Why Do FPS Players Hate SBMM? The Bitter Truth
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer? SBMM, or Skill-Based Matchmaking, is often perceived as crushing the casual fun in favor of sweaty, hyper-competitive matches. It can feel like every game is a tournament final, eliminating the joy of stomping noobs or relaxing after a long day. But the full story is much more nuanced, touching on everything from server lag to the psychological impact of constant pressure to perform.
The Core Complaints: A Breakdown
FPS players have a laundry list of grievances when it comes to SBMM, stemming from the impact it has on their gaming experience. It goes far beyond a simple dislike. They have strong feelings about it. Here are the major pain points:
-
Punishing Improvement: Arguably the biggest complaint is that SBMM penalizes players for getting better. The better you perform, the tougher your opponents become, effectively creating a performance ceiling. There’s a sense that you can never truly “relax” and enjoy the fruits of your labor. Many feel that the point of improving in a game is to be able to showcase your new skills. The SBMM algorithm negates this desire.
-
Elimination of Casual Play: Long gone are the days of jumping into a game to unwind and have some low-stakes fun. With SBMM, every match feels like a high-pressure situation where you need to be at the top of your game to avoid getting crushed. This turns even casual game modes into stressful, anxiety-inducing experiences. Many gamers like to play casually and that means that they do not want to constantly be paired with similarly skilled opponents.
-
Increased Sweating and Try-Hard Mentality: SBMM fosters an environment where players are incentivized to use the most effective weapons, strategies, and tactics at all times. This leads to a lack of experimentation and creativity, as players are afraid to deviate from the meta and risk losing.
-
Server Lag and Connection Issues: SBMM algorithms often prioritize skill matching over geographical proximity, resulting in players being connected to servers located far away from them. This can lead to increased ping, lag, and overall poor connection quality, further diminishing the enjoyment of the game. Nobody wants to play a game where the internet connection is not strong and results in lagged game play.
-
Smurfing and Account Boosting: As a response to SBMM, some players resort to creating new accounts (“smurfing”) to bypass the matchmaking system and play against weaker opponents. This creates an unfair playing field and frustrates legitimate players.
-
Loss of the “David vs. Goliath” Moments: Without SBMM, there’s always the chance of being matched against much stronger or weaker players. While getting stomped can be frustrating, it also creates opportunities for underdog moments, where less skilled players can pull off surprising victories against highly skilled opponents. These moments are exciting and memorable, but they are rare in SBMM-dominated environments.
-
The Illusion of Fairness: While SBMM is intended to create fair matches, it can often feel anything but. In reality, SBMM sometimes results in highly variable matches that seem random and unfair.
-
Streamer Privilege (Real or Perceived): The perception that streamers and content creators receive preferential treatment, being placed in easier lobbies to create more entertaining content, fuels resentment among regular players who feel they are being disadvantaged. As the article states, easy lobbies make the game look more accessible to newcomers.
The Argument in Favor of SBMM: Protecting New Players
It’s important to acknowledge that SBMM does have its merits, particularly when it comes to protecting new players. The intent is to prevent newcomers from being repeatedly crushed by experienced players, which can lead to frustration and discouragement. By matching new players with others of similar skill, SBMM aims to create a more welcoming and enjoyable experience, increasing the likelihood that they will stick with the game.
However, many believe that separate beginner lobbies would accomplish the same goal without affecting the rest of the community. A tier system could allow players to rise through the ranks of difficulty as their skill improves.
The Transparency Problem: Why Secrecy Fuels Frustration
A major source of frustration surrounding SBMM is the lack of transparency from developers. Many game companies do not clearly communicate how their SBMM systems work, or even confirm their existence. This opacity breeds suspicion and conspiracy theories, as players speculate about the inner workings of the matchmaking algorithms.
An additional issue is that the SBMM algorithm is a “black box”. The variables used to determine skill level are unknown. The algorithm seems to be proprietary information that the game developers do not wish to release to the public.
Finding a Balance: Can SBMM and Fun Coexist?
The question is, can SBMM and fun coexist in FPS games? Some argue that the key lies in finding a better balance between skill-based matching and other factors, such as connection quality and geographical proximity. Others suggest implementing more granular SBMM systems that take into account a wider range of player statistics and playstyles.
