Why Did Micah Hate Arthur? Unraveling the Twisted Relationship in Red Dead Redemption 2
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The dynamic between Arthur Morgan and Micah Bell is one of the most compelling and tragic aspects of Red Dead Redemption 2. While the game’s narrative might initially suggest a mutual dislike, delving deeper reveals a far more complex and, ultimately, one-sided animosity. It’s crucial to understand that Micah’s “hatred” for Arthur was not a straightforward emotion. It was a toxic concoction of envy, resentment, and a deep-seated desire for power, fueled by his psychopathic nature. Micah didn’t simply dislike Arthur; he actively sought to undermine and destroy him, alongside the entire Van der Linde gang, to elevate his own position.
Micah’s motivation wasn’t born from a personal grievance in the traditional sense. Instead, it stemmed from a twisted admiration and a deep insecurity. He recognized Arthur’s strength, both physical and within the gang’s hierarchy, and saw him as an obstacle to his own ambitions. Micah wanted the respect and influence Arthur commanded, and he was willing to achieve it through manipulation, betrayal, and violence. Thus, Micah’s “hatred” was more about his inability to be as valued and respected as Arthur. He viewed Arthur as a symbol of everything he craved and couldn’t naturally achieve.
Micah’s arrival and his immediate positioning next to Dutch, the gang’s leader, also triggered this simmering animosity. Micah saw Arthur’s close relationship with Dutch, and especially Arthur’s position as the muscle and long time loyal member of the gang, as a threat. He envied Arthur’s long-standing trust with Dutch, making it a primary target for manipulation. This envy, coupled with his innate psychopathy, led him to systematically undermine Arthur and the gang from within. His betrayal was not a sudden act but a calculated process of sowing discord and manipulating those around him to further his goals, making it clear why his actions were so devastating.
The Root of Micah’s Resentment
Micah’s resentment towards Arthur is layered, stemming from several key factors:
Envy and Ambition
Micah’s primary motivation was his insatiable desire for power and control. He observed Arthur’s position as the gang’s enforcer and his respected status with Dutch and many gang members. Instead of earning his own place through loyalty and merit, Micah chose the path of treachery, seeking to displace Arthur to gain the power he craved.
A Twisted Form of Admiration
Interestingly, Micah displayed a distorted form of admiration for Arthur’s toughness and effectiveness. He later admits to Cleet and Joe that he recognized Arthur’s strength early on. This recognition fueled his desire to surpass Arthur and ultimately dominate him, solidifying his own superiority. The “cowpoke” moniker, initially dismissive, becomes a twisted sign of that recognition.
Psychopathic Tendencies
Micah’s core personality played a significant role. His psychopathic traits, including a lack of empathy, manipulative behavior, and a tendency toward violence, fueled his actions. He saw Arthur not as a fellow human but as a tool or an obstacle in his path, which allowed him to betray and harm Arthur without remorse.
The Betrayal
The culminating event that cemented Micah’s “hatred” was his betrayal of the gang by selling information to the Pinkertons. This betrayal directly led to the downfall of the gang, the death of several members, and Arthur’s own tragic demise. Micah’s actions solidified his role as the ultimate antagonist to Arthur’s heroic journey, demonstrating the extent of his malicious intent. He not only wanted to dethrone Arthur but also to destroy what Arthur and the gang had built.
The Climax of Their Conflict
The final confrontation between Arthur and Micah was not just a physical battle; it was a culmination of their entire relationship. Micah, emboldened by his manipulation of Dutch and the gang, felt he was finally in a position to eliminate his perceived rival. Micah’s attempts to kill Arthur were fueled by his relentless pursuit of power and his psychopathic indifference to human life. The tragic ending where Micah directly or indirectly causes Arthur’s death further shows his hatred was ultimately his desire to completely dominate and erase Arthur.
The conflict between Arthur and Micah is not simply a clash of good versus evil; it’s a portrayal of the destructive nature of ambition when combined with psychopathic tendencies. Micah didn’t just hate Arthur; he saw him as a symbol of everything he was not, making his hatred a manifestation of his own dark and twisted desires.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Did Micah Ever Like Arthur?
No, despite any superficial interactions, Micah never genuinely liked Arthur. His interactions were calculated and manipulative. He recognized Arthur’s strength, but his admiration was twisted by envy and the desire to surpass him.
2. What Started the Feud Between Arthur and Micah?
The feud didn’t start with a single event but evolved over time. Micah’s arrival, his proximity to Dutch, and his immediate efforts to undermine the gang’s existing hierarchy all contributed to the animosity.
3. Why Did Micah Call Arthur “Cowpoke”?
Micah initially used “cowpoke” as a derogatory term. However, it later evolved into a twisted form of respect after he recognized Arthur’s strength during a confrontation in Strawberry.
4. Could Arthur Have Beaten Micah If He Wasn’t Sick?
Yes, it’s highly likely that a healthy Arthur could have defeated Micah. Arthur was physically stronger, and his tuberculosis significantly weakened him, thus limiting his ability to fight back.
5. Did Dutch Know Micah Was a Rat?
Not initially. Dutch was blinded by Micah’s manipulation and his own narcissistic tendencies. He was suspicious of everyone after the Saint Denis heist, but Micah’s lies successfully diverted suspicion.
6. Why Did Dutch Believe Micah Over Arthur?
Dutch was vulnerable due to the gang’s failures and his own paranoia. Micah exploited these weaknesses and played on Dutch’s fear of betrayal, which was not out of the ordinary with the gang’s situation at the time.
7. Why Was Dutch So Loyal to Micah?
Micah saved Dutch’s life early on in their relationship, creating a sense of debt that Dutch felt he owed. However, Micah’s lies and manipulations also kept Dutch close.
8. What Was Micah’s Mental Illness?
Based on his actions and behavior, Micah displays many traits of a psychopath. He lacks empathy, is manipulative, and shows a complete disregard for the well-being of others.
9. How Did Micah Get His Scar?
If Arthur has high honor during their final showdown, he will slash Micah’s face with a knife, leaving a prominent scar over his eye.
10. Did Micah Get Tuberculosis?
No, there’s no indication that Micah contracts tuberculosis. Despite blood exposure during the events that give Arthur TB, Micah does not get the disease.
11. Was Arthur a Better Shot Than Micah?
Yes, Arthur was widely considered the best shot in the gang. Even while dying, he draws his weapon faster than Micah, illustrating his superior skill.
12. Why Did Dutch Eventually Shoot Micah?
Dutch shot Micah as a way of acknowledging the wrong he had done and to honor Arthur, his fallen surrogate son. It was a form of redemption and an admission that he had been misled by Micah.
13. Did Sadie Have a Crush on Arthur?
There are strong hints that Sadie had romantic feelings for Arthur, stemming from the trust and respect they shared. Arthur also reminded her of her late husband, which strengthened their bond.
14. What Happens to Micah After RDR2?
Micah is eventually killed by John Marston in the epilogue of Red Dead Redemption 2, thus avenging Arthur’s death and completing a sense of justice.
15. Why is Arthur Never Mentioned in RDR1?
Arthur was not a character in the original Red Dead Redemption. Moreover, the deep pain associated with his death is a sensitive topic and likely why it was avoided. Arthur’s story was a prequel and focused on the demise of the gang, which is why he was never mentioned in the original game.