Can You Counter a Suspended Card? A Comprehensive MTG Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, you can counter a suspended card, but only at a specific time: when the last time counter is removed and the card is being cast. The suspend ability itself (putting the card into exile initially) and the triggered abilities that remove time counters cannot be directly countered by standard counterspells like Counterspell. However, abilities like Stifle can counter the triggered abilities that remove the time counters each upkeep. Let’s dive into the nuances of countering suspended cards in Magic: The Gathering (MTG).
Understanding Suspend
Before we get into the specifics of countering, let’s quickly recap what suspend does. Suspend is a mechanic that allows you to exile a card from your hand and put time counters on it. Each of your upkeeps, you remove a time counter. When the last time counter is removed, you cast the card without paying its mana cost. This is the key point where interaction is possible.
The Countering Window: Casting from Exile
The crucial moment for countering a suspended card is when it’s being cast from exile. This is considered casting a spell, and as such, it’s vulnerable to all the usual counterspells. Cards like Counterspell, Essence Scatter, or Dissolve can be used at this point.
Examples
- Your opponent suspends a creature like Greater Gargadon. On their last upkeep, the last time counter is removed. The Gargadon is now being cast. You can respond by casting Counterspell, sending the Gargadon to the graveyard instead of the battlefield.
What You Can’t Counter Directly
It’s equally important to understand what you can’t counter.
- The Suspend Ability Itself: When your opponent initially uses the suspend ability, it is a special action like playing a land. It is not a spell or ability, so cannot be countered by anything.
- The Triggered Abilities: These are the triggers on each of your upkeep that remove time counters. While you can’t use a counterspell on these triggers, cards like Stifle, Voidslime or abilities like Azorius Guildmage can be used to counter them.
FAQ: Countering Suspend and Suspended Cards
Here are 15 frequently asked questions about countering suspend and dealing with suspended cards in MTG.
1. Can you target a suspended card with abilities?
Yes, to a degree. While it is in exile with suspend counters on it, you can target a suspended card. You can target the card while in exile with effects that allow you to target cards in exile, such as removing it from the game.
2. Can you proliferate time counters on suspended cards?
No. Proliferate only allows you to choose permanents or players that already have counters. A suspended card in exile is neither a permanent nor a player.
3. Are suspended cards considered permanents?
No. Permanents are cards on the battlefield. A suspended card is in the exile zone.
4. Are there ways to remove time counters from suspended cards besides waiting?
Yes. Several cards specifically interact with time counters. Examples include Clockspinning, Fury Charm, and Jhoira’s Timebug. These can either remove time counters faster or add more, depending on the card’s effect.
5. Can you counterspell the suspend ability?
No. Suspending a card is a special action, similar to playing a land. It bypasses the stack and cannot be countered.
6. Can you cascade into a suspended card?
No, you cannot cascade into a card for its suspend cost. Suspend reads “rather than cast this card from your hand.” This means you can’t cascade into a card for its suspend cost. But you can still cast the card for its normal cost, like Search for Tomorrow.
7. Are suspend cards revealed to all players?
Yes. Suspend is a face-up mechanic. The card is revealed when put into exile.
8. What happens if a card with suspend is discarded?
If a card with suspend is discarded, it simply goes to the graveyard, unless another effect sends it elsewhere (like exile). The suspend ability only works if the card is in your hand.
9. If I Stifle the triggered ability that removes a time counter, what happens?
The time counter is not removed. The suspended card remains in exile with one more time counter, delaying its casting.
10. Does a creature cast from suspend have summoning sickness?
Yes, but it gains haste if it is cast as a result of the suspend ability and can attack and tap as if it didn’t. So while it does have summoning sickness, it gains haste if it is cast as a result of the suspend ability and can attack and tap as if it didn’t.
11. Can you exile a suspended card?
Yes. Once the card is suspended, it’s in exile. It can be targeted by effects that target cards in exile, such as removing it from the game entirely.
12. Can you copy a suspended card?
While the card is suspended (in exile), it is just a card in exile. You can’t copy it with something like Twincast at this point. You have to wait until the card is actually being cast to copy it.
13. Can you reactivate a suspended card after the game?
No. Once a card is suspended in a game, it remains in exile until resolved or the game ends.
14. Can you flashback a card with suspend?
You can give the card flashback, you can only cast the card, you can’t suspend it.
15. Does countering the card when it is cast from suspend stop the suspend ability?
The suspend ability has already done its job when the card is cast. Countering the card only stops the spell from resolving. The suspend mechanic itself is unaffected.
Strategic Considerations
Knowing when and how to counter a suspended card is crucial. Consider the following:
- Mana Availability: Ensure you have the mana to cast your counterspell when the suspended card is being cast.
- Priority: Pay close attention to priority. Your opponent has the chance to respond to your counterspell, so be prepared for a potential counter-war.
- Alternative Options: Sometimes, it’s better to let the suspended card resolve and deal with it later, especially if you have a more efficient answer (like a board wipe) or if countering it would leave you vulnerable.
- Reading Your Opponent: If your opponent suspends a high-impact card, they are likely relying on it. Countering it at the right moment can disrupt their strategy significantly.
Delving Deeper: Additional Resources
To further enhance your understanding of MTG rules and mechanics, consider exploring resources like the official MTG Comprehensive Rules and engaging with the Games Learning Society, which explores the educational aspects of gaming. Visit GamesLearningSociety.org for more information.
Conclusion
Countering a suspended card in MTG requires understanding the timing and limitations involved. You can’t directly counter the suspend ability or the time counter removal triggers with counterspells, but you can counter the card when it’s being cast from exile. Using this knowledge strategically can give you a significant edge in your games.
By mastering these nuances, you’ll be better equipped to handle the complexities of Magic: The Gathering and navigate the challenges posed by the suspend mechanic. Good luck, and happy dueling!