Why Dark Souls 3 Should Have Had an Easy Mode
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Dark Souls 3, a masterpiece of gothic horror and challenging combat, stands as a testament to FromSoftware’s dedication to creating demanding, yet rewarding experiences. However, the argument for including an easy mode stems from a desire for greater accessibility, allowing a wider audience to appreciate the game’s rich lore, intricate world design, and unique atmosphere without being completely gated by its notorious difficulty. An easy mode wouldn’t detract from the core experience for veteran players; instead, it would open the gates to those who appreciate the artistic and narrative aspects of the game but lack the time, reflexes, or inclination for its grueling combat. This is not about dumbing down the game, but about offering an alternative pathway for players to engage with this world, without feeling completely discouraged.
The Accessibility Argument
The primary argument for an easy mode hinges on accessibility. While the “git gud” mentality is prevalent within the Souls community, it inherently excludes a significant portion of potential players.
Opening the Doors to a Wider Audience
Many gamers face various challenges that make Dark Souls 3‘s default difficulty inaccessible. These include:
- Physical disabilities: Some players may have limited motor skills or coordination, making the precise timing and rapid reflexes required for combat difficult, if not impossible.
- Time constraints: Many individuals have demanding work schedules, family responsibilities, or other commitments that leave them with limited time for gaming. Investing dozens of hours into mastering the game’s mechanics may not be feasible.
- Personal preferences: Not everyone enjoys or seeks out extreme difficulty. Some gamers simply prefer to experience the story and world of a game without the constant stress of dying repeatedly.
- New gamers: Newer gamers who are wanting to get into this series, or gaming in general, may find Dark Souls 3’s initial difficulty frustrating and disheartening.
An easy mode could address these issues by offering reduced enemy damage, simpler AI, or other modifications that make the game more manageable for a broader range of players.
Preserving the Core Experience
Critiques of easy modes often claim that they dilute the core experience and diminish the sense of accomplishment that comes with overcoming challenges. However, a well-designed easy mode can avoid these pitfalls by:
- Focusing on reducing enemy aggression and damage: Reducing the damage enemies inflict would allow players to make more mistakes without being instantly punished.
- Offering more generous healing options: Increased estus flask capacity or faster healing animations could provide players with more sustain in combat.
- Simplifying enemy attack patterns: Making enemy attack telegraphs more obvious or reducing the number of attacks in their combos could make combat easier to read and react to.
It’s important to remember that Dark Souls 3 is not just about difficulty; it’s about the immersive world, the intriguing characters, and the compelling lore. An easy mode would allow players to appreciate these aspects of the game without being constantly overwhelmed by its combat.
Addressing Common Concerns
The debate surrounding difficulty settings in Souls games is often contentious. Let’s address some of the most common concerns:
“It’s Not a Souls Game Anymore”
The argument that an easy mode would fundamentally change the nature of Dark Souls is a common one. However, providing a toggleable easy mode that doesn’t impact the original difficulty leaves the core experience completely untouched for those who seek it. Veterans can continue to enjoy the challenging gameplay they’ve come to love, while others can explore the world in a less punishing environment.
“The Difficulty is the Point”
The difficulty in Dark Souls is undoubtedly a defining characteristic. However, it shouldn’t be the only point. The game’s developers invested immense effort into crafting a rich and immersive world, complete with detailed environments, compelling characters, and a deep, intricate lore. An easy mode would allow more players to experience and appreciate these aspects of the game.
“Just Use Summons”
While summoning other players for assistance can certainly make the game easier, it’s not a perfect solution. Relying on summons can detract from the solo experience, and finding reliable and skilled teammates can be challenging. Furthermore, summoning other players can increase the difficulty of encounters due to increased enemy health and aggression.
“It Will Ruin the Community”
Some fear that an easy mode would divide the community, leading to elitism and resentment. However, if implemented correctly, an easy mode could actually strengthen the community by bringing in new players who might otherwise be intimidated by the game’s difficulty. These new players could then contribute to discussions, share their experiences, and potentially even transition to the standard difficulty as they become more comfortable with the game’s mechanics.
Learning Through Struggle
The game is also about learning. But that learning may not be possible, or may not be desirable for a wide audience. Those who are wanting to enjoy the game’s art and other qualities, should have that option.
Conclusion
The inclusion of an easy mode in Dark Souls 3 would not diminish the game’s integrity or appeal to veteran players. Instead, it would broaden its accessibility, allowing a wider audience to experience the game’s rich lore, intricate world design, and unique atmosphere without being completely gated by its notorious difficulty. It’s about offering a choice and creating a more inclusive gaming experience. The GamesLearningSociety.org embraces the idea that there are different ways to explore and enjoy video games, encouraging the industry to consider more diverse modes and settings.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are 15 frequently asked questions addressing common concerns and providing further information about the potential implementation of an easy mode in Dark Souls 3:
1. What specific changes would an easy mode likely implement in Dark Souls 3?
An easy mode could implement a number of changes, including:
- Reduced enemy damage: Decreasing the amount of damage enemies inflict would allow players to make more mistakes without being instantly punished.