Ultimately, the success of SBMM depends on its implementation and how well it aligns with the overall goals of the game. If SBMM is perceived as being too restrictive, unfair, or detrimental to the overall player experience, it will inevitably face resistance from the community.
The Long-Term Impact: SBMM’s Effect on Game Communities
The widespread adoption of SBMM is having a significant impact on the dynamics of FPS game communities. As players become increasingly frustrated with the competitive nature of SBMM-driven matches, they may start to migrate to games that offer a more relaxed and casual experience. This could lead to a fragmentation of the player base, as different games cater to different preferences.
The long-term consequences of this trend are yet to be seen, but it’s clear that SBMM is a major factor shaping the future of FPS gaming. To learn more about the design of video games and the community that surrounds them, visit the GamesLearningSociety.org website.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About SBMM
Here are some frequently asked questions about SBMM that will further clarify its role in FPS games:
1. What exactly is Skill-Based Matchmaking (SBMM)?
SBMM is a matchmaking system that attempts to pair players of similar skill levels together in online multiplayer games. The goal is to create fairer and more balanced matches where players are challenged but not overwhelmed.
2. How does SBMM work? What factors are considered?
SBMM algorithms typically use a variety of factors to determine a player’s skill level, including K/D ratio (kills/deaths), win rate, score per minute, accuracy, and overall playtime. The exact formula varies from game to game and is often kept secret by developers.
3. Is SBMM in every FPS game?
Not every FPS game uses SBMM, but it has become increasingly common in recent years, especially in popular titles like Call of Duty, Apex Legends, and Fortnite.
4. Why do developers implement SBMM?
Developers implement SBMM primarily to protect new players from being overwhelmed by experienced players, and to create a more balanced and engaging experience for everyone. SBMM increases the likelihood that new players will stick with the game.
5. Does SBMM always work as intended?
No, SBMM doesn’t always work perfectly. It can sometimes create matches that feel unfair or unbalanced, and it can also lead to increased server lag and connection issues. Furthermore, players may deliberately manipulate the system.
6. Can I avoid SBMM? Is there a way to “trick” the system?
Some players attempt to bypass SBMM by using VPNs (Virtual Private Networks) to change their perceived location, or by creating new accounts (“smurfing”) with lower skill ratings. However, these methods are not always effective and can violate the game’s terms of service.
7. What are the alternative matchmaking systems to SBMM?
Alternative matchmaking systems include connection-based matchmaking (CBMM), which prioritizes connecting players based on geographical proximity and ping, and random matchmaking, which simply pairs players together without considering their skill level.
8. How does SBMM affect casual players?
SBMM can make casual play more stressful, as players are constantly matched against opponents of similar skill, eliminating the possibility of easy wins or relaxing matches.
9. Does SBMM affect my ping or connection quality?
Yes, SBMM can sometimes lead to increased ping and connection issues, as the algorithm prioritizes skill matching over geographical proximity and server location.
10. Are there any benefits to SBMM?
Yes, SBMM can protect new players from being overwhelmed, create more challenging and engaging matches for experienced players, and reduce the frequency of lopsided matches where one team dominates the other.
11. Why don’t developers communicate more about SBMM?
The reasons for the lack of transparency are complex, but it is possible that developers believe that publicly revealing the inner workings of SBMM would lead to players manipulating the system or exploiting its weaknesses.
12. What is “ELO” and how does it relate to SBMM?
ELO is a ranking system originally developed for chess that is often used as a component of SBMM algorithms. It assigns players a numerical rating based on their performance, and it is used to predict the outcome of matches.
13. Does SBMM take into account my party size when matchmaking?
Most SBMM systems do take into account the size of your party when matchmaking, attempting to match you against other parties of similar size and skill level.
14. Is SBMM based on level?
SBMM is not based on level. SBMM is based on in-game performance metrics, such as total playtime, score per minute, and number of kills.
15. What is being done about complaints regarding SBMM?
It is difficult to know what is being done. The lack of transparency from developers and Activision, as well as the complexity of the algorithm, make it challenging to change this matchmaking system.