Who is the Right Person to Kill for Astrid?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The right person to kill for Astrid is ultimately a matter of personal choice, as the game Skyrim allows players to decide who to kill among the three captives, Vasha, Alea, or Belen, with Astrid expressing a preference for killing Vasha, the Khajit, due to his self-admitted crimes. Killing any of the captives will result in Astrid providing the player with the password to the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary‘s “The Black Door”, regardless of the player’s choice.
Understanding the Context
To make an informed decision, it’s essential to understand the context of the situation and the characters involved. Astrid is a key figure in the Dark Brotherhood, a secret society of assassins, and her preferences and actions are guided by the organization’s goals and values.
Making a Decision
When deciding who to kill, players should consider their character’s personality, morals, and goals, as well as the potential consequences of their actions. killing Vasha may be seen as the most justifiable option due to his crimes but ultimately the decision to kill any of the captives will lead to the same outcome in terms of progressing the quest.
FAQs
1. Does it Matter Who You Kill for Astrid?
No, it doesn’t matter who you kill for Astrid, as the outcome of the quest will be the same regardless of the player’s choice.
2. What Happens if You Kill Astrid Right Away?
If you kill Astrid right away, you will begin a new quest line to Destroy the Dark Brotherhood, and you will also be able to retrieve her unique equipment.
3. Is it Better to Join or Destroy the Dark Brotherhood in Skyrim?
The decision to join or destroy the Dark Brotherhood depends on the player’s goals and preferences, with joining providing access to unique quests and equipment, and destroying allowing the player to take on the role of a hero.
4. What are the Disadvantages of Joining the Dark Brotherhood?
The main disadvantage of joining the Dark Brotherhood is the requirement to commit cold-blooded murder, which may conflict with the player’s moral values.
5. Can You Marry Astrid in Skyrim?
No, you cannot marry Astrid in Skyrim, as she is already married and her husband is essential to the quest line.
6. Who is the Hardest to Kill in Skyrim?
The Wispmother, Falmer Warmonger, and Hagraven are some of the most challenging enemies in Skyrim, due to their unique abilities and powerful attacks.
7. Did Astrid Betray the Dark Brotherhood?
Astrid betrays the Dragonborn, not the Dark Brotherhood, in a struggle for control and power over the organization’s leadership.
8. What if I Kill My Wife in Skyrim?
If you kill your wife in Skyrim, you will not be able to marry again, and the game will not provide any consequences or penalties for this action.
9. Can You Do the Dark Brotherhood if You Kill Astrid?
No, if you kill Astrid, you will not be able to complete the Dark Brotherhood quest line, and a new quest line to Destroy the Dark Brotherhood will begin.
10. Why Does Astrid Say Well Done if You Kill Her?
Astrid says “well done” if you kill her because, in her eyes, you have killed the person who deserved death, which is a twisted compliment from a member of the Dark Brotherhood.
11. What Happens if a Dark Brotherhood Initiate Dies?
Dark Brotherhood Initiates are essential characters and cannot die, making them valuable followers for stealthy characters.
12. Can You Marry Anyone in the Dark Brotherhood?
Yes, you can marry certain characters in Skyrim, including some members of the Dark Brotherhood, but this is subject to the character’s interest and availability.
13. Why Would the Dragonborn Join the Dark Brotherhood?
The Dragonborn may join the Dark Brotherhood to gain power, master different fighting styles, or to complete the organization’s quests and contracts.
14. What Do You Miss if You Kill Astrid?
If you kill Astrid, you will miss the opportunity to complete the Dark Brotherhood quest line and access the organization’s unique equipment and contracts.
15. Can You Save Astrid’s Husband in Skyrim?
No, you cannot save Astrid’s husband in Skyrim, as he is essential to the quest line and will die regardless of the player’s actions.