Table of Contents

Why Is Barbas So Annoying in Skyrim? The Definitive Guide

Quick answer

This page answers Why is Barbas so annoying? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

Barbas, the talking canine companion of Daedric Prince Clavicus Vile in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, manages to be both a beloved and intensely irritating character. He’s annoying primarily due to his incessant barking, his inability to sneak effectively, and his tendency to interfere with gameplay. While his questline, “A Daedra’s Best Friend,” offers unique rewards and lore, many players find his constant presence a major impediment to enjoying the game. His loud pronouncements, lack of stealth capabilities, and general disruptiveness make him a bane to stealth archers and anyone who values a quiet, immersive Skyrim experience. He’s basically the annoying friend you love to hate – and maybe secretly appreciate deep down.

The Symphony of Barking: A Sonic Assault on Skyrim

Barbas’ most infamous trait is, without a doubt, his relentless barking. It’s not just a little yip now and then; it’s a near-constant barrage of dog noises that can quickly grate on even the most patient player. This is especially problematic for players who enjoy a more subtle, immersive experience. The background music, the ambient sounds of Skyrim, and the conversations with NPCs are constantly interrupted by Barbas’ woofs and growls. Imagine trying to negotiate a delicate trade deal in Riften while Barbas is barking at a passing butterfly – it’s hardly conducive to smooth diplomacy!

Stealth: A Concept Lost on a Daedric Dog

For those who prefer a stealth-based playstyle, Barbas is essentially kryptonite. He doesn’t understand the concept of sneaking. While the Dragonborn is carefully crouching in the shadows, trying to pickpocket a guard or infiltrate a bandit camp, Barbas is merrily trotting along, barking greetings to the enemy. This immediately alerts everyone in the vicinity, turning what should have been a smooth operation into a chaotic brawl. The difference in AI between Barbas and normal followers regarding stealth makes him especially frustrating.

Quest Dependency and Forced Companionship

Another source of annoyance stems from the fact that Barbas is a quest-related follower. This means you can’t simply dismiss him like a regular companion. You’re stuck with him until you complete “A Daedra’s Best Friend,” which can be a significant commitment. For players who don’t want a dog tagging along, this forced companionship can feel like a tedious chore. The game essentially dictates you must tolerate his presence before you can finally be rid of him (or, potentially, choose to keep him – more on that later).

The Weight of Dialogue and Lore

While some players appreciate the lore and character development associated with Barbas and Clavicus Vile, others find his constant dialogue and the length of the questline a drag. He frequently comments on your surroundings, offering unsolicited advice and insights. While this might be interesting initially, it quickly becomes repetitive and distracting. It’s like being stuck on a road trip with someone who never stops talking. The combination of barking and dialogue can be overwhelming.

Collision Issues and Pathing Problems

Like many followers in Skyrim, Barbas can suffer from collision issues and pathing problems. He may get stuck in doorways, block narrow passages, or generally impede your movement. This is particularly annoying in dungeons or other confined spaces, where maneuvering is already challenging.

But Is He Really That Bad? A Defense of the Barking Buddy

Despite all these annoyances, Barbas does have his redeeming qualities. He’s unkillable during his quest, making him a useful (if loud) tank in combat. His dialogue, while repetitive, can offer hints and insights into the world of Skyrim. Plus, some players find his chaotic nature genuinely amusing. He is, after all, a piece of a Daedric Prince, and his behavior reflects that unpredictable nature. He also allows for the possibility of having two followers, and is therefore valuable in that respect. Ultimately, whether Barbas is an annoyance or a welcome companion is a matter of personal preference.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Barbas

Here are 15 frequently asked questions (FAQs) regarding Barbas:

Is there a way to reduce Barbas’ barking? Unfortunately, there is no in-game setting or mod to directly reduce Barbas’ barking. Players have resorted to turning down the sound effects volume, which affects other sounds as well.
Can Barbas be killed? During the “A Daedra’s Best Friend” quest, Barbas is essential and cannot be killed, except at the very end of the quest with the Rueful Axe.
Does Barbas count as a follower? Barbas is a quest follower, meaning he doesn’t prevent you from having another humanoid follower. You can have both Barbas and another follower at the same time.
What happens if I tell Barbas to stop following me? If you tell Barbas to stop following you before completing the quest, he will return to Haemar’s Shame, the shrine of Clavicus Vile.
Can I use Barbas to carry items? No, Barbas cannot carry items. He is an animal follower and lacks the inventory capacity of humanoid companions.
How do I start the “A Daedra’s Best Friend” quest? The quest starts in Falkreath. Usually, an NPC will approach you and ask you to speak with Lod, the blacksmith, or you can simply find Barbas on the road outside town after reaching level 10.
What are the rewards for completing “A Daedra’s Best Friend”? You can either receive the Rueful Axe by killing Barbas or the Masque of Clavicus Vile by reuniting him with Clavicus.
Which reward is better, the Rueful Axe or the Masque of Clavicus Vile? The Masque of Clavicus Vile is generally considered better, as it counts towards the Oblivion Walker achievement. The Rueful Axe is underwhelming in combat.
Is it better to kill Barbas or let him live? Letting Barbas live and obtaining the Masque of Clavicus Vile is recommended for the Oblivion Walker achievement and for lore reasons.
Can I get Barbas as a permanent companion? Without mods, Barbas is only a temporary companion during the “A Daedra’s Best Friend” quest. However, some mods allow you to keep him permanently.
Does Barbas affect my stealth? Yes, Barbas significantly hinders stealth. He does not sneak and will alert enemies to your presence.
What breed of dog is Barbas? Barbas is often depicted as resembling an Irish Wolfhound or a Soft Coated Wheaten Terrier.
What level do I need to be to start “A Daedra’s Best Friend”? The quest can be started as soon as you reach level 10.
Is Clavicus Vile evil? Yes, Clavicus Vile is generally considered evil. He is the Daedric Prince of wishes and trickery, often granting wishes that backfire in ironic and devastating ways.
Where is Haemar’s Shame? Haemar’s Shame is a cave located in the mountains southeast of Whiterun and northwest of Helgen. It houses the shrine of Clavicus Vile where Barbas takes you.

The Last Woof: A Love-Hate Relationship

Barbas embodies the quintessential “love-hate” relationship within the world of gaming. He’s annoying, disruptive, and often inconvenient. Yet, he’s also a unique and memorable character who adds a certain quirky charm to Skyrim. Whether you choose to embrace his chaotic presence or complete his quest as quickly as possible, Barbas will undoubtedly leave a lasting impression on your Skyrim adventure. His impact on game enjoyment is subjective, but there is no denying that he is a popular choice.

Ultimately, understanding the principles of Games Learning Society can help developers create characters like Barbas that evoke strong emotions, whether positive or negative, and contribute to a more engaging and memorable player experience. By analyzing how players interact with and react to characters, developers can refine their designs to maximize emotional impact and create more compelling narratives. Visit GamesLearningSociety.org to learn more about how games impact learning and behavior.