Table of Contents

Why is Plural Marriage Illegal? Unpacking the Complexities

Quick answer

This page answers Why is plural marriage illegal? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

Plural marriage, also known as polygamy (specifically polygyny when a man has multiple wives and polyandry when a woman has multiple husbands), is illegal primarily due to a complex interplay of historical, legal, social, and religious factors. At its core, the illegality stems from concerns about social order, gender equality, and the protection of vulnerable individuals, particularly women and children. Legally, it clashes with established monogamous marriage laws, which are deeply ingrained in Western legal traditions and are upheld by both state and federal jurisdictions. Furthermore, it can create intricate legal and social issues related to inheritance, child custody, and spousal rights that are difficult to resolve within the existing legal framework. This prohibition is further reinforced by international human rights standards that aim to protect the dignity and autonomy of women in marital relationships.

Historical Roots of the Ban

Common Law Origins and the Edmunds Act

The prohibition of polygamy in the United States has deep historical roots. Polygamy was a crime under common law, and this principle was later codified in statutory law. The landmark legislation that explicitly outlawed polygamy was the Edmunds Act of 1882. This federal law aimed directly at suppressing the practice of polygamy within the Mormon community, specifically targeting The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, which had openly practiced plural marriage. The Edmunds Act not only criminalized polygamy but also disenfranchised polygamists and made them ineligible for jury service. This legislation was part of a broader effort to assimilate Utah into the United States and to bring its legal system into alignment with the rest of the country.

The 19th-Century Social Context

In the 19th century, polygamy was often viewed as a threat to the traditional family structure and societal norms. Anti-polygamy rhetoric frequently portrayed it as a form of sexual exploitation of women and a violation of the sanctity of marriage. These views were deeply influenced by prevalent social and religious beliefs of the time. Furthermore, polygamy was linked to various social ills, further fueling public opposition and support for its criminalization.

Legal and Constitutional Challenges

Bigamy Laws and the Definition of Marriage

All U.S. states have bigamy laws that prohibit individuals from being legally married to more than one person at a time. These laws are the primary legal mechanism used to prosecute those who enter into plural marriages. The core concept is that a valid marriage requires the consent of two individuals to enter into a legally recognized union. Attempting to marry someone while already legally married is grounds for annulment of the subsequent marriage and can result in criminal charges.

Constitutional Arguments and Religious Freedom

While religious freedom is a fundamental right protected by the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, the Supreme Court has consistently held that this freedom is not absolute. In the landmark case Reynolds v. United States (1879), the Court upheld the constitutionality of the anti-polygamy laws, ruling that while the government cannot restrict religious beliefs, it can restrict religious practices that violate established laws. This decision established the principle that the government has the power to regulate activities deemed detrimental to public welfare, even if those activities are religiously motivated.

Social and Ethical Considerations

Gender Equality and the Dignity of Women

One of the primary arguments against polygamy is that it inherently undermines gender equality and violates the dignity of women. Critics argue that polygamous relationships often involve unequal power dynamics, where women may be treated as property or subjected to the will of the husband. The United Nations Human Rights Committee has specifically urged all countries to abolish polygamy, stating that it violates the freedom of women to marry with free and full consent.

Social Order and Potential for Conflict

Another concern is that polygamy can lead to social instability and conflict. Some studies suggest that societies with high rates of polygamy may experience higher levels of violence, crime, and social unrest. This is because polygamy can create competition for resources and mates, which can lead to aggressive or criminal behavior, particularly among men.

International Perspectives

International Human Rights Standards

The international community largely views polygamy as a violation of human rights, particularly the rights of women. The United Nations and various international organizations have advocated for the abolition of polygamy, citing its potential to harm women and children. Many countries have laws prohibiting or restricting polygamy, aligning with international human rights norms.

Varying Legal Frameworks Worldwide

While polygamy is illegal in many Western countries, it is legal or tolerated in some parts of the world, particularly in certain African and Middle Eastern countries. In these regions, polygamy is often rooted in cultural and religious traditions. However, even in countries where polygamy is legal, there are often regulations and restrictions in place to protect the rights of women and children.

FAQs About the Legality of Plural Marriage

Here are 15 frequently asked questions about the legality of plural marriage, with comprehensive answers to address common misconceptions and provide clarity on the topic.

Is polygamy the same as cheating? No. Polygamy involves multiple spouses with the knowledge and consent of all parties involved, while cheating (adultery) is being unfaithful to one’s married spouse without their consent.
What is the difference between polygamy and bigamy? Bigamy is the act of marrying someone while still legally married to another person, which is illegal in all U.S. states. Polygamy is the broader practice of having multiple spouses.
Why do some religions practice polygamy? Historically, some religions practiced polygamy for various reasons, including increasing the population, providing for widows, and consolidating power. While some religious groups have abandoned the practice, others continue to adhere to it.
Can I get legally married to more than one person in the U.S.? No. All U.S. jurisdictions prohibit individuals from having more than one legal spouse at a time.
What happens if I try to marry someone while already married? You can be charged with bigamy, which is a criminal offense. The subsequent marriage is also invalid and can be annulled.
Does the First Amendment protect polygamy as a form of religious freedom? While the First Amendment protects religious beliefs, the Supreme Court has ruled that it does not protect religious practices that violate established laws, such as anti-polygamy laws.
Are there any legal ways to have multiple partners in the U.S.? While polygamy is illegal, polyamory (having multiple romantic relationships with the consent of all parties) is not explicitly illegal, as long as the individuals are not legally married to more than one person.
What are the legal consequences of polygamy? The legal consequences can include criminal charges for bigamy, annulment of subsequent marriages, and loss of parental rights.
Is polygamy considered a human rights violation? Many international human rights organizations, including the United Nations, consider polygamy a violation of women’s rights and have called for its abolition.
Which countries allow polygamy? Polygamy is legal or tolerated in some parts of the world, particularly in certain African and Middle Eastern countries.
Did the Mormon Church always prohibit polygamy? No, the Mormon Church practiced polygamy from the 1830s to the early 1900s. However, it officially abandoned the practice in 1890.
What is the Edmunds Act? The Edmunds Act of 1882 was a federal law that criminalized polygamy and disenfranchised polygamists in the United States.
Why is polygamy often associated with patriarchal societies? Historically, polygamy has often been practiced in patriarchal societies, where men have more power and control over women’s lives.
How does polygamy affect children? Polygamy can have both positive and negative effects on children, depending on the specific circumstances. However, some studies suggest that children in polygamous families may experience higher rates of emotional and behavioral problems.
Is there a difference between polygyny and polyandry? Yes. Polygyny is when a man has multiple wives, while polyandry is when a woman has multiple husbands. Polygyny is far more common than polyandry.

Looking Ahead: The Future of Marriage Laws

The debate over the legality of plural marriage raises important questions about the definition of marriage and the role of government in regulating intimate relationships. As societal norms and values continue to evolve, it is possible that marriage laws will also change in the future. However, any potential changes would need to carefully consider the potential impact on gender equality, social order, and the well-being of all individuals involved. The Games Learning Society explores these complex societal issues through innovative learning experiences, demonstrating the power of understanding diverse perspectives. You can learn more about their work at GamesLearningSociety.org.

This examination underscores the multifaceted reasons behind the illegality of plural marriage, highlighting the ongoing tension between individual freedoms and societal values.