- Simplified enemy AI: Making enemies less aggressive or reducing the complexity of their attack patterns could make combat easier to read and react to.
- Increased player health and stamina: Giving players more health and stamina would increase their survivability and allow them to make more mistakes.
- More generous healing options: Increased estus flask capacity or faster healing animations could provide players with more sustain in combat.
- Reduced enemy health: Lowering the health of enemies, especially bosses, would shorten encounters and make them less demanding.
2. Would an easy mode impact the availability of achievements or trophies?
Potentially, but not necessarily. A well-designed easy mode could be implemented in a way that doesn’t affect the core achievements. Some games choose to disable certain achievements on easier difficulties, while others allow players to earn all achievements regardless of the difficulty setting.
3. How would an easy mode affect the online experience and PvP interactions?
Ideally, an easy mode would be completely separate from the standard difficulty, preventing players on easy mode from interacting with players on standard difficulty in PvP or co-op. This would ensure that the experience for players on standard difficulty remains unchanged.
4. Could an easy mode be implemented as a post-launch patch?
Yes, it’s technically possible. FromSoftware could release a patch that adds an easy mode to Dark Souls 3. However, it would require significant development effort to properly balance and implement.
5. Would an easy mode devalue the sense of accomplishment for players who beat the game on standard difficulty?
No, because players who beat the game on standard difficulty have the original difficulty of Dark Souls 3 available, and that is its own accomplishment. The existence of an easy mode does not diminish the achievements of players who choose to tackle the game’s default challenge.
6. How does Dark Souls 3’s difficulty compare to other Souls-like games, like Elden Ring or Bloodborne?
Dark Souls 3 is generally considered to be more linear and focused than Elden Ring, which is an open-world game. Bloodborne, on the other hand, emphasizes faster-paced combat and a more aggressive playstyle. The difficulty of each game is subjective and depends on individual playstyles and preferences.
7. What are some alternatives to an easy mode that could improve accessibility?
Besides an easy mode, other options could include:
- More detailed tutorials: Providing more comprehensive tutorials could help new players understand the game’s mechanics and systems.
- Adjustable difficulty parameters: Allowing players to customize individual difficulty parameters, such as enemy damage or healing rates, could provide a more tailored experience.
- More accessible summoning system: Making it easier to find and summon other players for assistance could help players overcome difficult challenges.
8. Is there any indication that FromSoftware would ever consider adding an easy mode to Dark Souls 3 or their other games?
Historically, FromSoftware has been resistant to the idea of adding easy modes to their games. However, the gaming landscape is constantly evolving, and player expectations are changing. It’s possible that FromSoftware may reconsider their stance in the future.
9. How would an easy mode impact the speedrunning community?
An easy mode would likely be irrelevant to the speedrunning community, as speedrunners typically focus on optimizing their routes and strategies within the standard difficulty.
10. Would an easy mode affect the game’s critical reception?
It’s difficult to say definitively. Some critics might applaud the increased accessibility, while others might criticize the perceived dilution of the core experience. However, if implemented correctly, an easy mode could potentially broaden the game’s appeal and lead to more positive reviews from a wider range of players.
11. What is the target audience for an easy mode in Dark Souls 3?
The target audience would be players who are interested in the world, lore, and atmosphere of Dark Souls 3, but are intimidated or discouraged by its high difficulty. This includes players with disabilities, those with limited time for gaming, and those who simply prefer a less challenging experience.
12. How would an easy mode impact the game’s replayability?
For some players, an easy mode could actually increase replayability by allowing them to experience the game from a different perspective or try out different builds without the constant pressure of dying repeatedly.
13. Could an easy mode be implemented as a separate “adventure mode” or “story mode”?
Yes, that’s a viable option. A separate mode could be designed to focus on exploration and narrative, with reduced combat difficulty and more generous resources.
14. What are some examples of other challenging games that have successfully implemented accessibility options?
Games like Celeste and Hades have been praised for their accessibility options, which allow players to customize the difficulty to their liking without compromising the core gameplay experience. These options often include features like assist mode, adjustable game speed, and customizable control schemes.
15. Why should game developers consider accessibility options more broadly?
Accessibility options are essential for creating inclusive gaming experiences that cater to a diverse range of players. By providing options like adjustable difficulty settings, customizable controls, and visual aids, developers can ensure that more people can enjoy and appreciate their games. The Games Learning Society champions the need for increased exploration of innovative gameplay and design strategies that promote learning and engagement for a wider audience.