Who to Kill in Dark Brotherhood Initiation?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
When initiating into the Dark Brotherhood, a crucial decision involves choosing which of the three captives to kill: Fultheim the Fearless, Alea Quintus, or Vasha the Khajit, with Astrid seemingly preferring the elimination of Vasha, who candidly admits to being a murderer, rapist, and thief. The choice, while pivotal, does not significantly alter the storyline, as the primary objective is to complete the initiation to join the Dark Brotherhood, an underground guild of spiritual assassins.
Understanding the Dark Brotherhood Initiation
The Initiation Process
The initiation process begins after completing the Innocence Lost quest, where the player is abducted by the Dark Brotherhood and taken to an abandoned shack with three hostages. Astrid, the leader of the Falkreath Sanctuary, instructs the player to kill one of the captives, thereby proving their commitment to the Dark Brotherhood.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
What happens if you kill Astrid in the abandoned shack? Killing Astrid in the abandoned shack will result in the failure of the Dark Brotherhood quest and initiate a new quest line to destroy the Dark Brotherhood, allowing the retrieval of her unique equipment.
-
Can you kill Astrid at any time? No, Astrid cannot be killed unless the quest dictates that she is no longer useful, as most NPCs in Skyrim are protected until their role in a quest is fulfilled.
-
Does Astrid betray you in Skyrim? Yes, Astrid betrays the player as part of the Dark Brotherhood storyline, leading to a confrontation that requires her death to progress.
-
Is it worth killing Astrid in Skyrim? Killing Astrid is necessary to progress the Dark Brotherhood storyline, as her death is a pivotal point in the quest line.
-
Which of the 3 captives should I kill in Skyrim? While the choice does not significantly impact the storyline, killing Vasha the Khajit seems to be Astrid’s preferred option, given his criminal admissions.
-
Should I kill Astrid or join the Dark Brotherhood? Joining the Dark Brotherhood provides access to one of Skyrim’s most engaging storylines, while destroying them offers an alternative path where the player can assume the role of a hero of justice.
-
Why does Astrid betray you? Astrid betrays the player because she believes they will eventually usurp her leadership of the Dark Brotherhood, given their role as the Listener and the admiration of other members.
-
Why should you not join the Dark Brotherhood? The primary drawback of joining the Dark Brotherhood is the requirement to commit murder, including the potential targeting of beloved characters, which may conflict with the player’s moral stance or attachment to certain NPCs.
-
Are you evil if you join the Dark Brotherhood? Yes, by joining the Dark Brotherhood, the player character engages in evil actions, including cold-blooded murder, which is a core aspect of the guild’s activities.
-
Can Dark Brotherhood initiates be sacrificed? No, Dark Brotherhood initiates are marked as essential and cannot be killed, preventing them from being used for sacrificial purposes in any quest.
-
How does the Dark Brotherhood kidnap you? After completing Innocence Lost, the player must wait 24 hours (in-game time), after which they will be abducted by the Dark Brotherhood and taken to an abandoned shack to begin their initiation.
-
Can I become the leader of the Dark Brotherhood? Yes, the player can become the leader of the Dark Brotherhood as part of the guild’s quest line, allowing for control over the organization and its activities.
-
Who betrays you in the Dark Brotherhood? Astrid is the primary character who betrays the player in the Dark Brotherhood storyline, although her betrayal is a pivotal plot point rather than an unexpected twist.
-
What happens if you kill Cicero before joining the Dark Brotherhood? Cicero is essential and cannot be killed until the specific quest where his death is required, making it impossible to kill him prematurely.
-
What are the benefits of joining the Dark Brotherhood? Joining the Dark Brotherhood provides access to enchanted equipment, unique weapons, an immortal horse, and other rewards, including a ring that enhances potions by 15%.