Why is Breath of the Wild Rated M? Unpacking the Confusion
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild is a critically acclaimed masterpiece, beloved by gamers of all ages. However, a common point of confusion arises from its rating in various regions. Many are surprised to learn that in some places, the game is designated with an M rating, which typically indicates content unsuitable for younger audiences. This rating, primarily used in Australia, contrasts sharply with the E10+ rating it receives in the United States. So, why the discrepancy?
The simple answer is: Breath of the Wild is not actually rated M in the United States. The M rating is specific to the Australian Classification Board, which has a stricter approach to content evaluation than the Entertainment Software Rating Board (ESRB) in the United States. The Australian M rating is roughly equivalent to a T (Teen) rating in the United States. In essence, the rating difference is primarily due to variations in rating systems and regional sensitivities to certain themes rather than any inherent mature content in the game itself.
The Australian classification board cited mild suggestive themes and violence as reasons for the M rating. While the violence is very cartoonish, with enemies disappearing in a puff of smoke rather than realistic gore, the combined presence of combat and the aforementioned themes led to the M classification there.
Understanding the Rating Discrepancy
It’s crucial to distinguish between the ESRB ratings (used in the US) and the Australian Classification Board ratings. The ESRB, which assigned Breath of the Wild an E10+ rating, focuses on content such as combat and mild suggestive material but does not deem them as highly problematic. The key here is to understand that regional boards have different standards and criteria.
Specifically, Breath of the Wild contains:
- Mild Fantasy Violence: Combat against fantasy creatures is a core gameplay element.
- Mildly Suggestive Material: As mentioned in reviews, there are some characters, particularly fairies, with exaggerated features. Also, some dialogue includes innuendos.
- Moderate Threat: The game does include some more intense moments in the combat and during specific encounters.
It’s also important to note that the game eschews gore entirely. Instead of graphic depictions of violence, enemies vanish in a puff of smoke. This is a deliberate design choice by Nintendo, making the game suitable for a wider range of audiences.
Why the Confusion?
The confusion likely stems from a combination of factors:
- Regional Differences: The most significant factor is the difference in rating boards and their interpretations of content.
- Misinterpretations: People might associate fantasy violence with more graphic representations, leading to assumptions about the game’s content.
- Online Information: Information spread online, often without the full context, can cause confusion and misinterpretations.
The bottom line is that Breath of the Wild is not an M-rated game in the United States and is considered appropriate for kids 10 years and older, according to the ESRB. The perceived “M rating” is simply a regional matter that does not reflect the game’s actual content in the United States.
15 Frequently Asked Questions About Breath of the Wild’s Rating
Here are 15 frequently asked questions to further clarify the game’s rating and content:
1. What is the official ESRB rating for Breath of the Wild?
The official ESRB rating is E10+ (Everyone 10+), meaning it is suitable for players aged 10 and above.
2. Why is Breath of the Wild rated E10+?
It’s rated E10+ primarily for its mild fantasy violence and occasional mild suggestive material, but no gore or graphic content.
3. Does Breath of the Wild contain blood or gore?
No, Breath of the Wild does not contain blood or gore. Enemies typically disappear in a puff of smoke when defeated.
4. Is Breath of the Wild appropriate for young children?
The ESRB rating suggests ages 10+, and most reviews agree. It is a personal decision for parents whether or not to allow younger children to play.
5. What kind of violence is present in the game?
The game features mild fantasy violence. This includes combat with swords, bows, and other weapons against fictional creatures, with impact depicted through stylized effects.
6. What constitutes “mildly suggestive material” in Breath of the Wild?
This refers to characters with exaggerated features and occasional innuendo in the dialogue.
7. Are there any scary moments in Breath of the Wild?
While not a horror game, it has intense moments and certain areas like Blood Moons or enemy encounters can be unsettling.
8. Is it true that Breath of the Wild is rated M in Australia?
Yes, the game is rated M in Australia by the Australian Classification Board, which is roughly equivalent to the T rating in the US.
9. Why does the Australian rating differ from the US rating?
The Australian rating board has stricter guidelines regarding suggestive themes and violence.
10. Is the game appropriate for a 12-year-old?
Most reviews and community feedback suggest that Breath of the Wild is generally appropriate for 11-12 year olds, with consideration for individual maturity levels.
11. How violent is Breath of the Wild compared to other games?
Breath of the Wild has less explicit violence than many other action-adventure games and eschews gore.
12. Are there any characters or dialogue that may be unsuitable for younger players?
Some dialogue might contain innuendo, and some character designs may be seen as mildly suggestive by some players.
13. Are the enemies in Breath of the Wild scary?
Enemies are fantastical and not intended to be overly graphic or scary, with the exception of enemies like Lynels, who can be very powerful.
14. Is Breath of the Wild more challenging than other Zelda games?
Breath of the Wild does have a steeper learning curve but becomes easier as the player progresses.
15. Are there any other Zelda games with similar ratings?
Most Zelda titles receive E (Everyone) or E10+ ratings. Hyrule Warriors and Link’s Crossbow Training are exceptions with T ratings.
Conclusion
The perceived M rating for Breath of the Wild is a matter of regional classification differences, not a reflection of highly mature content within the game itself. While the Australian rating system is stricter, the ESRB rates it E10+, making it suitable for a wide range of audiences. Understanding these differences ensures that parents and players can make informed choices based on their own standards and preferences. The game remains a beloved title due to its engaging gameplay and enchanting world, making it a worthwhile adventure for many.