Why did Odin stab Brok?

▶

Odin stabbed Brok because he had discovered that the god was impersonating Tyr to sabotage the group, and to prevent his true identity from being exposed, Odin made his grand revelation by stabbing and killing Brok. This act of violence served as a catalyst to take the fight to Odin, as the story lead Richard Gaubert explained, and it had a profound impact on the characters, particularly Sindri, who was driven by a desire for revenge against Odin.

Understanding the Context

The Events Leading to Brok’s Death

Brok had been questioning everything Tyr did or said, and when the god mentioned a path to Asgard, Brok understood that Tyr wasn’t really all he claimed to be, forcing Odin’s hands and leading to the All-Father killing the dwarf before making his escape.

FAQs

1. What did Odin do to Brok?: Odin made his grand revelation by stabbing and killing Brok, which turned Sindri, normally gregarious and deferential, into an angry Dwarf, deeply resentful of Kratos, Atreus, and their role in setting up Brok’s death.
2. Why was Brok killed off?: Brok died, and then that served as the catalyst to take the fight to Odin, as the story lead Richard Gaubert explained, and it had to hurt, with casualties both physically and emotionally.
3. How did Brok know it was Odin?: Brok questioned everything Tyr did or said, and when the god mentioned a path to Asgard, Brok understood that Tyr wasn’t really all he claimed to be.
4. Why couldn’t Brok be saved?: Mimir told Atreus that Brok can’t be brought back since he lost his direction and therefore his soul didn’t go to the lake of souls and was denied an afterlife.
5. Why did Brok turn blue?: The use of too much silver caused him to turn blue, which is probably as close as we get to a real-life example of what happened to Brok.
6. Why couldn’t Freya revive Brok?: Since Brok only had 3/4ths of his soul, it also made healing impossible, which is why Freya was unable to heal him when Odin, disguised as Týr, stabbed him.
7. Where did Tyr go when Odin killed Brok?: After you beat the main story, you can find the real Týr locked up in an Asgardian prison that ended up in Niflheim, and after you set him free, you can stumble upon him wandering in other realms.
8. Why did Odin hang himself?: He then hanged himself in Yggdrasil, the tree of life, for nine days and nine nights in order to gain knowledge of other worlds and be able to understand the runes.
9. Why didn’t Brok have a soul?: Mimir told Atreus that Brok can’t be brought back since he lost his direction and therefore his soul didn’t go to the lake of souls and was denied an afterlife.
10. Why can’t Brok have an afterlife?: Mimir told Atreus that Brok can’t be brought back since he lost his direction and therefore his soul didn’t go to the lake of souls and was denied an afterlife.
11. Will Brok be alive again?: Unfortunately, Sindri could only bring back most of Brok’s soul—not all of it, and as a result, when Brok died the second time around, there was no afterlife, and he’s just gone.
12. Is Sindri a villain now?: Sindri is set up as the series’ next antagonist, and his actions and behavior after Brok’s death suggest that he may become a villain in the future.
13. Why did Loki betray Odin?: Loki doesn’t care who he’s betraying, so long as it meets his needs, and he plotted to deceive his biological father to impress his adoptive father.
14. How did Sindri revive Brok?: Brok first died after he was killed by a spider, although Sindri traveled to Alfheim and Helheim to bring his brother’s soul back before it was lost forever and brought Brok back to life.
15. Who is stronger, Zeus or Odin?: The MCU seems to place Odin as more powerful, and the God of War series also portrays Odin as an extremely powerful god with a wide range of abilities and powers.