The Seven-Year Case: Why L.A. Noire Took So Long To Develop
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of why L.A. Noire took a staggering seven years to develop isn’t a simple one. It wasn’t just a case of a particularly ambitious project; it was a confluence of factors, including cutting-edge technology, a massive script, complex development challenges, changing publishers, platform shifts, and ultimately, severe internal problems at the development studio, Team Bondi. In short, L.A. Noire’s protracted development was a perfect storm of ambition and adversity. Let’s break down the elements contributing to this extended timeline.
The Technological Frontier: Motion Scanning and Facial Realism
Groundbreaking Tech
One of the primary reasons for the lengthy development was the game’s revolutionary approach to facial animation. Team Bondi partnered with Depth Analysis, an Australian company that provided a sophisticated motion capture system using 32 cameras. This system captured every subtle nuance of an actor’s facial expressions. The ambition was to translate these nuanced performances directly into the game, a level of realism that had never been seen before. This motion capture technology was groundbreaking, requiring significant time and resources to implement, fine-tune, and integrate into the game engine. The sheer volume of data generated, and the work required to render the performances believably for hundreds of character interactions was enormous.
The Facial Animation Bottleneck
The system created an unprecedented level of realism, but it was also incredibly demanding in terms of production. The sheer volume of face scans needed for the large cast of characters, coupled with the integration and rendering of these complex animations, consumed a significant portion of the development time. This wasn’t just about making faces move; it was about making them move believably, reflecting the subtle emotions needed to make the interrogation system work. This new technology, while a technical marvel, dramatically increased development time compared to more traditional animation techniques.
The Ambitious Scope: Script and Open World
A Massive Script
L.A. Noire wasn’t just about cutting-edge facial animation. It also featured an exceptionally lengthy and detailed script. The game is structured around multiple crime desks, each featuring a series of intricate cases. Each case had multiple lines of dialogue, branching paths depending on player choices, and unique interrogation sequences. The sheer scale of the writing alone was a huge undertaking. The script required careful crafting to ensure all dialogue choices and evidence connected seamlessly throughout the game.
Recreating 1947 Los Angeles
The development team also set out to meticulously recreate Los Angeles in 1947. This meant developing a vast open world filled with meticulously researched architecture, vehicles, and even period-accurate clothing. The effort required to build and populate a digital recreation of 1940s LA to such a degree of detail was a massive undertaking, further inflating the development timeline.
The Development Nightmare: Management and Publishing
Publisher Problems
Adding to the complexity, L.A. Noire changed publishers during development. This switch likely involved renegotiating contracts, transferring development assets, and potentially even altering some aspects of the game’s design to align with the new publisher’s preferences. These types of interruptions frequently lead to significant delays in game development.
Internal Turmoil at Team Bondi
Perhaps the most damaging factor was the internal issues at Team Bondi. Numerous reports emerged about the studio’s excessively long working hours and poor management style. These led to public complaints from staff members and a toxic work environment. Such conditions are hardly conducive to efficient game development. This internal turmoil likely contributed to the project’s many delays.
The Cost of Ambition
Ultimately, the seven-year development of L.A. Noire was a testament to the ambition of its vision, but also the challenges of trying to push the boundaries of technology and game design. The game was an incredible achievement, however the combination of groundbreaking technology, an ambitious scope, and severe internal problems culminated in a uniquely troubled, but ultimately impactful, development. The game’s success is particularly remarkable when considering the hardships faced by the development team.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About L.A. Noire
What is L.A. Noire’s genre?
L.A. Noire is primarily a crime thriller and detective game set in an open-world environment. It combines investigation, interrogation, and action elements.
Was L.A. Noire a commercial success?
Despite the lengthy development and studio troubles, L.A. Noire was a commercial success, selling nearly five million copies.
Why did Team Bondi shut down after L.A. Noire’s release?
Team Bondi closed due to a combination of severe debt, internal management issues, and the financial burden of the long and difficult development.
Is there a sequel to L.A. Noire?
There is no direct sequel to L.A. Noire. However, there have been reports about a spiritual successor that would use similar mechanics and technology.
How long does it take to complete L.A. Noire?
Focusing on the main story, L.A. Noire takes around 25 hours to complete. To achieve 100% completion, it typically requires about 46 hours.
What is the longest desk in L.A. Noire?
The Homicide desk is the longest section of the game, featuring six interconnected murder cases.
Can I play L.A. Noire after the ending?
Yes, you can. You can revisit any case or explore the open world via the “Cases” menu and select “The Streets of LA (Free Roam)“.
What is the core mechanic in L.A. Noire?
The core mechanic in L.A. Noire is the interrogation system. Players analyze facial cues of suspects and witnesses to determine if they are telling the truth or lying.
Why is L.A. Noire considered realistic?
The game’s facial animation is what made L.A. Noire’s realism stand out. The sophisticated motion capture technology developed by Depth Analysis captured a nuanced level of detail not previously seen in video games.
What is the rating for L.A. Noire?
L.A. Noire is typically rated 18+ due to its mature themes, including drug use, and some brief nudity.
How much of L.A. Noire is based on real events?
L.A. Noire draws inspiration from real-life events and murders that occurred in 1947 Los Angeles, although they are fictionalized for the game’s narrative. The ‘Black Dahlia’ case is a notable example.
Who is the main antagonist in L.A. Noire?
Garrett Mason, also known as the Black Dahlia Killer, is the primary antagonist of the Homicide desk cases.
Is L.A. Noire expensive?
The game’s price can be considered higher than some other older titles. This is likely due to its production value, and unique nature. The Nintendo Switch version, in particular, can be more expensive due to cartridge manufacturing costs.
What happens if you fail an interrogation?
Even if you make incorrect accusations during interrogations, the overall narrative of the game progresses. You might get a lower rating at the end of the case and miss out on some small details but the story continues.
What is the “true ending” in L.A. Noire?
The “true ending” is achieved by achieving 100% completion and 5-star ratings on all cases. The primary change is that Detective Jack Kelso sacrifices himself to save Detective Cole Phelps.