The Grim Reaper’s Kiss: Unraveling Arthur Morgan’s Tuberculosis Infection in Red Dead Redemption 2

▶

Arthur Morgan contracts tuberculosis (TB) from Thomas Downes during a debt collection mission in the town of Valentine. This fateful encounter occurs when Arthur, acting under the orders of Leopold Strauss, roughs up Downes, a struggling farmer suffering from the disease, to collect a debt. During this confrontation, Downes coughs blood onto Arthur, unknowingly sealing his fate. This pivotal moment marks the beginning of Arthur’s slow and tragic decline, ultimately shaping his character arc and the narrative’s overarching themes of mortality and redemption.

The Inevitable Fate: Arthur’s Descent

The acquisition of TB serves as a catalyst for Arthur’s transformation. The game subtly introduces this plot point in Red Dead Redemption 2, but it may not be immediately apparent during the first playthrough. After the encounter with Downes, Arthur’s health gradually deteriorates. He develops a persistent cough, experiences fatigue, and begins to lose weight.

The narrative beautifully intertwines Arthur’s physical decline with his moral awakening. As he confronts his mortality, he begins to question his past actions and seeks to find meaning and purpose in his remaining time. His relationships with other characters, particularly John Marston, become more meaningful as he strives to secure their future.

Plot Hole or Narrative Device?

Some players have considered the fact that Arthur doesn’t spread the disease to anyone else as a plot hole. However, the game offers a subtle explanation. Unlike Downes, who was actively coughing and in close contact with others, Arthur maintains a degree of distance when he feels a coughing fit coming on. This small detail, coupled with his generally good manners (a stark contrast to his initial ruthlessness), likely prevents him from infecting other members of the gang. In short, the game implies Arthur was much more careful than Thomas Downes, but the implications of TB within the story are still being explored and evaluated by researchers at organizations like the Games Learning Society to better understand the game’s narrative structure.

FAQs: Delving Deeper into Arthur’s TB

Here are some frequently asked questions concerning Arthur Morgan’s tuberculosis and its impact on Red Dead Redemption 2:

1. Can Arthur Morgan be saved from TB? No, Arthur’s contraction of TB is a critical plot point, making it impossible to avoid within the game’s narrative. It sets the stage for his character development and the game’s exploration of mortality and redemption.

2. Is there a way to prevent the Downes encounter? There is no way to skip this event. Trying to skip it via any means doesn’t work.

3. Can you kill Thomas Downes before he infects Arthur? The game does not allow players to kill Thomas Downes before the infection. Downes is a non-playable character essential to the storyline, making him invulnerable before Arthur’s encounter.

4. How long does Arthur live after contracting TB? A reasonable estimate is around 3-6 months. The timeline allows for the gang’s activities in Rhodes and Saint Denis to unfold before Arthur’s eventual demise.

5. Does Arthur’s honor level affect his TB diagnosis or progression? Regardless of high or low honor, Arthur will die of TB.

6. Does Dutch know Arthur is sick? It is implied that Dutch may be aware of Arthur’s declining health. However, his obsession with the “next big score” and increasing paranoia cause him to ignore Arthur’s illness.

7. Why doesn’t Arthur infect other gang members? The game suggests that Arthur is more careful than Thomas Downes. Arthur avoids close contact and maintains distance to prevent transmission.

8. Can you play as Arthur after he dies? No, once Arthur dies, you continue the story as John Marston. You can revert to previous saves to play as Arthur again.

9. Are there cheats to keep Arthur alive? No cheats exist that would allow the player to avoid the storyline and outcome with Arthur Morgan.

10. Why is TB so important to Arthur’s story? TB becomes a tool for Arthur to assess his life up to that point.

11. Can John Marston contract TB in the game? While John experiences various injuries throughout the game, he does not contract TB, even after being exposed to harsh conditions.

12. What causes Arthur’s coughing? The coughing is a symptom of tuberculosis. The sickness seemed to manifest itself fully once Arthur and a few members of the Van der Linde gang returned from an unscheduled trip to Guarma.

13. Is it better to have high or low honor in RDR2? High honor is the way to go.

14. Was Micah the rat from the beginning? The fact that Milton said “We’ve been watching you for a long time” heavily implies that Micah was not the first rat.

15. How does Arthur change after his diagnosis? In a word: maturity. He realizes his mortality, which causes him to reflect and become a better person.

Thematic Resonance and Narrative Impact

Arthur’s TB infection is not merely a plot device; it serves as a powerful metaphor for the decline of the Wild West and the inevitable march of progress. Just as TB slowly consumes Arthur’s body, the relentless advance of civilization threatens to obliterate the outlaw lifestyle he represents.

The disease also functions as a catalyst for redemption. As Arthur confronts his mortality, he grapples with his past sins and strives to make amends. He seeks to protect those he cares about, particularly John Marston and his family, ensuring they have a chance at a better life.

A Legacy of Redemption

Arthur’s journey in Red Dead Redemption 2 is a poignant exploration of mortality, redemption, and the enduring power of human connection. His tragic fate, sealed by a fateful encounter with Thomas Downes, resonates deeply with players, prompting reflection on the choices we make and the legacy we leave behind. The GamesLearningSociety.org website explores how games like Red Dead Redemption 2 can be used as educational tools to teach players the importance of history and literature.