Why is Genshin Impact Rated So Low? Unpacking Player Discontent
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Genshin Impact, the globally acclaimed open-world action RPG, has not been without its controversies. While it has garnered immense popularity and revenue, it has also faced periods of significant player backlash, leading to depressed ratings on app stores. The core reason for these low ratings is a combination of player dissatisfaction stemming from specific in-game events, reward systems, and perceived lack of communication from the developers, Mihoyo (now HoYoverse). Notably, the anniversary events have been a major source of discontent, often falling short of player expectations, resulting in large-scale review bombing campaigns.
Anniversary Event Failures and Reward System Criticisms
The most prominent instances of Genshin Impact’s rating plummeting are directly linked to perceived poorly executed anniversary celebrations. Instead of showering players with generous gifts and exciting content, Mihoyo’s anniversary events have frequently been criticized for offering lackluster rewards. This frustration is compounded by the game’s gacha system, where players spend in-game currency or real money to obtain new characters and weapons. When anniversary rewards don’t meet expectations, it feels like a slap in the face to the devoted player base who have invested time and money.
The raffle system used for online anniversary rewards has also been heavily criticized. Instead of guaranteed rewards for all participants, many players felt excluded and unfairly treated, as many were given a chance to win a single item, while others may get nothing at all. This perceived unfairness added fuel to the already burning fire of disappointment, causing further drops in player sentiment and app store ratings. The system’s inherent randomness fueled discontent among many players, leading to the review bombing campaigns as the primary means of venting their frustration.
Communication Breakdown
A key factor exacerbating the issue is a perceived lack of effective communication from Mihoyo. Players often feel that their concerns and feedback are not being adequately addressed. Silence or seemingly deflective responses only further amplify the negative sentiment, leading players to believe that their voices are not being heard. This communication gap further fuels the review bombing, with players using their app store reviews as a last resort to be heard.
Beyond the Anniversary: Other Contributing Factors
While anniversary events have been the most common catalyst for negative ratings, other factors contribute to the overall perception of the game. One is the issue of end-game content. For players who have reached the current end of the main storyline, there is often a lack of substantial new challenges or activities to engage in. This leads to a feeling of stagnation and the perception that the game is becoming less enjoyable.
Furthermore, the difficulty and complexity of certain in-game systems, such as artifacts (items that boost character stats), can be overwhelming for some players. Grinding for perfect artifacts is a time-consuming and often frustrating process that is reliant on luck, adding another layer of frustration.
These issues, combined with the perception of certain characters being underpowered or the rates of obtaining highly sought-after characters through the gacha system being perceived as low, contribute to an environment where player dissatisfaction can easily boil over.
The Impact of Review Bombing
The immediate effect of review bombing is a significant drop in app store ratings. For example, the Google Play Store rating of Genshin Impact has plummeted from over four and a half stars to below three in severe instances. While such a dramatic drop can serve as a powerful message to the developers, it also has a negative impact on the game’s overall perception, especially for new players who may see these low ratings and be discouraged from trying the game. However, it can also be seen as a necessary method for players to express their frustration and force the developer to address the problems at hand.
In conclusion, while Genshin Impact is a generally well-received game, its low ratings are often a direct result of the developer’s shortcomings in handling anniversary events, reward systems and player communication. By actively listening to the community and ensuring that future events provide satisfying and fairly distributed rewards, Mihoyo can address these issues and rebuild its reputation in the mobile gaming community.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Why did Genshin Impact’s rating drop drastically?
The main reasons for drastic rating drops are poorly received anniversary rewards and the use of a random raffle system for online rewards. This was coupled with perceived poor communication from the developers and a general lack of end-game content.
2. What is review bombing and why does it happen?
Review bombing is when a large number of users post negative reviews on a product or service, often in a coordinated effort to express dissatisfaction. In Genshin Impact’s case, players used this to protest the game’s handling of events and rewards.
3. Was the anniversary event the only reason for negative reviews?
No, while the anniversary events were the primary trigger, other factors like lack of end-game content, difficulty of obtaining desirable in-game items, and perceived weak characters, also contributed to negative sentiment.
4. What is the gacha system in Genshin Impact?
The gacha system is a mechanic where players spend in-game currency (or real money) for a chance to “pull” new characters or weapons. It is a form of randomized loot box.
5. Why do players feel the anniversary rewards are inadequate?
Players often feel the anniversary rewards are inadequate because they compare them to past events, and to what other games may offer for major milestones. They see this as a reflection of the developer’s appreciation for their loyal player base.
6. Is Genshin Impact really a low-end game?
While playable on low-end devices, Genshin Impact can be demanding on older phones and computers. Players with low-end devices may need to lower their graphics settings or use a game-streaming service like GeForce Now to enjoy the game smoothly.
7. Is Genshin Impact rated 18+?
No, Genshin Impact is rated PEGI 12, which means it’s not suitable for persons under 12 years of age due to depictions of non-realistic-looking violence. It does not contain sexually explicit content, despite some characters having revealing costumes.
8. Is Genshin Impact addictive?
Yes, many players find Genshin Impact to be highly addictive due to its engaging storyline, impressive graphics, vast world, and constant updates. The gacha system and daily tasks also contribute to the game’s addictive nature.
9. Is Genshin Impact religious?
The game is not religious, however, it is set in a polytheistic world called Teyvat, with numerous gods and god-like beings that play a significant role in the game’s narrative.
10. Who is considered the weakest 5-star character?
Qiqi is generally considered one of the weakest 5-star characters due to her lackluster cryo damage application and long cooldowns on her skills.
11. Who is the strongest character in Genshin Impact based on lore?
Based on lore, Zhongli, the Geo Archon, is often considered one of the strongest characters due to his history and overall power.
12. Who is the weakest Archon in Genshin Impact?
Venti, the Anemo Archon, is generally considered the weakest Archon in the game’s storyline. Despite his diminished power, he is still a powerful character.
13. Should a 12-year-old play Genshin Impact?
Genshin Impact is rated PEGI 12, which is deemed suitable for 12-year-olds. However, parents should be aware that some characters have revealing costumes.
14. Is Genshin Impact spyware?
Mihoyo has refuted claims of their anti-cheat software being spyware, and have updated the game since the controversy. However, some players remain skeptical.
15. Is Genshin Impact worth the time?
Genshin Impact is considered a good free-to-play option for those who enjoy RPGs with a focus on exploration, combat, and narrative. However, it is a time-consuming game and can be highly tempting to spend money on the gacha system.