Would Geralt Break Dijkstra’s Leg? A Deep Dive into The Witcher 3’s Brutal Choices
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, Geralt would break Dijkstra’s leg, and in fact, he does so in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. This isn’t a hypothetical scenario; it’s a pivotal moment triggered by specific player choices during the quest “Reason of State.” The act isn’t born out of malice but rather a calculated move born from necessity and Geralt’s unwavering protectiveness over Ciri. While Geralt certainly isn’t one to solve problems with wanton violence, he’s pragmatically brutal when necessary. Dijkstra’s threat to harm Ciri to sideline Geralt during the political coup forces Geralt’s hand. The leg-breaking, while shocking, becomes a testament to Geralt’s brutal efficiency when the stakes involve his adopted daughter and the chaos around him. This moment also underscores the complex moral landscape of The Witcher 3, where clear-cut heroes and villains are scarce, and choices often lead to difficult and violent outcomes. The act highlights that Geralt is not a knight in shining armor but a gritty survivor prepared to do what is needed, regardless of how unpleasant it may be.
The Context of the Leg Breaking
The event occurs during a chaotic and politically charged meeting. Loyal northern mages launch a coup, targeting those involved in a Nilfgaardian conspiracy. In the midst of this upheaval, Dijkstra emerges, aiming to solidify his own power. When he threatens Ciri, who is incredibly important to Geralt, it forces Geralt to take drastic measures. The leg-breaking is not just a moment of violence, it’s a crucial turning point that dramatically alters the power dynamics and sets the stage for various potential endings within the game. It showcases the lengths Geralt will go to protect those he cares for, even if it involves resorting to physical violence against a powerful, albeit dangerous, political player.
The Consequences of Geralt’s Action
The act of breaking Dijkstra’s leg is not a one-off event with no impact. It is a pivotal choice that has far-reaching consequences on the game’s narrative. It impacts the quest “Reason of State” and sets the stage for how the war unfolds, which faction ultimately takes control of the north, and determines the final fate of several characters. This event highlights the impact of decisions made in The Witcher 3. They often involve painful choices, with no easy answers. Geralt’s actions here are a prime example of how player actions have severe and significant impact within the game’s world and narratives.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions that readers may have regarding the incident, its consequences, and related characters:
1. Why does Dijkstra want Ciri?
Dijkstra’s primary motivation for wanting Ciri isn’t altruistic. He aims to use her as a political pawn. His plan is to have her marry King Vizimir of Redania. This would effectively allow Redania to claim the throne of Cintra and establish itself as the dominant power on the Continent. It’s a strategic move on Dijkstra’s part, highlighting his cold, calculating nature and his political ambition. He sees Ciri as a means to an end, rather than as a person.
2. What happens if you let Dijkstra live?
If you help Dijkstra assassinate Radovid and then allow him to eliminate Roche, Ves, and Thaler during the “Reason of State” quest, he takes control over Redania. This leads to him winning the war against Nilfgaard. He rules with an iron fist, prioritizes industrial progress, but freedom suffers under his rule. He brings prosperity and technological advancement through intimidation and a strict control over his citizens, ultimately becoming a powerful, yet brutal leader.
3. How do you keep Dijkstra and Roche alive?
It’s a tricky balance. If you want both Dijkstra and Roche to survive, you have to allow Radovid to remain alive, or essentially fail the “Reason of State” quest. This pathway ensures the North wins the war. However, this comes with its own major drawback, Radovid continues his brutal witch hunts for four years. He will be remembered as the “Protector of the North,” but at a heavy cost. Thus, there is no way to have a peaceful and happy ending where both Dijkstra and Roche survive while also eliminating Radovid.
4. Does killing Radovid change anything?
Yes, significantly. If you assassinate Radovid and subsequently side with Dijkstra, then he will take power over the North. He will transform it using his iron-fisted control and his subjects will ultimately become unhappy due to the lack of freedom. His reign will become a technological and industrial powerhouse, but at the expense of personal liberties, leading to a dystopian-like rule.
