Could Joel Have Survived His Injuries in The Last of Us? A Medical Analysis
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Could Joel Miller have survived the brutal injuries he sustained in The Last of Us, both in the original game and the HBO adaptation? The short answer is: maybe, but it was highly improbable, especially considering the circumstances. While survival is theoretically possible in the best-case scenario with immediate, advanced medical care, the likelihood of Joel surviving the rebar impalement (game) and the stab wound (show) in a post-apocalyptic world with limited resources and skills is drastically reduced. Let’s delve into a detailed breakdown.
The Severity of Joel’s Wounds: A Closer Look
Rebar Impalement (Game)
The rebar impalement Joel suffers in the original game is particularly egregious. The fall from the hospital mezzanine coupled with being impaled poses several immediate threats:
- Internal Bleeding: Rebar is often rusty and jagged, creating a non-sterile, tearing wound. Vital organs could be damaged, leading to rapid internal hemorrhage.
- Shock: The trauma and blood loss would quickly induce hypovolemic shock, a life-threatening condition.
- Infection: In a world overrun with fungal infections, introducing a dirty piece of metal deep into the body is a recipe for disaster. Bacterial infections like tetanus or sepsis would be highly likely.
- Pneumothorax: If the rebar penetrated the chest cavity, it could cause a collapsed lung, leading to severe respiratory distress.
Ellie’s removal of the rebar, while necessary to escape, would have exacerbated the bleeding. The fact that they escaped the enemy assault without paying the puncture wound any mind whatsoever (as the included text mentions) defies logic. In reality, Joel would have likely bled out in minutes or hours at most, succumbing to the effects of shock and trauma.
Stab Wound (Show)
While the stab wound in the HBO adaptation is less overtly gruesome than the rebar, it still presents a significant challenge to survival:
- Depth and Location: The depth and specific location of the wound are crucial. A deep stab wound near major blood vessels (like the aorta or vena cava) could cause catastrophic bleeding.
- Organ Damage: Depending on the angle and force, the knife could have damaged organs like the stomach, intestines, liver, or kidneys. Each presents its own set of complications.
- Infection: As with the rebar, infection remains a significant risk.
- Delayed Complications: Even if Joel initially survived, complications like peritonitis (inflammation of the abdominal lining) could arise days later, leading to death.
The show implies that Ellie’s efforts to find medicine were crucial to Joel’s survival. However, access to antibiotics, sterile surgical tools, and the knowledge to manage potential complications would have been necessary for a truly realistic recovery.
The Unrealistic Aspects of Joel’s Survival
Several elements contribute to the unrealistic portrayal of Joel’s survival in The Last of Us:
- Immediate Medical Care: In both scenarios, Joel lacks immediate, professional medical attention. He needs a trauma surgeon, sterile operating room, blood transfusions, and a cocktail of antibiotics, none of which are available.
- The “Plot Armor” Effect: In storytelling, characters sometimes survive situations that would realistically kill them. This plot armor is a common trope, but it sacrifices realism for the sake of narrative progression.
- The Pace of Recovery: Joel’s recovery time seems accelerated. Even with excellent medical care, recovering from such severe trauma would take weeks or months, not days.
Could Anyone Survive These Injuries?
Yes, it’s theoretically possible for someone to survive injuries similar to Joel’s with immediate and comprehensive medical intervention. However, the following factors would be crucial:
- Rapid Transport to a Hospital: Within minutes of the injury.
- Skilled Trauma Surgeons: Trained to stop bleeding, repair organ damage, and manage shock.
- Availability of Blood Transfusions: To replace lost blood volume.
- Broad-Spectrum Antibiotics: To combat infection.
- Intensive Care Monitoring: To manage potential complications.
Without these resources, the odds of survival are incredibly slim. Joel’s resilience in The Last of Us highlights his character’s toughness, but it doesn’t necessarily reflect real-world medical realities.
Joel’s Mental State and Its Impact
The provided text also highlights Joel’s mental state, including his panic attacks, anxiety, and past trauma. While these conditions wouldn’t directly impact his survival of the physical injuries, they would significantly affect his recovery and coping mechanisms. Psychological trauma can complicate the healing process and impact a person’s ability to fight off infection.
The Games Learning Society and the Realism of Games
The portrayal of injuries and medical care in games like The Last of Us offers a unique opportunity for learning and discussion. GamesLearningSociety.org explores the educational potential of video games, and the realism (or lack thereof) in such scenarios can be a valuable teaching tool. The discussion around Joel’s survival can be a starting point to teach gamers about biology, medical science and the actual effects of trauma.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Joel’s Injuries and Survival
Here are 15 frequently asked questions related to Joel’s injuries and survival in The Last of Us:
1. With the way violence works in the television adaptation, there’s simply no way the Joel of the HBO series would’ve survived the fall and rebar impairment. The fall alone would’ve been enough to kill him thanks to head trauma or internal bleeding.
You are correct. The cumulative effect of the fall, potential head trauma, and the rebar impalement, combined with the lack of immediate medical attention, makes Joel’s survival in the game incredibly unlikely. The HBO adaptation addressed this by changing the injury to a stab wound, which, while still serious, is somewhat more plausible to survive.
