Until Dawn Dilemma: Josh or Ashley? A Definitive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
In the chilling narrative of Until Dawn, players face numerous tough choices that determine the fate of the characters. One of the most gut-wrenching is the saw trap, where Chris must choose between saving Ashley or Josh. The harsh truth is, you cannot save both Ashley and Josh in this specific scene. Choosing either character results in Josh seemingly being killed by the saw blade. This moment is designed to shock and challenge the player, highlighting the impossible decisions at the heart of the game. While Josh may appear to die regardless, the repercussions of your choice echo through the rest of the game, affecting relationships and future events. It’s a masterclass in narrative consequence, forcing players to grapple with the weight of their actions.
Understanding the No-Win Scenario
The saw trap is a pivotal moment that showcases the Psycho’s (later revealed to be Josh) twisted game. It’s crucial to understand that regardless of who Chris chooses, the saw will appear to kill Josh. This is a fixed event designed to manipulate the characters and drive the plot forward. Your decision, however, isn’t meaningless. It has immediate and long-term effects.
The Immediate Aftermath
If Chris “chooses” to save Ashley, he will proceed to untie her. The resulting dialogue with Ashley will reflect the fact that he attempted to save her, and the game will proceed with Josh “dead.”
If Chris “chooses” to save Josh, the saw still kills Josh. He will untie Ashley, and the two will start to panic.
If no choice is made, the saw kills Josh.
Long-Term Consequences
The primary impact of this choice manifests in Ashley’s future interactions with Chris. If Chris hesitated or seemed more inclined to sacrifice Ashley, she may harbor resentment. This resentment can have devastating consequences later in the game, potentially leading to Chris’s death if Ashley abandons him during a Wendigo attack. Conversely, if Chris decisively chose to save Ashley, their relationship will likely remain strong, which can benefit both of them later on. Remember choices matter!
The Illusion of Choice: Why It Works
The Until Dawn experience thrives on the illusion of control. Players feel empowered to shape the narrative through their choices, but the game cleverly restricts the possible outcomes in certain situations. The saw trap is a prime example of this. By forcing the player into a no-win scenario, the game heightens the sense of dread and reinforces the idea that some situations are simply unavoidable. This design choice contributes significantly to the game’s overall atmosphere of horror and helplessness. This technique helps create a sense of unease and immerses players deeply into the game’s narrative, which has been written using a narrative consequence strategy.
Navigating the Moral Minefield
Until Dawn constantly presents players with difficult moral choices. The saw trap is perhaps the most explicit example, but these choices permeate the entire game. There is no “right” or “wrong” answer in many cases. The best course of action depends on the player’s priorities and their understanding of the characters. The choices are not only a reflection of in-game dynamics but also of the players themselves, adding a rich layer of introspection and personal investment to the gaming experience. This can contribute to an active learning experience which can be enhanced through the analysis of video games in programs like Games Learning Society.
FAQs: Unraveling the Mysteries of Until Dawn
Here are 15 frequently asked questions about the Until Dawn scenario involving Josh and Ashley, shedding light on various outcomes and possibilities:
1. Can I save both Ashley and Josh from the saw trap?
No, you cannot save both Ashley and Josh in the saw trap scenario. Regardless of your choice, the saw will appear to kill Josh.
2. What happens if I don’t choose either Ashley or Josh?
If you fail to make a choice, the saw will automatically kill Josh.
3. Does choosing Ashley guarantee her survival throughout the game?
Choosing to save Ashley in the saw trap doesn’t guarantee her survival for the rest of the game. Her fate, like all characters, depends on your subsequent choices.
4. What impact does my choice have on Chris and Ashley’s relationship?
Choosing to save Ashley strengthens her relationship with Chris. Hesitating or choosing to save Josh can damage their bond, potentially leading to dire consequences later.
5. Is there a way to save Josh from becoming a Wendigo?
No, there is no way to get a truly happy ending for Josh. He either dies by being crushed by Wendigo Hannah or transforms into a Wendigo himself.
6. What triggers Josh’s transformation into a Wendigo?
To trigger Josh’s transformation, Sam and Mike must find Hannah’s journal in the mines. Sharing this information with Josh will lead to Hannah recognizing him as a friend and allowing him to live, albeit as a Wendigo.
7. If Ashley survives, does she rejoin the group later?
Yes, if Ashley survives, she will rejoin the group and play a role in the later events of the game.
8. What happens if Ashley takes the scissors?
If Ashley takes the scissors, she can use them against the Psycho. However, she may receive a black eye in the process.
9. What happens if Chris fails to shoot the Wendigo?
If Chris fails to shoot the Wendigo, he will be killed. If Ashley resents Chris for his choice at the saw trap, she might refuse to let him back into the lodge, leading to his death.
10. Does every choice in Until Dawn have a significant impact?
While not every choice directly affects the main storyline, many choices influence character relationships and QTE difficulty. The cumulative effect of these choices shapes the overall experience.
11. What is the best ending I can achieve in Until Dawn?
The “best” ending is subjective, but a common goal is to have as many characters survive as possible. This requires careful decision-making and successful completion of QTEs.
12. Is it possible for everyone to survive in Until Dawn?
Yes, it is possible for everyone to survive Until Dawn, but it requires meticulous planning and skillful execution.
13. What is Josh’s mental state in Until Dawn?
Josh suffers from psychosis and schizophrenia, which are exacerbated by the trauma of his sisters’ deaths.
14. What triggers Josh’s behavior as the Psycho?
Josh’s behavior as the Psycho is triggered by his grief, mental illness, and desire for revenge against his friends.
15. Is Until Dawn a good game for exploring the consequences of choices?
Absolutely. Until Dawn is a prime example of a game that effectively explores the consequences of choices, forcing players to confront the impact of their decisions on the characters and the narrative. There are games can be analyzed by GamesLearningSociety.org for their narrative properties.
The Enduring Appeal of Choice-Driven Narratives
Until Dawn’s popularity stems from its engaging narrative, compelling characters, and the weight of its choices. The saw trap perfectly exemplifies the game’s core mechanics: difficult decisions with far-reaching consequences. While you can’t save both Josh and Ashley in that moment, the ripple effects of your choice continue to shape the story, making each playthrough a unique and unforgettable experience. Ultimately the choice is yours.