Why the Stormcloaks are the Worst Faction in Skyrim
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The Stormcloaks, led by Ulfric Stormcloak, present a compelling narrative of Nordic independence and religious freedom in the face of Imperial oppression. However, a deeper examination reveals a faction riddled with flaws that make them arguably the worst choice in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim. Their short-sighted goals, internal prejudices, and unwitting manipulation by the Thalmor all contribute to a bleak outlook for Skyrim should they achieve victory. They prioritize Nordic supremacy at the expense of Skyrim’s diverse population and are strategically detrimental to the defense of Tamriel against the looming threat of the Aldmeri Dominion. The Stormcloaks’ rebellion ultimately weakens the Empire, playing directly into the Thalmor’s long-term objectives.
The Stain of Xenophobia
Internal Prejudice & Disregard for Non-Nords
One of the most significant issues with the Stormcloaks is their rampant xenophobia. While they claim to be fighting for Skyrim’s freedom, this freedom appears to be reserved solely for Nords. Many non-Nord citizens living in Stormcloak-controlled areas face discrimination, suspicion, and even violence. The treatment of Dunmer refugees in Windhelm is a stark example, relegated to a dilapidated district and largely ignored by the city’s authorities.
This isn’t merely a matter of individual prejudice; it’s embedded in the Stormcloak ideology. They frequently express the belief that Skyrim belongs to the Nords, implicitly suggesting that other races are unwelcome. This ethnic nationalism is a dangerous foundation for any society, and it makes the prospect of a Stormcloak-led Skyrim deeply unsettling for non-Nord players and characters. The Stormcloaks’ exclusionary policies and rhetoric fly in the face of inclusivity and tolerance.
The Thalmor’s Useful Pawn
Unwittingly Serving Elven Agendas
Perhaps the most damning indictment of the Stormcloaks is their unwitting role as Thalmor pawns. The Thalmor, the ruling power of the Aldmeri Dominion, explicitly view Ulfric Stormcloak as an “asset,” recognizing that his rebellion weakens the Empire and furthers their own goals.
The Empire, despite its flaws, remains the primary bulwark against the Dominion. By instigating and prolonging the Skyrim Civil War, the Stormcloaks are diverting Imperial resources and manpower away from the crucial task of defending against future Thalmor aggression. Whether Ulfric is aware of the extent of the Thalmor’s influence or not, the consequences of his actions are clear: he is playing directly into the hands of Skyrim’s greatest enemy. This manipulation alone is a major reason to consider them the worst possible faction.
Short-Sighted Ambitions
Vanity over Vision
Ulfric’s ambition is often interpreted as purely self-serving. Even if driven by a genuine desire to protect Nordic traditions, his rebellion lacks a long-term strategy for Skyrim’s survival. A Stormcloak victory would likely lead to economic instability, diplomatic isolation, and increased vulnerability to external threats.
The focus is on immediate gratification – freeing Skyrim from Imperial rule – without a clear plan for governing a newly independent nation. This lack of foresight is particularly troubling given the complex political landscape of Tamriel and the ever-present danger of the Aldmeri Dominion. Ulfric’s pursuit of power seems to overshadow any genuine concern for the well-being of all Skyrim’s inhabitants.
The Downside of Civil War
Devastation and Division
Choosing the Stormcloaks guarantees bloodshed, destruction, and the further fracturing of Skyrim’s already fragile society. Villages are burned, families are torn apart, and the land is ravaged by war. The economic cost of the conflict is immense, and the long-term consequences for Skyrim’s infrastructure and social fabric are devastating.
Even if the Stormcloaks were to win, the victory would be hollow, achieved at the expense of countless lives and immeasurable suffering. The war leaves deep scars and fosters resentment that could persist for generations. The pursuit of independence should not come at the cost of widespread devastation. Engaging with games can provide opportunities for learning, and the Skyrim Civil War can be used to examine the consequences of political decisions. Check out GamesLearningSociety.org for more on this topic.
