Why Did We Free Gul’dan?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The decision to free Gul’dan at the beginning of the Warlords of Draenor (WoD) expansion in World of Warcraft is one that continues to be debated and scrutinized. While it seems counterintuitive to release a known villain, the rationale at the time, presented within the game’s narrative, was based on the desperate need to halt the Iron Horde and prevent them from flooding through the Dark Portal into Azeroth. We freed Gul’dan, along with Grommash Hellscream and another orc, believing that stopping their power source would sever the connection fueling the portal. The short-term goal was to prevent immediate invasion, even if it meant dealing with the long-term consequences of Gul’dan’s potential return to power, as the Iron Horde posed an immediate existential threat to Azeroth. This ultimately proved to be a gamble with devastating repercussions, culminating in the events of Legion and elements of Battle for Azeroth (BfA).
The Logic of a Risky Choice
Hindsight, of course, is 20/20. Players and lore enthusiasts often question this decision, pointing to the catastrophic fallout. However, in the heat of the moment within the storyline, the situation looked dire. The Iron Horde, a technologically advanced force of orcs from an alternate timeline, was poised to invade Azeroth with overwhelming might.
- Immediate Threat: The Iron Horde represented an immediate, tangible danger that dwarfed any potential future threat posed by Gul’dan.
- Severing the Portal: The primary objective was to disrupt the Dark Portal’s energy source. Gul’dan, along with the others, was forcibly channeling their power to keep the portal open. Freeing them, it was reasoned, would interrupt this flow and collapse the portal.
- Containment: The assumption was that once free, the forces of Azeroth could either contain or eliminate Gul’dan before he could amass significant power. This proved to be a severe miscalculation.
The decision reflects a common trope in storytelling: choosing the lesser of two evils. While freeing Gul’dan ultimately unleashed a greater evil, at the time it was perceived as the most effective way to address the immediate threat.
The Unintended Consequences
The release of Gul’dan had a domino effect of disastrous consequences:
- Empowering the Legion: Gul’dan, free from the constraints of the Iron Horde, quickly re-established contact with the Burning Legion.
- The Legion’s Invasion: This led to the full-scale demonic invasion of Azeroth in the Legion expansion, one of the most significant events in Warcraft history.
- The Broken Shore: The catastrophic defeat at the Broken Shore resulted directly from Gul’dan’s actions and manipulation.
- Sargeras’ Sword: Ultimately, Gul’dan’s actions paved the way for Sargeras to impale Azeroth with his sword, creating the wound that drives the narrative of Battle for Azeroth.
What if We Hadn’t Freed Gul’dan?
It’s a fascinating “what if” scenario. Had we not freed Gul’dan, the Iron Horde might have successfully invaded Azeroth. The ensuing war could have been devastating, potentially leading to the destruction of key cities and the loss of countless lives. However, it’s likely that without Gul’dan’s interference, the Burning Legion would not have launched such a direct and overwhelming assault on Azeroth. The price for stopping the Iron Horde may have simply been too high.
FAQs: Gul’dan and His Impact
Why did Gul’dan turn evil?
Gul’dan’s path to evil began with rejection. The elements initially appeared to him, promising acceptance, but ultimately abandoned him. Consumed by sorrow and hatred, he became vulnerable to the Burning Legion, who offered him power in exchange for his loyalty, a deal he readily accepted.
Why did Sargeras kill Gul’dan (the original)?
The original Gul’dan was not killed directly by Sargeras but by the demons he served. Kil’jaeden revealed the reason: Gul’dan died because he betrayed the Legion.
Why did Gul’dan release Illidan?
Gul’dan released Illidan from his imprisonment, intending to use him as a weapon against the forces of Azeroth. Illidan wasn’t dead, but his soul was separated from his body due to the crystal surrounding him. Gul’dan simply allowed Illidan to reclaim his physical form.
How did Gul’dan come back to life (alternate timeline)?
This Gul’dan wasn’t brought back to life, he was from an alternate timeline Draenor. Garrosh Hellscream used time travel to prevent the original orcs from drinking the blood of Mannoroth, creating this new timeline and its version of Gul’dan.
Is Gul’dan the strongest warlock?
Gul’dan is considered the most powerful non-Eredar warlock in the Horde’s history, and arguably one of the strongest warlocks ever to exist. He mastered fel magic to an unparalleled degree.
Why was Gul’dan so strong?
Gul’dan’s strength stemmed from his pact with the Burning Legion. This pact granted him immense power over fel magic, transforming him into a formidable warlock. However, his mortal body remained a limitation, requiring him to constantly seek new sources of power.
What did Illidan do for 10,000 years?
Illidan was imprisoned for 10,000 years primarily because he created a new Well of Eternity, a dangerous act that threatened the balance of magic on Azeroth.
Who gave Gul’dan his power?
The demon lord Kil’jaeden offered Gul’dan immense power in the form of fel magic in exchange for his loyalty to the Burning Legion. This marked the turning point in Gul’dan’s descent into darkness.
Why did Deathwing want the Skull of Gul’dan?
Deathwing wanted the Skull of Gul’dan as payment for his services. The skull contained a fragment of Gul’dan’s soul, allowing the deceased warlock to communicate with Ner’zhul. The exact purpose of Deathwing’s interest remains shrouded in mystery.
Is Illidan the Chosen One?
While Xe’ra, a Naaru, attempted to transform Illidan into a champion of the Light, the Naaru’s Chosen One, Illidan refused, asserting that his scars and sacrifices defined him.
Was Durotan stronger than Gul’dan?
Durotan possessed superior physical strength and combat skills, but Gul’dan’s use of fel magic gave him an overwhelming advantage. Durotan couldn’t withstand Gul’dan’s dark magic.
Who corrupted Sargeras?
The narrative surrounding Sargeras’ corruption has evolved. Initially, it was believed that his battle against the Void Lords gradually corrupted him. However, newer lore suggests the Nathrezim (Dreadlords) may have played a more active role in manipulating him.
Why did Furion banish Illidan?
Malfurion banished Illidan after Illidan absorbed the power of the Skull of Gul’dan to defeat Tichondrius. Malfurion and Tyrande were horrified by Illidan’s actions and his embrace of demonic power, leading to his exile.
Is Ner’zhul stronger than Gul’dan?
Initially, Ner’zhul held greater power, but Kil’jaeden granted Gul’dan enough power to supplant Ner’zhul as the dominant force within the orcish clans. Later, Ner’zhul was transformed into the Lich King.
Who killed Gul’dan (alternate timeline)?
Illidan killed Gul’dan, dismissing him as an insignificant obstacle on his path to confront the demon lords. Gul’dan was simply eradicated without ceremony.
Understanding the context, motivations, and consequences surrounding the decision to free Gul’dan provides valuable insights into the complexities of storytelling within the Warcraft universe. It demonstrates how seemingly rational choices can have unforeseen and devastating repercussions, a lesson often explored in games and other forms of narrative entertainment. This is something to consider when understanding how games and learning link. Learn more at Games Learning Society! You can also visit their website by using this link: GamesLearningSociety.org.
The choice to free Gul’dan resulted from a combination of dire circumstances, a calculated risk, and ultimately, a tragic misjudgment of Gul’dan’s cunning and the Burning Legion’s ambitions. It serves as a potent reminder that even well-intentioned decisions can have catastrophic consequences.