Why is Josh the Killer in Until Dawn?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The central mystery of Until Dawn revolves around the identity of the Psycho, a masked tormentor who terrorizes the group of friends. The shocking reveal is that this figure is none other than Josh Washington, the seemingly grief-stricken brother of the missing twins, Beth and Hannah. Josh’s descent into this role isn’t solely driven by a desire to inflict harm, but rather stems from a complex web of grief, mental instability, and a thirst for revenge. He orchestrates the deadly game as a twisted form of retribution against his friends whom he blames for the tragic events of the previous year. The prank on his sisters that led to their disappearance on the mountain is the catalyst for his actions.
A Descent into Madness: The Motivations Behind Josh’s Actions
Josh’s actions are far more complex than just a desire to cause physical harm. His mental state is clearly fragile. He experiences hallucinations, including a manipulative psychiatrist and visions of his deceased sisters. This suggests underlying issues exacerbated by trauma and grief. He’s not just seeking to scare his friends; he’s trying to make them feel the same despair and terror he experienced after losing Beth and Hannah. He views their earlier prank as a gross act of betrayal.
Josh’s actions are intended to be a twisted game of vengeance. His goal isn’t to murder his friends outright; he wants them to endure the same anguish and helplessness that he did. The various traps and situations he places his friends in are all designed to exploit their fears and test their bonds, reflecting his own feelings of vulnerability and loss. He wants them to understand the severity of their actions. While he does hurt them, such as knocking out Ashley and Chris, he is not actively seeking to kill them as the “Psycho”.
Josh’s role as the Psycho is a manifestation of his unraveling psyche. He is so consumed by grief and his need for vengeance that he loses sight of his original intentions. His actions showcase the devastating effects of unresolved trauma and the dangerous path revenge can take. His psychological state, his grief over the loss of his sisters, and his distorted perception of justice all combine to form the character of the killer.
Ultimately, Josh’s transformation into the Psycho reveals the complex layers of his personality and the devastating consequences of unchecked grief and a thirst for revenge. It serves as a chilling reminder that even those we believe we know best can be consumed by their internal battles.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Why does Josh become a Wendigo in Until Dawn?
Josh’s transformation into a Wendigo is a separate, tragic event that occurs after the main game’s events if he is spared. Following the destruction of the lodge, Josh is left on the mountain. In a desperate attempt to survive, he consumes human flesh from a Wendigo’s stockpile. This act leads to his own transformation into a Wendigo, a monstrous entity fueled by cannibalism. It highlights the grim consequences of the Wendigo curse.
2. Why did Josh go crazy in Until Dawn?
Josh’s descent into madness is a result of immense trauma and grief following the disappearance of his sisters. He feels betrayed by his friends for their roles in the prank that preceded the tragedy. The emotional toll of this, coupled with existing mental health issues, leads to his distorted perception of reality and his twisted acts of vengeance. His hallucinations and distorted sense of justice are manifestations of this underlying psychological damage.
3. What is wrong with Josh in Until Dawn?
Josh suffers from severe mental instability rooted in grief and trauma. He hallucinates a manipulative psychiatrist and sees visions of his deceased sisters, indicating a break from reality. His actions as the Psycho suggest that he may not be in his right mind as he torments his friends.
4. Who is the real killer in Until Dawn?
The main antagonist during the lodge portion of the game is Josh Washington, revealed as the Psycho. However, the Wendigos are also significant threats, and in a way, they are the real and ancient monsters of the game, with Hannah becoming the primary Wendigo to hunt the group. Josh orchestrated the events as revenge, and his later transformation into a Wendigo is tragic.
5. Is it possible to save Josh in Until Dawn?
“Saving” Josh doesn’t mean he gets a happy ending. To “save” him in the main game, Sam and Mike must find Hannah’s journal in the mines and reveal its contents to Josh. If they do, he is spared by Hannah during their later encounter. However, Josh’s fate is still bleak, as he eventually becomes a Wendigo.
6. Can Josh survive in Until Dawn without becoming a Wendigo?
No, Josh cannot survive without becoming a Wendigo if you choose to find Hannah’s journal and spare him in the main game. The only outcome for a spared Josh is a slow descent into cannibalism after the lodge is destroyed, resulting in his Wendigo transformation.
7. Is it better to save Josh or Ashley in the specific trap scene?
In the trap scene where Josh presents his friends with the dilemma of saving him or Ashley, you cannot truly “save” both. It’s a ruse by Josh. Choosing to save Ashley will lead to some tension, with Josh making snide remarks, but neither character is actually in danger of dying at that point.
8. Did Josh like Sam in Until Dawn?
Yes, Josh and Sam were close friends. Sam has the second-highest relationship status with Josh after the events, indicating their mutual support. They leaned on each other for solace after the tragedy of Josh’s sisters’ disappearance.
9. How did Hannah recognize Josh in Until Dawn?
If Sam and Mike discover Hannah’s journal, they learn the truth about her fate and share it with Josh. When Hannah (as a Wendigo) later encounters Josh, she recognizes him after he shouts her name, resulting in her sparing him initially.
10. Did Hannah eat Beth in Until Dawn?
Yes, it’s implied that Hannah ate Beth in order to survive after their fall. Hannah, succumbing to the Wendigo spirit, consumed her sister’s body, which ultimately led to her own transformation into a Wendigo.
11. How did Josh fake his death in Until Dawn?
Josh faked his death using a mannequin with a hole through it, which he could fit his head into, making it seem like the trap killed him. This illusion was part of his elaborate plan to torment his friends and exact revenge.
12. Who was drunk with Josh in Until Dawn?
Chris was the only character, besides Josh himself, who was not part of the prank the previous year. He was passed out drunk, hence why he is the most tortured during Josh’s game.
13. Is there a way to save Josh and Ashley in Until Dawn?
In the specific trap scene of the game, you cannot save both Josh and Ashley from death, because it is actually an elaborate prank. However, through making the right choices throughout the game, both can live through the night. The fate of Josh at the end depends on whether or not you find Hannah’s journal.
14. Can you save Mike’s fingers in Until Dawn?
Yes, you can save Mike’s fingers. If you choose to keep his fingers, he will break the machete later on. However, if you allow him to amputate his fingers, he keeps the machete. Both decisions have gameplay implications.
15. Why is it bad to say the name “Wendigo”?
In many cultures, saying the name of a malevolent entity, like “Wendigo,” is believed to summon or empower it. Some Native American beliefs suggest that mentioning such beings can attract their attention or bring them closer. This belief underscores the horror themes of the game.