Why Are There Two Roundtable Holds in Elden Ring?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The existence of two Roundtable Holds in Elden Ring is a source of much confusion and intrigue among players. The most plausible explanation for this phenomenon lies in the game’s lore and narrative, particularly surrounding the events of the Shattering and the actions of Queen Marika. In essence, the Roundtable Hold that players can fast travel to is not the original. The original Roundtable Hold was located within Leyndell, the Royal Capital, and it was destroyed during the cataclysmic events of the Shattering. The version that players use as a safe haven is, in fact, a meticulously crafted copy, placed in a different realm or dimension entirely by Marika. This action was undertaken to preserve a sanctuary for the Tarnished warriors who are tasked with restoring the Elden Ring and becoming Elden Lord.
The original Roundtable Hold in Leyndell served as a gathering place for champions chosen by the Two Fingers – the manifestations of the Greater Will. These champions would gather, discuss, and strategize under the guidance of the Two Fingers in their quest to become Elden Lord. However, the Shattering, a pivotal event that saw the Elden Ring broken, devastated the Lands Between, including the capital and, crucially, the Roundtable Hold. The version players access is a sanctuary crafted to maintain the path for Tarnished, providing guidance and assistance along the way. The copy ensures a safe space for the Tarnished, away from the direct dangers and chaos of the Lands Between.
The copy of the Roundtable Hold acts as a necessary hub, allowing players to interact with various NPCs like Hewg, the blacksmith, Fia, the Deathbed Companion, and the Twin Maiden Husks. Furthermore, this iteration is intrinsically linked to the Erdtree, meaning that when the Erdtree is set ablaze, the Roundtable Hold reflects that state, further solidifying its connection to the fabric of the world. This burning of the Roundtable Hold does not diminish its functionality or safety, highlighting its unique nature. It represents the shifting state of the Lands Between, a reflection of the challenges faced by the Tarnished. This connection to the Erdtree also underscores the importance of the Roundtable Hold in the grand scheme of the Elden Ring’s lore.
Unraveling the Mysteries: The Purpose of the Two Roundtable Holds
The presence of two Roundtable Holds, therefore, isn’t simply a mistake or an oversight. The distinction between the original and the copy speaks volumes about the game’s core narrative. It illuminates the power and agency of Queen Marika and underscores the catastrophic impact of the Shattering. The original Roundtable Hold, now a ruin within Leyndell, symbolizes the fall of the old order and the crumbling of the Golden Era. In contrast, the sanctuary version represents the hope and guidance offered to the Tarnished, a beacon in the midst of chaos. The copy ensures a continued path to becoming Elden Lord despite the events of the Shattering.
The decision to place the copy in a separate dimension adds another layer of depth. It shields the sanctuary from the immediate dangers that pervade the Lands Between and signifies the unique state of the Tarnished. This separate realm also isolates the Tarnished from direct interference by the other entities, thereby enabling them to complete their quest with a measure of autonomy. It showcases Marika’s subtle machinations, manipulating events to bring about her desired outcome. The Roundtable Hold is not just a convenient location for gameplay, but a carefully designed component of the game’s rich and multi-layered story. It reflects the game’s themes of fate, destiny, and free will.
FAQs: Exploring the Roundtable Hold in Detail
Here are some frequently asked questions (FAQs) to further expand on the information surrounding the Roundtable Hold and its significance within Elden Ring.
### 1. Where is the Real Roundtable Hold Located?
The real Roundtable Hold is located within the walls of Leyndell, the Royal Capital. This is the original, now destroyed, version that was used before the Shattering. Players can find ruins of it later in the game.
### 2. Who Are the Two Fingers in the Roundtable Hold?
The Two Fingers are manifestations of the Greater Will, and they act as guides for the demigods, indicating the path that they must take. They are the primary representative of the Greater Will within the game, along with the Elden Beast. The Two Fingers in the Roundtable Hold are thought to be corrupted and senile.
### 3. Does the Roundtable Hold Get Destroyed?
Yes, the Roundtable Hold, or rather its copy, is set ablaze. This happens when the Erdtree is burned and is a symbolic representation of the events that unfold in the game. The state of the Roundtable Hold is intertwined with the state of the Erdtree.
### 4. Why is the Roundtable Hold on Fire?
The Roundtable Hold is on fire because it’s intrinsically linked to the Erdtree. When the Erdtree is burned, the Roundtable Hold mirrors that state. The belief is that the Hold may even exist inside the Erdtree itself.
### 5. What Triggers Melina’s Invitation to the Roundtable Hold?
Melina will invite you to the Roundtable Hold after you activate a Site of Grace in the open world. These must not be located in Limgrave or the Weeping Peninsula, and must be outside of caves, tunnels, and catacombs. Resting is not necessary for this to trigger, only the unlocking of the Site of Grace.
### 6. Who is the Enemy in the Roundtable Hold?
Mad Tongue Alberich is an invader that players will encounter in the Roundtable Hold. He can be particularly challenging, especially for lower-level players who enter the Hold early.
### 7. What Leads to the Ruination of the Round Table?
In a general lore context, such as the Arthurian legend, the ruination of the Round Table is due to conflicting loyalties between King Arthur and Lancelot. However, within Elden Ring, the concept of the Round Table’s downfall is more closely linked to the Shattering and the burning of the Erdtree.
### 8. How Do You Leave the Roundtable Hold?
You can leave the Roundtable Hold by fast-traveling to any previously unlocked Site of Grace using the map.
### 9. Should You Let Fia Hold You?
Letting Fia hold you grants you Baldachin’s Blessing, a consumable that temporarily boosts your poise. There is a minor health debuff until it’s used, and you can return for additional blessings.
### 10. Are the Two Fingers Corrupted?
The Two Fingers in the game appear to be corrupted and senile. They were once revered for their wisdom but have fallen into disrepair along with the Erdtree.
### 11. How Do You Get to the Roundtable Hold Without Melina?
You can unlock the Roundtable Hold by resting at one of two Sites of Grace: either the Stormveil Main Gate (after defeating Margit) or the Lake-Facing Cliffs, directly north of Stormveil Castle after defeating Godrick.
### 12. Who is the Red Apparition in the Roundtable Hold?
The red apparition is the Dung Eater. He will appear later in the game after you make it to Leyndell, the Royal Capital.
### 13. Who is Nepheli Loux?
Nepheli Loux is found in the Roundtable Hold, located in the room outside the library. Her adoptive father is Gideon Ofnir, leader of the Roundtable Hold. There are theories that her real father is Godfrey, First Elden Lord.
### 14. What is Fia Known For in Roundtable Hold?
Fia, the Deathbed Companion is known for offering hugs, which grant the player the Baldachin’s Blessing. Using this item increases poise but decreases max HP until used.
### 15. Are Melina and Ranni Related?
It is heavily implied that Melina and Ranni are sisters through their ties to Queen Marika. Melina’s dialogue suggests she was born at the foot of the Erdtree, and her mother is within it, which are strong connections to Marika.
The presence of two Roundtable Holds is, therefore, more than just a narrative quirk. It is a reflection of the complex lore, the catastrophic events that have shaped the world, and the ongoing battle for power. The differences between these two spaces highlight the depth of the Elden Ring’s story and provide important context to the player’s journey. The copied Roundtable Hold offers a vital sanctuary for the Tarnished while serving as a reminder of the shattered world and the quest to restore it.