Conclusion
While the Stormcloaks may appeal to those who prioritize Nordic independence and religious freedom, their flaws are too significant to ignore. Their xenophobia, unwitting manipulation by the Thalmor, short-sighted ambitions, and the devastating consequences of civil war all contribute to a bleak outlook for a Stormcloak-led Skyrim. The Imperial Legion, despite its own shortcomings, represents a more stable and inclusive path forward, offering the best chance for Skyrim to thrive in the face of external threats.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Are the Stormcloaks objectively evil?
No, the Stormcloaks aren’t necessarily evil, but they represent a perspective driven by nationalism and insularity, leading to negative consequences. Their actions and the broader implications of their victory make them a less desirable faction compared to the Imperial Legion.
2. Is Ulfric Stormcloak a good person?
Ulfric’s motivations are complex. Some see him as a freedom fighter, while others view him as a power-hungry demagogue. Regardless of his intentions, his actions have detrimental consequences for Skyrim and its people, making his moral standing questionable.
3. Do all Stormcloaks hate non-Nords?
Not all Stormcloaks harbor explicit hatred for non-Nords, but the faction’s ideology promotes Nordic supremacy, which leads to discrimination and prejudice against other races within their territory. This prejudice is a significant factor when evaluating the faction’s moral standing.
4. Does choosing the Stormcloaks affect gameplay significantly?
Yes, choosing the Stormcloaks will make Imperial camps and forts hostile, changing the dynamics of exploring Skyrim. The narrative and dialogues also shift to reflect the Stormcloak perspective on the civil war.
5. What are the potential long-term consequences of a Stormcloak victory?
A Stormcloak victory could lead to economic instability, diplomatic isolation, and increased vulnerability to the Aldmeri Dominion. The weakened Empire would struggle to defend against future Thalmor aggression, jeopardizing the entire continent of Tamriel.
6. Are the Imperials entirely blameless in the Skyrim Civil War?
No, the Imperials are not blameless. The White-Gold Concordat, which banned the worship of Talos, is a major source of resentment in Skyrim. The Empire’s perceived weakness and subservience to the Thalmor fueled the Stormcloak rebellion.
7. Can you play as a non-Nord in the Stormcloak faction?
Yes, you can play as any race in the Stormcloak faction. However, the narrative implications and the treatment your character receives may not be as favorable as if you were a Nord.
8. Does joining the Stormcloaks lock you out of certain quests?
Yes, joining the Stormcloaks locks you out of the Imperial Legion questline and vice versa. However, you can still access most other quests and storylines in the game regardless of your faction choice.
9. Is there a way to prevent the Skyrim Civil War?
No, there is no way to completely prevent the Skyrim Civil War in the base game. Even during the main questline, the truce is only temporary, and the war will resume unless one side is defeated.
10. Are the Stormcloaks stronger than the Imperial Legion?
Neither faction is definitively stronger. The balance of power shifts based on the player’s actions and choices throughout the civil war questline. Both sides have strengths and weaknesses that can be exploited.
11. How do the Thalmor benefit from the Skyrim Civil War?
The Thalmor benefit from the Skyrim Civil War because it weakens the Empire, their primary opposition. A divided Empire is less capable of resisting Thalmor expansion and influence.
12. Do the Stormcloaks have any allies outside of Skyrim?
The Stormcloaks have limited allies outside of Skyrim. Their focus is primarily on Nordic interests, which makes it difficult for them to form strong alliances with other factions or nations.
13. What happens to non-Nords in Skyrim if the Stormcloaks win?
The fate of non-Nords in a Stormcloak-controlled Skyrim is uncertain. While not explicitly stated, the prevailing xenophobia and Nordic supremacist ideology suggest that they would face discrimination and unequal treatment.
14. Can you betray the Stormcloaks and join the Imperials?
Yes, you can betray the Stormcloaks during the quest “The Jagged Crown.” Instead of returning the crown to Ulfric, you can hand it over to General Tullius and join the Imperial Legion.
15. What is the main reason to choose the Imperial Legion over the Stormcloaks?
The main reason to choose the Imperial Legion is that they represent a more stable and inclusive option for Skyrim’s future. The Empire, despite its flaws, is better equipped to defend against the Aldmeri Dominion and ensure the long-term prosperity of all its citizens.