Table of Contents

How Many Times Can You Reroll a Dice?

Quick answer

This page answers How many times can you reroll a dice? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

The seemingly simple act of rerolling a die opens up a rabbit hole of nuanced rules and strategic implications across various games. The direct answer to how many times you can reroll a dice is: it depends entirely on the game and the specific rules governing the reroll ability. There is no universal, across-the-board answer. Some games might allow for unlimited rerolls under certain conditions, while others restrict rerolls to a single instance. Let’s dive deep into this fascinating topic!

Understanding the Basics of Rerolls

Rerolling a die is a common mechanic in many tabletop games, wargames, and even some video games. It’s a second chance, an opportunity to mitigate bad luck or capitalize on a strategic advantage. However, the implementation of rerolls varies greatly. To understand how many times you can reroll, you need to consider several factors:

The Game System: Different games have different rules. What applies in Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) won’t necessarily apply in Warhammer 40,000 or Monopoly Go.
The Specific Ability or Rule: Rerolls are usually granted by a specific ability, spell, item, or rule. These will often contain limitations on their usage.
Stacking Rerolls: Can multiple reroll abilities be used on the same die roll? This is a key question and often the source of confusion.
Restrictions and Limitations: Many reroll abilities come with limitations such as requiring you to accept the second result or only allowing rerolls on specific die results.

Common Reroll Limitations

Most games implement some form of limitation on rerolls to prevent them from becoming overpowered or disrupting game balance. Here are some of the most common restrictions:

Single Reroll: This is perhaps the most common limitation. The rule explicitly states that you can only reroll the die once.
Mandatory Acceptance: You must accept the result of the reroll, even if it’s worse than the original. This adds an element of risk to the reroll.
Specific Trigger: The reroll might only be triggered by a specific die result, such as rolling a 1 or failing a particular check.
Limited Uses per Turn/Game: Some abilities can only be used a certain number of times per turn, game, or even session.
Once per Die: If you’re rolling multiple dice, the rule might specify that you can only reroll each individual die once.
Pre-Modifier Rerolls: Rerolls often happen before any modifiers are applied. This is important to keep in mind when strategizing.
Choice of Result: Some abilities allow you to choose between the original result and the reroll, giving you more control.

Rerolls in Specific Games: Examples

Let’s look at how rerolls work in a few popular games to illustrate the point:

Dungeons & Dragons (D&D): While there isn’t a universal reroll rule in D&D, features that grant rerolls, like the Lucky feat, typically have limitations. The Lucky feat, for instance, allows you to reroll an attack roll, ability check, or saving throw, but you must choose which roll to use. It’s a limited resource (uses replenish on a long rest) and can only be applied to a specific roll once.
Warhammer 40,000: In Warhammer 40,000, rerolls are common but highly controlled. Certain units or abilities allow you to reroll hit rolls, wound rolls, or saving throws. However, the rules often specify exactly what can be rerolled and the number of times it can be done. Strategic Command Points are often used to enable rerolls.
Monopoly Go: Rerolls in Monopoly Go sometimes involve glitches or exploits, but the mechanics of such exploits are separate from the game’s original rules.

Probability and Rerolls: A Numbers Game

Rerolling a die significantly impacts the probability of certain outcomes. For example, if you need a 4 or higher on a six-sided die to succeed, your initial probability is 50%. If you get to reroll a failed roll, the probability of success increases dramatically.

Let’s say you roll a 1, 2, or 3 (failure). You now have a second chance. The probability of rolling a 4, 5, or 6 on the reroll is also 50%. Therefore, the overall probability of success becomes more than 50% when a reroll is allowed. The extract states that assuming an average roll, 66% of the dice will be a success.

The exact increase in probability depends on the number of sides on the die and the target number you need to achieve.

Stacking Rerolls: A Complex Issue

The question of whether reroll abilities “stack” is a crucial one. Generally, if you have multiple sources of rerolls, only one applies. Games are usually designed to avoid endless reroll loops. Most often, the rules will state that you can only apply one reroll to a given die roll, regardless of how many abilities grant you the option.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Dice Rerolls

Here are some frequently asked questions related to the topic of dice rerolls:

What happens if I have two abilities that let me reroll the same die? Usually, you only get to use one of those reroll abilities. Most game rules are designed to prevent stacking of reroll effects. Pick the ability that gives you the best chance of success or has the fewest restrictions.
Do I have to accept the second roll when I reroll a die? It depends on the specific ability or rule. Some rerolls require you to accept the second result, while others allow you to choose between the original roll and the reroll.
Can I reroll a reroll? In most cases, no. Reroll abilities are typically limited to a single application per die roll unless a specific rule states otherwise.
Do rerolls happen before or after modifiers are applied? Rerolls usually happen before any modifiers are applied to the roll. This is a critical point to remember when planning your strategy. The provided text confirms that rerolls happen before modifiers.
If I have advantage (roll two dice and pick the higher), can I reroll one of the dice? Again, this depends on the specific rules of the game and the nature of the reroll ability. Some abilities might allow you to reroll one of the dice rolled with advantage, while others might not.
Does rolling a 1 always mean automatic failure, even if I have a reroll? No, not necessarily. In D&D, rolling a 1 on an attack roll is an automatic miss, but if you have a reroll ability, you can use it to try to change the outcome.
What’s the rarest dice roll possible? When rolling two standard six-sided dice, the rarest rolls are 2 and 12, each with a probability of 1/36.
Can I cheat when rolling dice to get a better outcome? While there are methods to manipulate dice rolls, cheating is generally frowned upon and can ruin the fun for everyone involved. The article mentions a simple method of altering a roll by quickly knocking over dice that come up with a 1.
What is the average result of a die roll with a reroll? Rerolling a die will, on average, result in the reroll being 4.5.
How do rerolls affect the overall probability of success? Rerolls significantly increase your chances of success, especially when the original probability is low. The exact increase depends on the number of sides on the die and the target number you need to achieve.
Are rerolls considered modified rolls? A: Rerolls always happen before modifiers, so the re-roll ability is triggered before applying modifiers.
What is the most common dice rolled in D&D? The most popular type of d&d die is the six-sided die, which is used to determine the winner of most activities.
Can I use a Miracle dice on a reroll? Miracle dice cannot be changed or re-rolled, unless a rule specifically states otherwise.
Can I manipulate dice rolls? It is possible for an average player to learn how to control the dice, but it isn’t easy. Unlike advantage play in blackjack, dice control is a physical skill rather than a purely mental talent.
What are cheating dice called? Cheating dice are called loaded dice (called tappers, missouts, passers, floppers, cappers, or spot loaders, depending on how and where extra weight has been applied).

Conclusion

The number of times you can reroll a die is dictated by the specific rules of the game you’re playing and the abilities you’re using. Always carefully read the rules and understand the limitations before attempting a reroll. Understanding these rules and probabilities adds a layer of strategic depth to games, and the Games Learning Society ( GamesLearningSociety.org ) is an excellent resource for exploring the educational aspects of gaming and learning. Knowing when and how to use a reroll can be the difference between victory and defeat!