Remake vs. Remaster: Which Reign Supreme?

Quick answer

This page answers Is a remake better than a remaster? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

Is a remake better than a remaster? The answer, frustratingly, is: it depends. It depends on what you’re looking for, what the original source material was like, and how well the remake or remaster was executed. There’s no one-size-fits-all answer because these are fundamentally different approaches to preserving and updating classic media. One offers a fresh perspective, while the other enhances the original experience. Let’s dive deep into this fascinating debate.

Understanding the Core Differences

To truly appreciate the nuances of this debate, we need to clearly define what a remake and a remaster actually are. This also includes a definition for reboots.

What is a Remaster?

A remaster is like giving an old painting a good cleaning and touch-up. It focuses on improving the technical aspects of the original work. For video games, this typically means:

Increased resolution: Sharper textures and models, leading to a clearer image.
Improved frame rates: Smoother gameplay for a more modern feel.
Enhanced audio: Cleaner sound effects and music, often re-recorded or upscaled.
Minor bug fixes: Addressing technical issues present in the original.

The goal of a remaster is to make the original game look and sound its best without altering the core gameplay, story, or art style. It’s about enhancing what already exists. The intention is to introduce classic experiences to new audiences with the knowledge that they’re deserving of such revisions. A great example is “The Last of Us Remastered” for the PlayStation 4 which improved upon the original PlayStation 3 release.

What is a Remake?

A remake, on the other hand, is more like re-imagining the painting entirely. It’s a more substantial undertaking that involves rebuilding the game from the ground up. This can include:

Updated graphics: Completely new art assets and models.
Modified gameplay: Changes to mechanics, controls, and level design.
Expanded story: Added content, new characters, or altered plot points.
Modernized presentation: New user interface and cinematic cutscenes.

The intent of a remake is usually to take an older game that has become outdated and update it for a new platform and audience. A remake tells the same story as the original but uses a different set of casts, and may use actors from the original, alter the theme, or change the flow and setting of the story. The remake intends to recreate the idea of using modern methods in order to show to the audience the genius ideas of the creators of the past. While retaining key characters and story elements. A prime example is “Resident Evil 2 Remake,” which dramatically modernized the classic survival horror game while staying true to its core essence.

What is a Reboot?

A reboot is like starting with a blank canvas and painting something completely new, inspired by the original. A reboot is a new game with a fresh storyline, including some elements of the original game. The remake intends to regenerate the basis of original story but updating and re-writing not the original show but a new version of it. The new story can use the same premise as the earlier storyline, a few of the key characters, or use the same setting as the original. A prime example is “Tomb Raider (2013),” which retold Lara Croft’s origin story with a grittier, more realistic tone.

The Case for Remasters

Remasters shine when the original game is already strong in its core design but held back by technical limitations. They offer a chance to experience a beloved classic in its best possible light.

Preserving the Original Vision

One of the biggest strengths of a remaster is its respect for the original creator’s vision. It doesn’t try to reinvent the wheel but rather polishes it to a brilliant shine. This is particularly important for games with iconic art styles or unique gameplay mechanics that might be lost in a more radical remake.

Accessibility for Modern Audiences

Remasters can make classic games more accessible to a wider audience. Improved graphics, smoother performance, and updated control schemes can overcome the barriers that might deter younger gamers or those unfamiliar with older titles.

Nostalgia Done Right

For longtime fans, remasters offer a chance to relive cherished memories without compromising the essence of what made the original so special. It’s a nostalgic trip with a fresh coat of paint.

The Case for Remakes

Remakes excel when the original game has significant flaws or untapped potential. They offer a chance to address shortcomings, expand upon existing ideas, and create something truly special.

Fixing Flaws and Addressing Criticism

Remakes provide an opportunity to rectify issues that plagued the original game, such as clunky controls, confusing level design, or underdeveloped characters. They can take fan feedback into account and create a more polished and satisfying experience.

Expanding the World and Story

Remakes can delve deeper into the lore, characters, and world of the original game, adding new content, exploring unexplored themes, and providing a richer narrative experience. This is an opportunity to rework such stories in a modern context, allowing them to amend parts of the scripts or songs that are no longer acceptable in today’s day and age, thus adapting the classic Disney animation works to a more modern audience.

Introducing New Gameplay Mechanics

Remakes can modernize the gameplay mechanics of the original, incorporating new features, refining existing systems, and making the game more engaging for contemporary audiences.

When Do Remasters Fall Short?

Remasters are not without their limitations. If the original game had fundamental design flaws, a remaster can only do so much to improve the experience. Polishing a flawed gem doesn’t make it a diamond.

Limited Scope of Improvement

Remasters are inherently limited by their focus on technical improvements. They can’t address deeper issues with the game’s story, characters, or gameplay mechanics.

The Risk of Diminishing Returns

Sometimes, the improvements offered by a remaster are not significant enough to justify the purchase, especially for players who already own the original game.

The “Loudness War” in Audio

In audio remasters, be mindful of the “loudness war,” where the average volume is increased and dynamic range is compressed at the expense of clarity, making the remastered version sound louder at regular listening volume and more distorted than an uncompressed unremastered version.

When Do Remakes Miss the Mark?

Remakes are a much riskier proposition than remasters. They have the potential to be transformative, but they also carry the risk of alienating fans of the original.

