The Tumultuous History of Pinball: Why Was It Ever Illegal?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Pinball, that flashing, clanging, utterly captivating arcade game, was once Public Enemy Number One. It might seem absurd today, but the reason pinball was illegal in many American cities and towns boils down to its perceived association with gambling and organized crime. City officials and moral crusaders viewed pinball as a game of chance, not skill, and therefore a dangerous temptation that preyed on the vulnerable, especially children. This perception led to widespread bans, primarily from the 1940s until the mid-1970s, marking a bizarre chapter in American history.
The Dark Days: Pinball as a Menace
The wave of pinball bans was fueled by several factors:
- The Gambling Argument: The core argument against pinball was that it was a game of chance, indistinguishable from slot machines. Early pinball machines lacked flippers and relied heavily on luck. Awarding free games or prizes reinforced the gambling accusation.
- Organized Crime: In cities like Chicago, pinball became associated with organized crime syndicates who controlled the distribution and operation of the machines. This connection painted pinball as a morally corrupting influence.
- Moral Panic: Concerns about juvenile delinquency and the perceived squandering of children’s money added to the outrage. Pinball was portrayed as a gateway to more serious forms of gambling and crime.
- Political Opportunism: Ambitious politicians, like New York City Mayor Fiorello LaGuardia, seized on the anti-pinball sentiment to boost their public image and demonstrate their commitment to fighting crime and protecting citizens.
The Flippers Change Everything
The invention of flippers in 1947 should have marked a turning point. Flippers introduced an element of skill, allowing players to actively control the ball and influence the game’s outcome. However, the bans remained in place for decades, demonstrating the entrenched opposition to pinball. Despite the skill now involved, many still viewed it as a form of gambling and a negative influence.
The Champion Who Saved Pinball
The tide began to turn in the mid-1970s. A pivotal moment occurred in 1976 when Roger Sharpe, a young writer and pinball enthusiast, was called before the New York City Council. Sharpe expertly demonstrated that pinball was no longer a game of chance but a game of skill. He called his shot, predicting exactly where the ball would go when he plunged it, and landed it exactly where he said. He argued, and proved, that a skilled player could control the ball and consistently achieve high scores. His testimony convinced the council to overturn the ban, paving the way for other cities and states to follow suit.
The Lingering Shadow: Pinball Today
While the widespread bans are largely a thing of the past, the legacy of that era continues to resonate. The stigma associated with pinball took decades to overcome. And, surprisingly, some antiquated laws still remain on the books.
For instance, South Carolina has a law prohibiting anyone under 18 from playing pinball. The reasoning behind this is a vestige of the old concerns about gambling and corruption. While rarely enforced, this law serves as a reminder of pinball’s turbulent past.
Today, pinball is enjoying a resurgence in popularity. New manufacturers are creating innovative machines, and dedicated pinball arcades are popping up across the country. Pinball has evolved from a “game of chance” to a skill-based form of entertainment, and for many it is also a competitive sport. You can also learn more about games and play at the Games Learning Society through their website GamesLearningSociety.org.
Pinball: Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Why was pinball considered illegal in the United States?
Pinball was considered illegal primarily because it was viewed as a form of gambling. City officials and concerned citizens believed that pinball machines were rigged, offering little or no opportunity for skill-based play and encouraging addictive behavior, especially among young people.
2. In what cities and states was pinball banned?
Pinball was banned in numerous cities across the United States, including New York City, Chicago, and Los Angeles. The bans were more localized than statewide, with individual municipalities enacting their own ordinances against the game.
3. When did the pinball bans start?
The pinball bans began in the early 1940s, coinciding with heightened concerns about organized crime and juvenile delinquency.
4. How long did the pinball bans last?
The pinball bans lasted for several decades, with some cities maintaining the prohibition until the mid-1970s.
5. Who was Fiorello LaGuardia and what was his role in the pinball bans?
Fiorello LaGuardia was the mayor of New York City during the 1940s. He was a staunch opponent of pinball and spearheaded the city’s ban on the game, believing it was a corrupting influence that robbed schoolchildren of their money.
6. What was the connection between pinball and organized crime?
In some cities, pinball machine distribution and operation were controlled by organized crime syndicates. This association fueled the perception that pinball was a morally corrupting activity.
7. What role did the invention of flippers play in the pinball story?
The invention of flippers in 1947 added an element of skill to pinball, challenging the notion that it was purely a game of chance. However, the bans remained in place for many years despite this development.
8. Who was Roger Sharpe and how did he help to lift the pinball bans?
Roger Sharpe was a pinball enthusiast and writer who played a key role in overturning the pinball bans. In 1976, he demonstrated to the New York City Council that pinball was a game of skill, convincing them to lift the city’s ban.
9. Is pinball still illegal anywhere in the United States?
While widespread bans are a thing of the past, South Carolina has a law prohibiting anyone under 18 from playing pinball. However, this law is rarely enforced.
10. Why is pinball making a comeback?
Pinball is experiencing a resurgence in popularity due to a combination of factors, including nostalgia, the increasing recognition of pinball as a skill-based game, and the development of new and innovative pinball machines.
11. What makes pinball different from gambling?
The key difference is the element of skill. While luck plays a role, skilled pinball players can control the ball, strategically aim for targets, and consistently achieve high scores. Games of gambling are typically based purely on chance.
12. What is “tilting” in pinball?
Tilting refers to shaking or bumping the pinball machine in an attempt to influence the ball’s trajectory. However, excessive tilting can trigger a “tilt” penalty, ending the player’s turn, it’s usually measured by a pendulum within the machine touching the side.
13. What are some of the most popular pinball machines ever made?
Some of the most popular pinball machines include Addams Family, Twilight Zone, Medieval Madness, and Attack From Mars.
14. Where can I find pinball machines to play today?
Pinball machines can be found in arcades, bars, restaurants, and private collections. Websites like Pinball Map can help you locate machines near you.
15. What skills can one learn from playing pinball?
Playing pinball can help develop hand-eye coordination, problem-solving skills, spatial reasoning, and strategic thinking. It can also promote patience and perseverance.