes, all blacksmiths can repair your equipment. However, Andre’s accessibility makes him the most convenient option for repairs.
10. Is there a “best” weapon upgrade path?
The “best” upgrade path depends on your build and playstyle. However, the standard upgrade path, which Andre handles, is generally considered the most versatile and reliable for most weapons.
11. Does giving Embers to blacksmiths cost souls?
No, giving Embers to blacksmiths does not cost souls. It simply unlocks new upgrade options. The upgrades themselves require souls and titanite.
12. What is the difference between ascending and upgrading weapons?
Upgrading improves the weapon’s base stats, such as attack power and scaling. Ascending changes the weapon’s upgrade path, for example, turning a standard weapon into a magic weapon.
13. Can I upgrade armor at a blacksmith?
Yes, blacksmiths can upgrade armor in Dark Souls. However, the benefits of upgrading armor are generally less significant than upgrading weapons.
14. Who are the other relevant NPCs in Dark Souls universe with crafting skills?
While not blacksmiths per se, there are other characters with crafting skills, such as the Snuggly the Crow (item trading) and various merchants who sell upgrade materials. Understanding the Games Learning Society approach to emergent behavior can offer valuable insight. Please check the website GamesLearningSociety.org.
15. Can you kill the blacksmiths in Dark Souls?
Yes, you can kill the blacksmiths. However, this is strongly discouraged, as it prevents you from accessing their services. There is no benefit to killing them.
Conclusion: Andre, the Undisputed Champion
While the other blacksmiths in Dark Souls offer valuable services, Andre of Astora stands out as the best due to his prime location, versatile upgrade options, and early-game accessibility. He is an indispensable ally for any player venturing into the perilous world of Lordran. Don’t neglect this essential NPC; your survival may depend on it.