Lies of P vs. Nioh 2: Which Souls-like Reigns Supreme in Difficulty?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question on the minds of many Souls-like enthusiasts is: Is Lies of P harder than Nioh 2? The short answer, though nuanced, is generally yes, Lies of P presents a more consistently challenging experience than Nioh 2 for most players. While both games are notorious for their difficulty, they achieve it in different ways. Lies of P emphasizes tight, precise parrying, and aggressive enemy design that leaves little room for error. Nioh 2, on the other hand, throws complex combat systems, overwhelming enemy numbers, and intricate gear customization at the player. This distinction in design philosophy makes comparing their difficulty not as straightforward as it seems.
Lies of P is often cited as being on par with, or even exceeding, the challenge of FromSoftware’s most difficult titles, such as Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice. Its focus on the perfect block mechanic and fast, relentless bosses requires a very specific skill set. Failing to master the parry will result in frequent, brutal deaths. The game punishes passive play and forces players to engage aggressively, making it incredibly demanding.
In contrast, Nioh 2‘s difficulty stems from its sheer volume of systems and customizable elements. Players are constantly juggling stances, active skills, Soul Cores, and a vast array of gear. While the bosses are formidable, the most challenging aspects of Nioh 2 often come from navigating complex levels filled with hordes of enemies, and managing the game’s many mechanics. Nioh 2 also offers options for player builds that allow them to overcome certain challenges, which can make it feel less consistently punishing. Although it takes time, many players find a groove and are able to become increasingly powerful.
The challenge each game poses is therefore fundamentally different. Lies of P is an exercise in precise combat and pattern recognition, while Nioh 2 is about mastering complex systems and adapting to overwhelming situations. In a direct comparison, a player who may find Nioh 2 manageable can easily be caught off guard and decimated by the unforgiving parry requirements in Lies of P.
Therefore, while both are incredibly challenging games, Lies of P leans towards being consistently more difficult due to its reliance on demanding combat mechanics and aggressive boss encounters. Nioh 2 has a higher skill ceiling due to the depth of its systems, but it is arguably more forgiving once these systems are mastered.
Deeper Dive: Why the Perception of Difficulty Differs
Lies of P: A Test of Precision
The core of Lies of P‘s difficulty lies in its combat mechanics, particularly the perfect guard. It’s a far cry from the dodge-heavy gameplay of other Souls-likes, like the Dark Souls series or Elden Ring. The timing window for a perfect parry is tight, and failing to execute it results in significant damage. Many enemies and bosses relentlessly pursue the player, making passive dodging less effective than actively engaging with the perfect guard.
The boss fights in Lies of P are a standout experience. They are designed to punish players for predictable behaviour. The bosses are aggressive, fast, and often come with multiple phases, each more demanding than the last. The Nameless Puppet, the secret final boss, is frequently cited as one of the toughest challenges, requiring players to master the parry system to stand a chance. The difficulty spikes in Lies of P are more pronounced and less forgiving than the ones seen in Nioh 2.
Nioh 2: Overwhelming Systems and Complex Encounters
Nioh 2’s difficulty comes from a different angle. It isn’t just about precise parrying or dodging. Instead, it’s about navigating a complex web of character customization, skills, and gear. Players must manage three distinct stances, a vast arsenal of weapons, a complex Ki management system, and Soul Cores, among other mechanics. This requires significant investment of time to truly understand and master.
Enemy encounters in Nioh 2 are often overwhelming in their numbers. Players frequently find themselves facing multiple enemies at once, with several ranged attackers raining down projectiles from afar. This requires more of a strategic approach and careful engagement, compared to the more one-on-one nature of most Lies of P boss fights.
Furthermore, the loot system in Nioh 2 can be a double-edged sword. The sheer amount of gear available can be overwhelming, but finding the right combination can significantly alter your power. This leads to players having access to a very wide range of builds that are capable of very powerful damage.
Conclusion
While both games are challenging in their own rights, Lies of P generally presents a higher barrier of entry and a more consistently brutal experience, due to its focus on perfect parries and unforgiving boss design. Nioh 2, with its complex systems, offers a different, albeit still very demanding kind of difficulty. Both games offer satisfying challenges that will test the skill of any gamer, but Lies of P is the harsher experience overall.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is Lies of P harder than Dark Souls 3?
Many players find Lies of P harder than Dark Souls 3 due to its emphasis on perfect guarding. While Dark Souls 3 allows for more versatility in combat strategies, Lies of P forces a more rigid and precision-based approach.
2. Is Lies of P more similar to Bloodborne or Sekiro?
Lies of P is often compared to both. Like Bloodborne, it has a gothic setting and aggressive enemies, but the combat is more reliant on parrying like Sekiro. Overall, most people agree the game is closer to Sekiro.
3. Is Lies of P a true “Souls-like” game?
Yes, Lies of P is undoubtedly a Soulslike game. It incorporates many of the core elements of the genre, such as challenging combat, interconnected levels, and a dark atmosphere, all inspired by the original souls games.
4. Why is the Nameless Puppet so difficult in Lies of P?
The Nameless Puppet is the secret final boss and arguably the hardest fight due to its relentless aggression, fast attacks, and varied patterns. It requires players to master the parry system to stand a chance.
5. Is it okay to play Nioh 2 without playing Nioh 1?
Yes, absolutely. Nioh 2 is actually a prequel, so understanding the story doesn’t require playing the first game. Both games are excellent, but can be enjoyed separately.
6. What makes Nioh 2 so complicated?
Nioh 2 is complex due to its vast array of systems, including stances, active skills, Soul Cores, and gear customization. Mastering these systems takes time and effort, making the game feel overwhelming at first.
7. How linear is Lies of P compared to other Souls-likes?
Lies of P is quite linear compared to other Souls-likes. It lacks the expansive interconnected world seen in games like Elden Ring, with progression being largely through narrow paths.
8. How many hours of gameplay does Lies of P offer?
A standard playthrough of Lies of P focusing on the main objectives takes about 29 ½ hours. Completing everything could reach 58 hours or more for a full 100% completion.
9. Is Nioh 2 better than Sekiro?
It depends on personal preference. Nioh 2 offers extensive loot and build customization, while Sekiro focuses on refined parrying-based combat. Both are excellent games, but cater to different player tastes.
10. Is Elden Ring easier than Lies of P?
Yes, most players find Elden Ring to be significantly easier than Lies of P. Elden Ring allows for more build variety and exploration, making it more forgiving than Lies of P’s demanding combat.
11. Does Lies of P have a good story?
Yes, Lies of P features a compelling narrative inspired by Pinocchio. It explores dark themes and moral choices, adding depth to the gameplay experience.
12. What is the primary combat focus of Lies of P?
The primary combat focus of Lies of P is on perfect blocking or parrying. It’s a more rigid mechanic compared to rolling, dodging, or guarding.
13. What makes Nioh 2 enjoyable?
Nioh 2 is enjoyed for its extensive loot system, deep combat mechanics, and challenging encounters. Players enjoy the ability to heavily customise and create unique and powerful builds.
14. Is Lies of P underrated?
Some critics believe Lies of P is underrated, arguing it is one of the finest Souls-like games and excels in combat design. Its difficulty may be contributing to its lack of widespread mainstream appeal.
15. Is the parry in Elden Ring hard to master?
Yes, the parry in Elden Ring is considered difficult by many due to its tight timing window. Success requires a good understanding of enemy attack animations and precise execution.