Is it possible to save both Ashley and Josh?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The answer to the question Is it possible to save both Ashley and Josh? is no, as the game’s storyline is designed in a way that Josh’s fate is sealed, and Ashley’s survival depends on the player’s choices, but saving both is not an option in the traditional sense, although there are some nuances to this answer that will be explored in the FAQs below. The game Until Dawn is known for its branching storyline and multiple endings, but when it comes to Ashley and Josh, the player’s choices have significant consequences that ultimately lead to a fixed outcome for Josh and a variable outcome for Ashley.
Understanding the Game’s Mechanics
To understand why it’s not possible to save both Ashley and Josh, it’s essential to delve into the game’s mechanics and storyline, which will be explored in the following FAQs.
FAQs
1. What happens if you don’t choose Ashley or Josh?
If you don’t make a choice, the saw kills Josh, that is the only result, and the resulting dialogue will be as if you chose Ashley, instead of if Chris picked to save Josh and noticed that the trap didn’t work as intended.
2. What happens if Chris chooses to save Josh in Until Dawn?
Even if Chris decides to save Josh, the saw blade will always turn on to Josh’s track, causing him to be murdered, and he will untie Ashley, and the two will start to panic.
3. Is it better to save Josh or Ashley?
Josh dies either way, as the saw blade is designed to kill him, and Ashley’s survival depends on the player’s subsequent choices.
4. Can you save both twins in Until Dawn?
No, you can’t change the fate of Hannah and Beth, as their death is a fixed event that sets up the main story of the game.
5. What happens if you shoot Chris instead of Ashley?
Regardless of who you decide to shoot (or not shoot), the result will end up the same in the next chapter.
6. Why does Josh turn into a Wendigo?
Josh becomes a Wendigo by eating human flesh, which is a key event in the game’s storyline.
7. Can you stop Josh becoming a Wendigo in Until Dawn?
“Saving” Josh ends with him turning into a Wendigo, and to get this ending, Sam and Mike have to find Hannah’s journal in the mines near the end.
8. Is Josh schizophrenic in Until Dawn?
Josh appears to have psychosis, which was caused by depression, and schizophrenia, a mental illness characterized by a disconnection from reality.
9. What happens if Mike doesn’t cut his fingers off?
If Mike interacts with a moving arm, his fingers will get caught in a bear trap, where then, Mike can use the machete to either cut off his fingers or open the bear trap.
10. Can we save Hannah in Until Dawn?
No, regardless of what happens, Hannah will always die in the final explosion.
11. What happens if Ashley investigates the voice in Until Dawn?
If Ashley goes to investigate the voice she assumes is Jessica’s, and opens the trapdoor or unlocks its latch, a Wendigo will pop out and decapitate her.
12. Is it possible to save Ashley?
Yes, it is possible to save Ashley if the player makes the correct choices, such as not opening the trapdoor or abandoning it.
13. What happens if you sacrifice Ashley?
You lose a Soldier if you sacrifice Ashley, and the consequences of this choice will be felt throughout the game.
14. Should Mike shoot Emily?
Shooting Emily dead will unlock the “Exorcism Of Emily” Bronze Trophy, while sparing her life will unlock the “Let eM In” Bronze Trophy instead.
15. Can Josh not turn into a Wendigo?
No, Josh becomes a Wendigo by eating human flesh, and there is no way to prevent this from happening, as it is a key event in the game’s storyline.