Why did Astrid betray you?

▶

Astrid betrayed you because she feared being overthrown as the leader of the Dark Brotherhood, and she believed that you, as the Listener, posed a significant threat to her power and authority. Her betrayal was motivated by a desire to maintain control and eliminate potential rivals, which ultimately led her to try to kill you and preserve her position within the organization.

Understanding Astrid’s Motivations

The Fear of Being Overthrown

Astrid’s decision to betray you was driven by her fear of being overthrown as the leader of the Dark Brotherhood. As the Listener, you represented a potential threat to her power and authority, and she believed that eliminating you would help her maintain control over the organization.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Why does Astrid want you to kill Vasha? Astrid prefers you to kill Vasha, the Khajit, because he describes himself as a murderer, a rapist, and a thief, making him a more desirable target.
2. What happens if you kill Astrid? If you kill Astrid, you will initiate the “Destroy the Dark Brotherhood” quest and be able to retrieve her unique equipment.
3. Can you marry Astrid from the Dark Brotherhood? No, you cannot marry Astrid without mods, as she does not have the married lines recorded for her voice type.
4. Is the Dark Brotherhood good or bad? The Dark Brotherhood is generally considered neutral evil, as they kill for money but have rules that govern their behavior.
5. Who betrays the Dark Brotherhood? You, the player, have the option to betray the Dark Brotherhood by killing Astrid and initiating the “Destroy the Dark Brotherhood” quest.
6. What if I don’t kill Astrid? If you don’t kill Astrid, all the members of the Brotherhood will become un-killable, and you will not be able to initiate the “Destroy the Dark Brotherhood” quest.
7. Can we save Astrid? No, Astrid is an essential character who cannot be killed until the “With Friends Like These” quest is completed.
8. Why is Astrid bad? Astrid is considered bad because she is condescending, power-hungry, and paranoid, which leads her to make questionable decisions.
9. What are the benefits of killing Astrid? Killing Astrid allows you to initiate the “Destroy the Dark Brotherhood” quest and retrieve her unique equipment.
10. Is the Night Mother evil? The Night Mother is generally considered evil because she sanctions murder and is culturally taboo to discuss.
11. What should you avoid in Skyrim? You should avoid spreading your skills too thin, stealing from chickens, and fighting with guards, among other things.
12. Who is guilty in the Dark Brotherhood quest? It is unclear which hostage is guilty in the Dark Brotherhood quest, as each character provides a vague backstory.
13. Which faction is best in Skyrim? The Dark Brotherhood is often considered one of the best factions in Skyrim, due to its unique storyline and playstyle.
14. Can the Dark Brotherhood be saved? You can save the Dark Brotherhood itself, but not its members, by completing the questline and seeing it through.
15. Will the Dark Brotherhood forever end? The Dark Brotherhood questline will continue indefinitely until you choose to destroy the organization or stop completing contracts.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Astrid’s betrayal was a result of her fear of being overthrown and her desire to maintain control over the Dark Brotherhood. By understanding her motivations and the consequences of her actions, you can make informed decisions about how to proceed in the game. Whether you choose to kill Astrid and destroy the Dark Brotherhood or continue to work with them, the game offers a rich and complex storyline that allows you to explore the world of Skyrim in a unique and engaging way.