5. Will Dijkstra help at Kaer Morhen?
No, Dijkstra will not help at Kaer Morhen regardless of your actions throughout the game. If you do manage to obtain his treasure through finding out its location by torturing Triss in an earlier quest, he’ll give you some money, but he is adamant about not helping you fight the Wild Hunt at Kaer Morhen. This highlights his cynical approach and his willingness to prioritize his own interests above all else.
6. Should you shove Dijkstra or tell him?
This is a key moment that will affect the “Reason of State” quest. If you choose to tell Dijkstra about the Emperor, you will receive an opportunity to involve yourself in the plot to kill Radovid. However, if you shove him aside, you will not receive the quest. This emphasizes that the decisions you make in The Witcher 3 are critical to the game’s direction and narrative.
7. Can Ciri become Empress if Dijkstra wins?
No, Ciri cannot become the Empress if Dijkstra wins the war. The only way Ciri can become Empress is if you take her to Emhyr before fighting Imlerith and the Ladies of the Wood AND you help the Nilfgaardian empire win the war, which also requires that you ensure both Radovid and Dijkstra are killed off. It’s important to note that Ciri has many possible fates depending on your actions during the game.
8. What happens if Dijkstra wins the war?
If Dijkstra wins the war, he becomes the absolute ruler of Redania and also wins the war against Nilfgaard. However, he rules with fear and intimidation. While the Continent will prosper industrially and technologically, the people will lose their freedom under his harsh rule. His reign is a testament to the idea that progress can come at a considerable moral cost.
9. Is Dijkstra a good guy?
Dijkstra’s morality is deeply complex. While he does bring technological advances and prosperity, he is not a virtuous character. He is ruthless, cunning, and willing to sacrifice freedom for power. Whether he is “good” is largely up to player interpretation. His pragmatism and ends justify the means approach make him a controversial figure, leading many players to dislike him due to his tyrannical rule.
10. Were Philippa and Dijkstra lovers?
The books imply a past relationship between Philippa and Dijkstra. However, the exact nature of the relationship isn’t explicitly stated and its sexual aspects are never explored outright. Philippa often uses Dijkstra’s past affections to manipulate him. This adds an additional layer of intrigue to the complex relationship between these two powerful characters.
11. Does Dijkstra hate Geralt?
Yes, Dijkstra dislikes Geralt. This dislike stems from past encounters where Geralt outmaneuvered him, and notably, an instance when Dijkstra was temporarily crippled. This is often viewed as an “injury to insult” situation. The past encounters are the source of a deep-seated resentment that is apparent in their interactions.
12. Can Ciri be a Witcher if Radovid dies?
Yes, Ciri can become a Witcher even if Radovid dies. In fact, it’s even a preferred outcome by many players. The game’s endings are far more nuanced than just one faction winning or losing the war. It’s possible to have a happy ending where Ciri becomes a Witcher if you’ve made good decisions throughout the main story narrative.
13. Is Vilgefortz the main villain?
Yes, Vilgefortz of Roggeveen is often regarded as the main antagonist of The Witcher book series. He is a powerful mage who stands in opposition to many of the main characters. He’s shown to be ruthless, ambitious, and extremely dangerous and is a major antagonist in the Netflix TV adaptation as well.
14. What is the best ending in Witcher 3?
Many consider Ciri’s Witcher ending to be the best conclusion. In this ending, Ciri survives the final battle and chooses the path of a Witcher. This ending often resonates with players because it feels thematically consistent with her character’s free spirit and fiery nature. This outcome is earned by trusting Ciri and supporting her own choices throughout the game’s narrative.
15. Why does Geralt hate portals?
Geralt dislikes portals because they are unreliable. There have been several instances within the universe of The Witcher where people have been mutilated or disappeared entirely while using portals, resulting in severe consequences. The unpredictability and potential danger of portals are the main reason for Geralt’s aversion to them.