Why Is Undertale Controversial?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Undertale, the indie darling RPG created by Toby Fox, has garnered both immense praise and considerable controversy. The primary reason for its controversial nature lies in the intense and sometimes toxic behavior of its fanbase. While the game itself promotes themes of pacifism, friendship, and understanding, some members of the community have exhibited behaviors that are seen as harassing, obsessive, and generally off-putting, leading to a significant backlash against the game and its fans. This, combined with the game’s complex themes that can be unsuitable for younger children, and its association with “cringe” online culture, contributes to its negative reputation.
The Fandom’s Double-Edged Sword
Undertale’s success is undeniably linked to its passionate fanbase. However, this passion has often manifested in ways that are considered problematic.
Harassment and Overzealousness
One of the earliest sources of controversy stemmed from instances of harassment directed towards content creators and live streamers. Some fans took issue with players choosing to kill in-game characters or pursue the “genocide” route, resulting in online harassment campaigns. This aggressive behavior tarnished the image of the community and made many people wary of engaging with Undertale fans. The community has had its infamy stem after incidents involving harassed YouTubers, pornography, and fans who plastered the internet with in-game jokes. Over time, a game that started out as heartwarming and lovable gained infamy for supposedly having one of the worst fandoms on the internet.
Obsessive Fan Works and “Cringe” Culture
Undertale’s popularity also led to an explosion of fan-made content, including fan fiction, artwork, and music remixes. While much of this content was creative and well-intentioned, some of it was perceived as excessively sentimental, overly sexualized, or simply low-quality. The proliferation of these fan works, often shared widely online, contributed to a perception of the Undertale fanbase as being “cringe” or immature.
Popularity Backlash and the “Edgy” Factor
As Undertale’s popularity soared, a backlash inevitably emerged. Some individuals saw the game as overhyped or targeted towards a younger audience, leading to a rejection of the game and its fans. This rejection was sometimes expressed through online mockery and ridicule, further contributing to the negative perception of the Undertale community. People who think they are “too edgy” for the game, saw something stupid that its fans did and reflexively hate it.
Content Considerations
Beyond the fandom, certain aspects of the game’s content also contribute to its controversial nature.
Mature Themes and Difficulty
Despite its cartoonish appearance, Undertale explores complex themes such as death, morality, and the consequences of violence. These themes, combined with occasional frightening imagery and moments of intense gameplay, can make the game unsuitable for younger children. While Undertale is a creative video game with beautiful music and an intriguing story line, the game’s difficulty, complex themes, and occasionally frightening imagery make it inappropriate for younger children.
Disturbing Elements
The game also contains elements that some players may find disturbing, such as the unsettling designs of certain characters or the eerie atmosphere of the True Lab. The characters in Undertale are often bizarre and unsettling, with some appearing to be outright creepy or disturbing.
Is the Controversy Justified?
Whether the controversy surrounding Undertale is justified is a matter of opinion. While the negative behavior of some fans is undeniable, it’s important to remember that toxic individuals exist within all communities. To condemn the entire fanbase based on the actions of a few would be unfair. Furthermore, many people who have actually played the game tend to enjoy it. In the end, judging Undertale should be based on the game itself and not exclusively on the actions of some of its fans. Undertale is an excellent example of how video games can promote positive behavior. For more information on how gaming can have a positive impact, visit the Games Learning Society website.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions related to the controversy surrounding Undertale:
1. Is Undertale fandom toxic?
Yes, there are those who will harrass you till you play it. However, there are some fans whose works are quite good, if not sublime. there’s fans such as myself who will recommend it, but will not harrass or bring it up out of context. And there are those who just love playing undertale as is.
2. Why is Undertale not kid friendly?
The long answer: While Undertale is a creative video game with beautiful music and an intriguing story line, the game’s difficulty, complex themes, and occasionally frightening imagery make it inappropriate for younger children. In terms of difficulty, Undertale’s gameplay may be too complicated for younger players.
3. How disturbing is Undertale?
This dark and eerie setting can create a sense of unease and discomfort for some players. The characters: The characters in Undertale are often bizarre and unsettling, with some appearing to be outright creepy or disturbing.
4. Why do people simp over Sans?
One thing is this key aspect – personality. Sans is unadmittedly likable – he’s got a punny sense of humor, cares a bunch about his little brother, and is easy-going and laidback. Normal traits to admire and like right?
5. Do they swear in Undertale?
Profanity (12) Sexy is used multiple times. The player will be insulted by some characters but the insults are very mild, such as “idiot”. Papyrus, Alphys, and the pair of characters Catty and Bratty say “Oh my God!” multiple times. Undyne says hell at least once, and she and Alphys use damn at least once each.
6. Can you play Undertale without killing anyone?
You don’t have to kill anyone, and unless you’re going to kill everyone you’re better off without any bloodshed – not only is it the only way to experience the ‘true” ending, the vast majority of your encounters with enemies are a lot easier if you leave your weapon unused. The game wants you to finish it.
7. Is Flowey afraid of Chara?
He knows that there is another person with you. He is not afraid of Frisk… He is afraid of Chara.
8. Why does everyone like Sans so much?
Unique Personality: Sans is known for his laid-back, easygoing, and humorous personality. He often uses puns and jokes, which players find endearing and entertaining. His relaxed attitude contrasts with the game’s darker themes, making him a memorable character.
9. Can you get banned from Undertale?
Overview. Getting banned from the game can happen to you. EVERY BAN IS AN HWID BAN. IF YOU ARE HWID BANNED, YOU CAN NO LONGER JOIN THE GAME EVEN IF YOU HAVE AN ALT AS YOUR COUMPUTER ID IS BANNED.
10. Why does Sans always smile?
It could be argued that Sans uses his smile as a poker face to obscure his feelings or intentions, which is why he is always seen with it.
11. Who is bad Chara or Frisk?
It’s Frisk that is killing people (or technically the player, but I’ll use the player and Frisk interchangeably in this post.) Chara doesn’t force Frisk/the player to do anything, it’s entirely your choice.
12. Why was Chara evil Undertale?
The reason why they became pure evil is fairly simple. When they died, their soul was taken by Asriel, removed from their body. Their body was eventually taken to the ruins and buried under the golden flowers, but their soul wasn’t. This left them without a soul, and without compassion, like Flowey was.
13. Is it okay for Christians to play Undertale?
I would say yes, as it is (most of the time) a very wholesome game that has strong messages of kindness and friendship. However, there are multiple routes/endings to the game, one of which is the Genocide route. It requires you to kill every enemy in the game and is a lot darker in general.
14. Is there blood in Undertale?
The normal battles are mild in terms of violence, but if you choose to do a Genocide run and kill Sans, a giant bloody cut is seen on his stomach and blood dripping from his mouth. Not disturbing but intense.
15. What is the scariest part of Undertale?
Some of the scariest parts of Undertale include: Fighting Monster Kid, killing an almost spared Toriel, talking with Sans in the resort, finding the items from the previous humans (and their coffins), Lancer’s life being threatened by his own father, and Alphys’ Hidden Laboratory.
In conclusion, Undertale’s controversial status is a complex issue, driven by a combination of fan behavior, content considerations, and the inevitable backlash that accompanies widespread popularity. While the game itself offers valuable lessons about empathy and choice, its association with a sometimes-toxic fandom has unfortunately tarnished its reputation in some circles. However, many people who enjoy the game and its message of kindness and friendship continue to support it.