Why Some People Don’t Like Breath of the Wild
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (BotW) is often hailed as a masterpiece, revolutionizing the open-world genre and redefining the Zelda formula. However, despite its widespread acclaim, it’s not universally loved. Several factors contribute to why some players find themselves disappointed with BotW, ranging from issues with game design choices to personal preferences in gameplay experiences. Specifically, the lack of traditional Zelda elements, the weapon durability system, and the perceived emptiness of the open world are often cited as major drawbacks.
Core Complaints Against Breath of the Wild
At its heart, the dissatisfaction with BotW often boils down to the following:
-
Departure from Traditional Zelda Formula: For long-time fans, BotW’s radical shift from the established structure of dungeons, specific item acquisition, and a linear narrative can be jarring. The absence of classic items like the hookshot or boomerang and the prioritization of exploration over intricate dungeon puzzles disappointed many who valued these core elements.
-
Weapon Durability System: The infamous weapon durability system is a frequent point of contention. While intended to encourage experimentation and resourcefulness, many players found it frustrating to have weapons break constantly, especially during challenging encounters. The fleeting nature of powerful weapons diminished the sense of reward and progression.
-
Perceived Empty Open World: While vast and beautiful, some players felt the world of Hyrule lacked meaningful content. Despite the abundance of shrines and Korok seeds, the overall density of engaging activities and compelling side quests was seen as insufficient, leading to a feeling of emptiness and repetition.
-
Story and Character Development: The narrative in BotW is intentionally minimalist, focusing on exploration and player-driven storytelling. However, some found the story weak and the characters underdeveloped compared to previous Zelda games. The reliance on memories to piece together the narrative felt detached and less emotionally engaging for some.
-
Enemy and Boss Variety: While the combat system is praised for its fluidity, the limited variety of enemies and bosses became a recurring criticism. Many felt that the reused boss designs, particularly the Blight Ganons, lacked originality and were ultimately uninspired.
-
Art Style: While technically proficient, the “cartoony-realistic hybrid” art style of BotW (and Skyward Sword) didn’t appeal to all players. Some preferred the more stylized or realistic aesthetics of previous Zelda titles, finding BotW’s visuals generic or uninspired.
These elements, combined with individual gaming preferences, contribute to why some players couldn’t fully embrace the world of Hyrule in Breath of the Wild. The game’s success is undeniable, but its departures from tradition left some players feeling disconnected and unsatisfied. Game design is inherently subjective. A game that is well-received is bound to still have its criticisms and criticisms are important for the game’s evolution. For example, GamesLearningSociety.org studies the impact of game design elements on player engagement and learning, highlighting the complexities of creating universally appealing experiences.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Will I like Tears of the Kingdom if I disliked Breath of the Wild?
Possibly. Tears of the Kingdom addresses many of the criticisms leveled at Breath of the Wild. It offers improved enemy variety, more intricate dungeons, a richer storyline, and arguably a more engaging world. However, the weapon durability system remains, and the core gameplay loop is similar. If those were your primary issues with BotW, you might still find TotK frustrating.
2. How do people like Breath of the Wild?
People enjoy Breath of the Wild for its open-world freedom, emergent gameplay, and sense of discovery. Like Skyrim or Oblivion, it allows players to explore a vast world at their own pace, creating their own adventures and tackling challenges in creative ways.
3. Is Breath of the Wild too hard for beginners?
The initial hours of Breath of the Wild can be challenging, especially for newcomers to open-world games or those unfamiliar with the combat mechanics. However, the game generally becomes easier as players acquire better equipment and skills. The open-ended nature allows players to avoid difficult encounters until they are better prepared.
4. Which is better, Tears of the Kingdom or Breath of the Wild?
Many consider Tears of the Kingdom to be the superior game. It builds upon the foundation of Breath of the Wild, expanding the world, adding new mechanics (like Fuse and Ultrahand), and addressing some of the criticisms of its predecessor.
5. Is Tears of the Kingdom harder than Breath of the Wild?
Some players find Tears of the Kingdom to be more challenging than Breath of the Wild, particularly in the early game. Enemies are generally stronger, and the tutorial phase is more demanding. However, the new abilities also offer more strategic options for combat and exploration.
6. Is Tears of the Kingdom longer than Breath of the Wild?
Yes. Tears of the Kingdom features a larger map with more content, including the Sky Islands and the Depths. Completing all the main and side quests, exploring every nook and cranny, and collecting all the items will take significantly longer than in Breath of the Wild.
7. Which Zelda game is the easiest?
Several Zelda games are considered relatively easy, including Twilight Princess, The Wind Waker, and A Link Between Worlds. Breath of the Wild is generally considered easier than many classic Zelda titles due to its open-ended structure and the availability of powerful equipment.
8. Is Breath of the Wild a lonely game?
The atmosphere of Breath of the Wild can feel lonely, particularly in the early hours of the game. The world is vast and sparsely populated, emphasizing Link’s isolation and his quest to restore Hyrule. However, this sense of loneliness is intentional and contributes to the game’s overall narrative.
9. Why is Breath of the Wild so frustrating?
Frustration in Breath of the Wild often stems from the weapon durability system, the strength of enemies, and the perceived lack of clear direction. The constant breaking of weapons and the difficulty of combat can be discouraging for some players.
10. What is the scariest thing in Breath of the Wild?
Several elements in Breath of the Wild can be unsettling, including the Blood Moons, which resurrect all defeated enemies, the eerie Typhlo Ruins, and the imposing Hyrule Castle. The sense of vulnerability and the constant threat of danger can create a sense of unease for some players.
11. How long does it take the average person to beat Breath of the Wild?
Completing the main story of Breath of the Wild typically takes around 50 hours. However, exploring the world, completing side quests, and collecting all the items can extend the playtime to 100-200 hours or more.
12. What is the most annoying enemy in Breath of the Wild?
Many players find Wizzrobes to be particularly annoying due to their ability to manipulate the elements and their tendency to teleport away from danger. Lynels are also challenging and can be frustrating to fight, especially for inexperienced players.
13. What happens when you 100% Breath of the Wild?
There is no in-game reward for achieving 100% completion in Breath of the Wild. However, players who complete all the shrines, side quests, Korok seeds, and map locations can take pride in their accomplishment.
14. What is the most difficult enemy in Breath of the Wild?
Lynels are widely considered the toughest enemies in Breath of the Wild. Their high health, powerful attacks, and aggressive behavior make them formidable opponents, even for experienced players.
15. What not to do in Breath of the Wild?
Avoid attacking Cuccos, destroying Mellie’s plum garden, or dropping blocks on yourself. More seriously, avoid ignoring weapon durability and not exploring various options with your combat.
Ultimately, whether or not someone enjoys Breath of the Wild is a matter of personal taste. While it is celebrated by many, its unique design choices simply don’t resonate with everyone.