Loss of Original Charm

In trying to modernize the game, remakes can sometimes lose the charm and character that made the original so special. This can be due to changes in art style, voice acting, or even the overall tone of the game.

Unnecessary Changes

Some remakes make changes that are simply unnecessary or even detrimental to the experience. These changes can be motivated by a desire to appeal to a wider audience or to simply put a personal stamp on the game.

Gameplay Issues

Remakes sometimes have an updated gameplay that falls short of the older version.

Factors to Consider When Choosing

Ultimately, the decision of whether a remake or remaster is “better” comes down to personal preference.

Your Relationship with the Original: If you have a deep love for the original and want to experience it in its best possible form, a remaster is likely the better choice.
Your Tolerance for Change: If you’re open to significant changes and are willing to accept a different interpretation of the original, a remake might be more appealing.
The Quality of the Implementation: Regardless of whether it’s a remake or a remaster, the quality of the implementation is crucial. A poorly executed remake can be far worse than a well-done remaster.

Making an Informed Decision

Before deciding whether to buy a remake or a remaster, research. Watch gameplay videos, read reviews, and listen to the opinions of other fans. This will help you make an informed decision and avoid disappointment.

The Games Learning Society is a community dedicated to supporting research and collaboration on games and learning. Visit Games Learning Society to learn more about how games can be used for educational purposes.

Conclusion: There’s Room for Both

In the end, there’s no need to choose sides in the remake vs. remaster debate. Both have their place in the world of gaming, and both can offer valuable experiences to players. The key is to understand the differences between them and to choose the option that best suits your individual preferences. Remakes hold a valuable spot in the zeitgeist so long as they serve a purpose. Introducing classic experiences to new audiences with the knowledge that they’re deserving of such revisions is important, not because of guaranteed popularity, but due to the evolution in which they can afford entire genres and franchises.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are 15 frequently asked questions about remakes and remasters, providing additional valuable information for the readers:

What’s the legal stance on remaking a game?
- You can’t keep the real names nor the same level structure with improved graphics. That will be a partial remake of a game and that is forbidden by law, even if you are not charging money for the game. You can however copy the style and make it very similar without infringing copyright.
Is a remastered movie always better than the original?
- Remastering often means scanning the film at current high resolution, so it almost always looks better. Technology has changed so much in the last 20 years that even silent films look fantastic when remastered.
What does “remastered quality” truly mean?
- A remaster is a change in the sound or image quality of previously created forms of media, whether audiophonic, cinematic, or videographic. The resulting product is said to be remastered. The terms digital remastering and digitally remastered are also used.
Why are games remade in the first place?
- A remake typically maintains the same story, genre, and fundamental gameplay ideas of the original work. The intent of a remake is usually to take an older game that has become outdated and update it for a new platform and audience.
Why are remakes so popular in the entertainment industry?
- Remakes hold a valuable spot in the zeitgeist so long as they serve a purpose. Introducing classic experiences to new audiences with the knowledge that they’re deserving of such revisions is important, not because of guaranteed popularity, but due to the evolution in which they can afford entire genres and franchises.
Why does Disney frequently create remakes of their animated classics?
- They give the creators a chance to rework such stories in a modern context, allowing them to amend parts of the scripts or songs that are no longer acceptable in today’s day and age, thus adapting the classic Disney animation works to a more modern audience.
Is a remake just a money-grab by Hollywood studios?
- Hollywood film studios are only interested in making money, and they produce remakes because they think enough moviegoers are interested in seeing the remake for it to earn a profit for the film studio. Moviegoers are usually entertained rather than killed by remakes.
Why are older songs and albums being remastered so frequently?
- Remastering music improves the quality of the original copy of a song or album. The process aims to remove flaws from the music, to provide a cleaner, sharper, and more refined listening experience in line with modern audio standards.
What are the core benefits of remastering audio?
- Most works are remastered to keep up with the latest audio formats. This helps bring the sound into the modern experience as opposed to sounding flat, old, or out of date.
Why is it called remastered?
- Remastering music improves the quality of the original copy of a song or album. The process aims to remove flaws from the music, to provide a cleaner, sharper, and more refined listening experience in line with modern audio standards.
Are remasters always worth the investment?
- It’s different for each game. Some remasters are absolutely amazing, some of them are alright, and some of them are hardly any better than the original, while on rare occasions some remasters can actually be worse than the original game. It all depends on who it is that’s doing the remaster.
What kind of visual enhancements can one expect from a remastered movie?
- Remastering often means scanning the film at current high resolution, so it almost always looks better. Technology has changed so much in the last 20 years that even silent films look fantastic when remastered.
Do you get penalized if a teammate initiates a “remake” in a game?
- No, you can /remake without penalty in normal games if someone in your premade disconnects. Note that if you’re the inactive player, you’ll still receive normal penalties—the game will count as a loss, and you’ll be flagged by LeaverBuster.
Is a remake simply a remaster with a new title?
- If a remaster is a mostly graphical overhaul, then a remake is when developers get under a game’s hood to make significant changes. These games are remade from the ground up, sometimes down to the original source code.
Does initiating a “remake” in a game result in a loss of League Points (LP)?
- But unlike forfeits, remakes don’t count as a loss. Instead, no changes in your LP/Blue Essence or XP will occur and will only mark that particular match as a remake. However, this isn’t going to be the case for the inactive player/s, and Diamond IV and above players in their premade.