Does Killing Regalla Change the Story in Horizon Forbidden West?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, killing Regalla does change the story, although not in a way that drastically alters the ending. The core narrative of Horizon Forbidden West remains the same regardless of your choice. However, the decision significantly impacts Aloy’s immediate interactions, available rewards, and a particular scene near the game’s conclusion. Sparing or killing Regalla affects which characters are present at key moments and influences Aloy’s moral standing within the game’s context. Ultimately, it is up to the player to decide what is best for Aloy.
The Regalla Dilemma: Kill or Spare?
One of the most compelling moral choices in Horizon Forbidden West is deciding the fate of Regalla, the leader of the rebel Tenakth faction. This isn’t a simple good versus evil scenario; it’s a clash of ideologies and a test of Aloy’s compassion versus her pragmatism. Let’s delve into what changes based on your decision.
If You Choose to Kill Regalla
- Immediate Consequences: Regalla’s story ends abruptly. Kotallo swiftly executes her, reflecting the Tenakth’s strict code of justice.
- Reward: You receive Regalla’s Wrath, a powerful Sharpshooter Bow considered by many to be game-breakingly good. Its high damage output makes it a valuable asset throughout the rest of the game.
- Impact on Allies: Kotallo and other Tenakth warriors are satisfied with your decision, reinforcing their respect for Aloy as a worthy ally.
- Late-Game Absence: Regalla will not appear during the final battle against the Zeniths. The area where she would have died, had she been spared, remains unchanged.
If You Choose to Spare Regalla
- Immediate Consequences: Aloy intervenes, preventing Kotallo from killing Regalla. Instead, Regalla is given a chance to redeem herself by fighting alongside Aloy against the Zeniths.
- Reward: Chief Hekarro rewards Aloy with a valuable piece of Tenakth armor, a testament to the alliance forged.
- Impact on Allies: While Kotallo and some other Tenakth warriors are skeptical, Hekarro sees the potential in Regalla’s fighting prowess and the strategic advantage she brings.
- Late-Game Appearance: Regalla appears during the Singularity mission, fighting valiantly alongside Aloy and her companions as they storm the Zenith base.
- Ironic Fate: Despite being spared, Regalla meets her end during this final battle, finding the warrior’s death she sought.
- Cool Scene: Players who spare Regalla get to experience a cool scene near the end of the game.
Moral and Narrative Implications
The choice is not solely about acquiring the best gear. It also touches on Aloy’s character development and the themes of redemption and forgiveness.
- Aloy’s Character: Killing Regalla may seem out of character for Aloy, who typically strives to find peaceful solutions and believes in the potential for change. Sparing Regalla aligns more with Aloy’s compassionate nature, even if it’s a risky decision.
- Theme of Redemption: Sparing Regalla explores the possibility of redemption, even for those who have committed terrible acts. It challenges the Tenakth’s rigid justice system and offers a path towards unity.
- Strategic Advantage: Regalla is a formidable warrior. Having her fight alongside Aloy against the Zeniths provides a tactical advantage, albeit a temporary one.
- Player Choice: Ultimately, the decision reflects the player’s own values and how they want to shape Aloy’s journey. Do they prioritize immediate rewards and the satisfaction of justice, or do they believe in second chances and the power of alliance?
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Regalla’s Fate
1. What is the best choice: killing or sparing Regalla?
There’s no definitive “best” choice. It depends on your play style and priorities. If you value a powerful weapon, kill Regalla. If you prefer a compelling narrative moment and a chance for redemption, spare her.
2. Does sparing Regalla change the game’s ending?
The core ending remains the same. However, sparing Regalla leads to a specific scene during the final battle and affects dialogue with other characters.
3. What are the specific rewards for each choice?
Killing Regalla rewards you with Regalla’s Wrath Sharpshooter Bow. Sparing her rewards you with Tenakth armor from Chief Hekarro.
4. Does Regalla survive if you spare her?
No. Regalla dies during the final battle against the Zeniths, regardless of your choice.
5. Is Regalla’s Wrath bow worth killing her for?
Many players consider Regalla’s Wrath to be one of the best bows in the game due to its high damage output and accuracy. If you prioritize combat effectiveness, it’s a worthwhile reward.
6. Does killing Regalla affect Aloy’s reputation with the Tenakth?
No. While some warriors may prefer that you kill Regalla, your overall reputation with the Tenakth remains positive, especially if you continue to help their clans.
7. What happens if I choose the “This isn’t easy” dialogue option?
This dialogue option doesn’t change the outcome. It simply provides Aloy with an opportunity to express her conflicted feelings about the decision.
8. Does Regalla’s presence in the final battle make a significant difference?
Regalla’s presence in the final battle is a nice addition. Ultimately, whether she is there or not does not significantly impact the outcome of the battle itself.
9. Are there any achievements or trophies tied to this decision?
No, there are no achievements or trophies specifically linked to the decision of whether to kill or spare Regalla.
10. Does the difficulty level affect the consequences of this choice?
No, the difficulty level does not affect the consequences of whether to kill or spare Regalla.
11. What is the best way to beat Regalla in combat?
Focus on targeting her head with arrows, especially after removing her helmet. Utilize Aloy’s skills and elemental weaknesses to your advantage.
12. How does this decision compare to other moral choices in the Horizon series?
The Regalla decision is similar to other moral choices in the Horizon series, such as those in Horizon Zero Dawn, where decisions impact character relationships and immediate outcomes, but rarely alter the main storyline’s conclusion. The Games Learning Society and other research communities are beginning to study how these choices affect player engagement.
13. Who is the most important character to Aloy in the story?
According to developers, Varl was the most important character to Aloy. This is why his death had such a profound impact on her.
14. Is Sylens a good or bad guy?
Sylens is a complex character whose motives are often unclear. He is not necessarily evil but is driven by his own desires and knowledge, regardless of the consequences.
15. How do you beat Regalla on Ultra Hard difficulty?
On Ultra Hard, focus on removing Regalla’s helmet with precision shots and then targeting her head for critical damage. Use elemental attacks and dodge effectively to survive her powerful attacks.
Final Thoughts
The decision to kill or spare Regalla in Horizon Forbidden West is a testament to the game’s compelling narrative and character development. While it doesn’t fundamentally alter the ending, it provides a unique opportunity for players to shape Aloy’s journey and explore the complex themes of justice, redemption, and the difficult choices that come with saving the world. So choose wisely, and may your path be filled with epic battles and unwavering resolve! Don’t forget to explore other fascinating topics related to game-based learning at GamesLearningSociety.org.