2. Could you survive Joel’s injury? Yes it is possible. But not necessary everybody would survive of the same wound under the same or equal circumstance.
The crucial phrase is “under the same or equal circumstance”. With access to a modern hospital and skilled medical professionals, survival is possible. In the apocalyptic setting of The Last of Us, however, the odds are heavily stacked against survival.
3. Could Joel have survived the rebar? Ellie removes Joel from the rebar soon after and they successfully escape the enemy assault, without paying the puncture wound any mind whatsoever. In real life, Joel would have almost certainly bled to death within minutes of being disimpaled.
This is a valid point. The removal of the rebar without proper medical equipment would likely cause significant, rapid blood loss. Even if bleeding was initially controlled, the risk of infection remains extremely high. The show’s altered approach makes this more plausible but hardly realistic.
4. Does Joel survive being stabbed in the stomach? No, Joel Does Not Die In The Last Of Us Episode 6
This is a factual statement. Joel survives the initial stabbing in episode 6 of the HBO series.
5. This is the case with Joel who does not die in The Last of Us, despite his injury meaning big things for the coming episodes. As is known from the original game, Joel’s wound will cause Ellie to look for medicine.
The search for medicine is a narrative device to drive the story and showcase Ellie’s resourcefulness and compassion. It also allows the viewer to see a character and understand the struggles people have to go through.
6. How did Joel survive being bitten? Ellie cleaned him, probably used some alcohol, and sewed him up before he lost too much blood. We’ll just have to believe in the fact that he has a crazy immune system and didn’t get an infection, the wound didn’t hit any major organs, and through crazy luck, he survived.
This is not in the story. He was never bitten. He was never at risk to turn into the infected.
7. What if Joel had Survived The Last Of Us Part 2? – ChatGPT Predicts
This is a hypothetical scenario outside the established canon. Joel’s death is a central plot point in The Last of Us Part II, and altering that event would significantly change the narrative.
8. Is it possible Joel is still alive? Though Joel survives the first Last of Us game, he meets his fate in The Last of Us II at the hands of a character named Abby.
This is a definitive statement based on the established storyline. Joel’s death is a fixed event in The Last of Us Part II.
9. Why didn t Joel get infected? Sunday’s episode of “The Last of Us” revealed how the cordyceps fungal infection likely spread so rapidly around the world. It turns out Joel may have narrowly avoided being infected simply because of his food choices on the series’ pilot.
Joel and Ellie are never infected during any part of the HBO or video game story.
10. Why does Joel grab his chest? “You see some of that as they exit the cabin as he seizes his chest.” Mazin confirms Joel is suffering a panic attack, “and he doesn’t know why.” “Panic attacks feel very much like heart attacks,” Mazin says, “It’s your body telling you you’re in terrible danger, but you don’t understand yet why.
The chest-grabbing indicates a panic attack, highlighting the psychological toll of Joel’s past trauma and his growing attachment to Ellie.
11. Why did they change Joel’s injury? This change in Joel’s injury may not have resulted from a bombastic action set piece like in the games, but it trades that for realism, which is a key element of The Last of Us show. There’s a lot less leeway for suspension of disbelief in a live-action TV show, making this change a pretty smart one.
The change to a stab wound increases the realism and plausibility of Joel’s survival, aligning better with the show’s grounded and character-driven approach.
12. What happens to Joel after he gets impaled? During the climax of the University sequence, Joel is impaled on a rebar after falling from the hospital’s mezzanine while fighting a Hunter mook. Ellie removes Joel from the rebar soon after and they successfully escape the enemy assault, without paying the puncture wound any mind whatsoever.
As previously discussed, the escape without paying any mind to the injury is a significant departure from realistic medical consequences.
13. What does Joel suffer from? While none of Joel’s medical issues are in the game’s story, this fact brings new context into how Joel behaves in the game. Especially towards Ellie. Joel’s anxiety meds in The Last of Us reveal Joel suffered from anxiety and high blood pressure even before the apocalypse.
Joel’s pre-existing anxiety and high blood pressure add another layer of complexity to his character and help explain certain aspects of his behavior. These conditions could also make him more vulnerable to the physical and psychological effects of trauma.
14. How many years did Joel survive? Fleeing his home near Austin with his brother Tommy and his 12-year-old daughter Sarah, they got involved in a firefight with a soldier; Sarah was mortally wounded and died in his arms, leaving him traumatized. In the 20 years that followed, Joel did whatever he had to do to survive.
This outlines the timeline of Joel’s life and highlights the pivotal event that shaped his character and his actions throughout the story.
15. Did Joel stop a cure? Still, despite this clear in-character morality, objectively it’s possible that Joel didn’t prevent a cure from happening. It’s quite possible that the doctors with the Fireflies were desperate and taking a risk.
Whether or not Joel prevented a cure is a complex moral dilemma at the heart of The Last of Us. There is no definitive answer, and different interpretations are possible. You can learn more about these themes at the Games Learning Society website: https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.
In conclusion, while Joel’s survival showcases his resilience and the power of hope, it also highlights the narrative liberties taken in The Last of Us. The portrayal of his injuries and recovery stretches the boundaries of realism, reminding us that even in a post-apocalyptic world, the laws of medicine still apply.